Live data from Hacker News

Having no experience can be better than having the wrong experience

twitter.com

211–215 of 215 posts

Re: Having no experience can be better than having the wrong experience

#211
post #29

I work for a non-tech company as a solo full stack dev. I have been able to interview with fortune 500 companies and get offers. I have been getting contacted by recruiters from hot startups, Microsoft, Google, AWS, Amazon and Meta. I am not sure if I'm stupid but I really don't know how "no experience" can be better than wrong experience. There is always things you learn, better negotiation tactics, your value to a…

> I work for a non-tech company as a solo full stack dev.

If you don't mind me asking, how did you come across this sort of a job? I don't suppose there's a job board for non-tech companies looking to hire a solo full stack dev? :)

Re: Having no experience can be better than having the wrong experience

#212

Earlier quoted context omitted.

"Wrong kind of experience is worse than no experience" is an interesting concept. It implies that the people thinking like this think that people aren't mutable. With no experience, you're a tabula rasa, but once you've been carved, that's it, fixed in stone. Which may be true for some people, but I'm fairly certain that humans are known for their adaptability, their willingness to learn. At least that's why they get…

> With no experience, you're a tabula rasa, but once you've been carved, that's it, fixed in stone. I mean, if you work in a company/team with bad practices, then that's likely to rub off onto you and affect your further employment prospects, because it will be hard to unlearn being okay with untestable code, no documentation and even the code itself not being self-documenting where possible, the code being not scala…

It can also happen that the person learns "this doesn't work well, this also doesn't, this too -- I wish we were doing everything differently!"

And later, when joining a better company, s/he more deeply understands the reasons behind their good practices -- because s/he has seen the mess, without.

Having seen and lived in mistakes, is life experience, can be useful. Depends on the person

Re: Having no experience can be better than having the wrong experience

#213

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> With no experience, you're a tabula rasa, but once you've been carved, that's it, fixed in stone. I mean, if you work in a company/team with bad practices, then that's likely to rub off onto you and affect your further employment prospects, because it will be hard to unlearn being okay with untestable code, no documentation and even the code itself not being self-documenting where possible, the code being not scala…

It can also happen that the person learns "this doesn't work well, this also doesn't, this too -- I wish we were doing everything differently!" And later, when joining a better company, s/he more deeply understands the reasons behind their good practices -- because s/he has seen the mess, without. Having seen and lived in mistakes, is life experience, can be useful. Depends on the person

> And later, when joining a better company, s/he more deeply understands the reasons behind their good practices -- because s/he has seen the mess, without.

There are two assumptions here:

  1. that the person will be accepted into that better company, even with these pre-existing sub-optimal practices which may manifest in a coding interview or a take-home task
  2. that the person will be open to learning these better practices, instead of being set in their ways, after having had their first experiences shape their views without the desire to challenge them
I agree that there is definitely potential for growth, but in some respects, for certain individuals such pre-existing views might be a liability. Though that also speaks of one's quality as an engineer, of course.

Re: Having no experience can be better than having the wrong experience

#214
post #29

I work for a non-tech company as a solo full stack dev. I have been able to interview with fortune 500 companies and get offers. I have been getting contacted by recruiters from hot startups, Microsoft, Google, AWS, Amazon and Meta. I am not sure if I'm stupid but I really don't know how "no experience" can be better than wrong experience. There is always things you learn, better negotiation tactics, your value to a…

> I work for a non-tech company as a solo full stack dev. If you don't mind me asking, how did you come across this sort of a job? I don't suppose there's a job board for non-tech companies looking to hire a solo full stack dev? :)

I met an older guy in a CS class. We did a project together and became school buddies. Before graduating I wanted to intern somewhere where I would get a lot of freedom. He was high up in a business and decided to offer me an internship.

I did a couple small projects to solve problems they were having. They were successful. I'm now pretty important to the business. I know databases of the ERP system, I have a lot of trust and basically am above the HR and have complete freedom.

When I interview no company is willing to offer the flexibility they do. So, honestly I'm not even sure how one would go about finding a gig like this.

Re: Having no experience can be better than having the wrong experience

#215
post #117

Earlier quoted context omitted.

What I see happen though is people get downleveled. It’s hard to get senior at FAANG without big tech experience, let alone staff+. So if you spend your career somewhere else and try to switch to FAANG after, say, 10 years, you’ll end up getting down leveled. Now, you’re probably making more money, so maybe this doesn’t matter.

I went from CTO to SDE II, and it totally made sense. There's nothing wrong with being downleveled if you are playing a different scale game. There is a huge difference being a senior engineer working on a $5,000 system versus a $1,000,000,000 system.

Yeah, similar story for me. "Senior engineer" at failed startup into Founder/CTO at other failed startup. Then L3 at Snap into L4 at G. No hard feelings whatsoever. We're all moving pixels and pushing buttons for money, I try not to get too caught up in the promo game; much more interesting stuff in life outside the screen.
Post reply on HN