Live data from Hacker News

Show HN: Bionic Reading – Formats text to make it faster to read

bionic-reading.com

211–220 of 281 posts

Re: Show HN: Bionic Reading – Formats text to make it faster to read

#211

I am very glad that Bionic Reading is being discussed in HN. I am aware that it cannot help everyone. But I also get a lot of feedback from people who are helped a lot by this reading mode. Imagine you have problems with reading. You don't realize what a huge hurdle that is until you talk to people who are affected. Being ashamed in front of society. The problem of learning new things. Being called stupid. And these…

Nice work!

This would be an awesome enhancement to Pocket- which already extracts web page texts into a lighter format - I'd probably read everything through that

Re: Show HN: Bionic Reading – Formats text to make it faster to read

#212

I found this to be an unbelievable improvement in reading for me. It was automatic and effortless. I cannot believe how much faster that helped me to read without sacrificing on comprehension. Unreal. Reading the non-bionic (?) text on the website suddenly felt like a sluggish chore, and for the first time I am realizing that I am actively using not insignificant amounts of energy to mentally parse text.

Hi sweetheart I am very happy about that. Nice that you get the “reading pull” and thereby gain the benefits. Best regards from the Alps, Renato

Re: Show HN: Bionic Reading – Formats text to make it faster to read

#213

Cool, here's a quick hack to try a similar technique with the comments in this thread (copy and paste into dev tools: $$('span.commtext').forEach(span => { const frag = document.createDocumentFragment(); span.textContent.split(/\s+/).forEach(word => { const len = Math.ceil(word.length * 0.3); const leading = document.createElement('strong'); leading.textContent = word.slice(0, len); const trailing = document.createTe…

I made a version which works in all web pages, it is still very hacky though: function bionifyPage(){ function bionifyWord(word) { if (word.length == 1) { return word; } var numBold = Math.ceil(word.length * 0.3); // return " " + word.slice(0, numBold) + " " + + " " + word.slice(numBold) + " "; return " " + word.slice(0, numBold) + " " + " " + word.slice(numBold) + " "; } function bionifyText(text) { var res = ""; if…

Could you make one that reduces the opacity of the second half of the word, while keeping the same boldness for the complete text, to compare the effect?

Re: Show HN: Bionic Reading – Formats text to make it faster to read

#214

The rules implemented are very simple (taken from the patent application [1], the exact numbers are configurable). If there are 4 letters, 40% of all letters are bold. There is this claim as the first text on the website: We are happy if as many people as possible can use the advantage of Bionic Reading. For this reason, Bionic Reading should be able to be integrated into existing apps and services. The benefit for t…

No post body was provided.

Re: Show HN: Bionic Reading – Formats text to make it faster to read

#215
post #118

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The opposite is true, in fact - a patent is a monopoly on the patented technology, no matter where alternative implementations come from. You might be thinking of “clean room” techniques which protect against claims of copyright infringement.

> You might be thinking of “clean room” techniques which protect against claims of copyright infringement. Ah yes, that's what I was thinking of -- thanks. Specifically a scene from an episode of Halt and Catch Fire (I won't describe it due to spoilers). That's a real bummer for patents though and makes me wonder how something like Amazon's 1-click checkout was able to be patented. I wonder how "save billing details…

I believe those scenes were an amalgamation of Tim Paterson’s clean room implementation of DOS from the CP/M manuals [0] and Compaq’s IBM compatible BIOS implementation[1].

They are a some of my favorites, and are fun to watch.

[0] https://dfarq.homeip.net/did-microsoft-steal-dos-from-cpm/

[1] https://dfarq.homeip.net/first-compaq-computer/

Re: Show HN: Bionic Reading – Formats text to make it faster to read

#216
post #195

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It’s just an emoji, not a Memoji ( https://emojipedia.org/man-wearing-turban-medium-dark-skin-t... ) It’s probably a review written by somebody with a brown skin tone. Page authors don’t know the social intricacies of what constitutes Sikhs and chose this one as “close enough”.

There’s probably some sort of important lesson here…

Maybe, but Sangeeth is not here to tell us if they are Sikh or not, so it's hard to say.

I think it's unfortunate that (at the time of writing) the comments about the product and its effectiveness are ranked lower than this discussion about the _possibility_ that a non-Sikh person has been represented as Sikh.

If Sangeeth themselves had popped up in this thread to comment on the choice of emoji, then sure, but it's just somebody making some assumptions based on a 't' vs 'th' cluster in the name.

Re: Show HN: Bionic Reading – Formats text to make it faster to read

#217

> Bionic reading aims to encourage a more in-depth reading and understanding of written content by reading faster? I mean the examples are pretty compelling and it did feel like I was reading faster, but at the same time their goals are at odds - faster reading doesn't necessarily mean more attentive reading, or being able to absorb more information. Still, interesting technique. I just wish they made their examples…

As another comment said, this would be good for those with short attention spans or those with reading disabilities like dislexia to focus better. I would want to see an epub renderer so I can read ebooks with this method.

Re: Show HN: Bionic Reading – Formats text to make it faster to read

#218
I’ve used both Bionic Reading while on Reeder, and the Open Dyslexic font while on Kindle, for several years to similar effect.

My personal finding is that it makes the work my eyes need to do to keep on the line, and move from line to line easier.

But I will note that the largest increase in reading speed for me, up to 800 words per minute, came from single word focusing. There are tools, such as speed reader mode in Emacs, or an old browser extension called Squid, that take the readable text and put it all on one line, then move the text through a window that stays fixed on the screen.

By training yourself to relax and not read the words aloud, I was able to increase my reading speed from around 200 wpm to over 800 wpm. The trick is to slowly ramp up the speed, and not just jump up to the fastest speed possible. It’s also important to remember to blink.

Alternatively, text to speech works for to in a similar way, and I’ve found that I can handle 2.5x - 3.5x speeds after a few hours of training. As a bonus, nobody else can decider what you’re listening to, and you get some funny looks.

Let me know if others have found similar techniques to work for them.

Re: Show HN: Bionic Reading – Formats text to make it faster to read

#220

This presumes you're scanning lines but if you really want to speed read you should scan whole blocks of text as you draw the eye down, there should be little to no horizontal movement when you're really reading fast. - - - - An interesting and effective method of speed reading is Rapid Serial Visual Presentation (RSVP). These days it's mostly used in the context of psychological/perception studies, but it came about…

> There's an interesting effect where you can take some text and, for each word longer than ~5 letters [...]

I think you're referring to this (dubbed "Typoglycemia"):

> Aoccdrnig to rscheearch at Cmabrigde uinervtisy, it deosn't mttaer waht oredr the ltteers in a wrod are [...]

It's sort of true (although there was never any research at Cambridge that anyone has been able to unearth), but it's way more limited that "any word longer than 5 characters". This is a good explanation of it (arbitrary link found after a search):

https://www.sciencealert.com/word-jumble-meme-first-last-let...

People seem to want it to be universally true, though. It's for sure an interesting phenomenon (and meta-phenomenon).

Post reply on HN