Live data from Hacker News

Twitter starts to require login to view tweets

reddit.com

211–220 of 643 posts

Re: Twitter starts to require login to view tweets

#211

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I'm using old.reddit.com, and it's ok. Shame if they would turn that off though.

There's a Chrome extension for redirecting to old.reddit.com: https://chrome.google.com/webstore/detail/old-reddit-redirec...

You can just uncheck "Use new Reddit as my default experience" in settings and get the old experience without an extension, if you have an account anyway.

Re: Twitter starts to require login to view tweets

#212

Im just curious, what are the motivations for a company to make this move? It seems like a death sentence to me but I cant think of any examples off-hand.

I am thinking that Twitter has reached saturation for the most part. Pretty much everyone has heard of it and has an opinion about it. The areas of the world that do have an untapped audience also have authoritarian regimes that do not like Twitter very much.

At the same time, there is some manager with a spreadsheet that has new account creation metrics. S/he wants that number to be as high as possible. How do you do that if people do not actually want to make an account? Try capturing the people who usually click in from other sites and bounce back.

I think the end result will be that social media somehow becomes even more pictures of text than previously.

Re: Twitter starts to require login to view tweets

#213
post #201

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> A social network can only pick two. Reddit has all three (no need for email even), they might not be perfect but I can't remember any time I saw "viagra links" or other obvious spam. They have problems with accounts obviously, but you can't frame it as a spam problem.

I see a lot of spam on Reddit. That does nothing to speak of “auto moderator”, fragmented rules/guidelines and ilk and the sheer effort involved by volunteers. Even then: the spam gets through. But I agree that PII is not solving this.

>I see a lot of spam on Reddit.

Where? I've seens a couple of ghost subreddits with spam, but then you see the same with ghost fb groups, weird twitter profiles, youtube, etc On even moderately sized subs I've seen any that wasn't removed quickly by the mods.

People can say mods are too expensive for fb and twitter, but there is the dishonesty, instead of paying mods they pass on that cost to us with our pii while pretending it's free.

Re: Twitter starts to require login to view tweets

#214
post #80

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Of course, in order to help out the unfortunate website operators, people should willingly give up pii that the same companies have shown they don’t give a damn about protecting. /s

"For your protection." The most abused and dishonest phrase of the 21st century.

Also at top of the list: “We care about your privacy” (and not that we are required by law to give you these options that follow)

Re: Twitter starts to require login to view tweets

#215

As a shareholder--good. As a lazy Twitter reader--bad.

I don't have a Twitter account, and this now makes it far, far less likely that I will even click on a Twitter link or engage with the platform whatsoever.

I could obviously be in the minority (though I'm certainly not alone), but I'm curious if you think that my scenario will be the less common one and this will actually increase signups, or if it will have a positive impact on the stock price in another way.

Re: Twitter starts to require login to view tweets

#216
post #39

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Login is typically disabled for crawlers.

Which by Google's own T&Cs is illegal and could get your site dropped from their index... They state that you should not present a different site experience to their crawler compared to what normal users get. As usual it's OK for the big guys to break the rules whereas us little site owners have no choice but to obey them.

Don't they have an explicit exception for login screens on their T&C?

Re: Twitter starts to require login to view tweets

#218
post #196
post #84

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Which is not reassuring considering their past abuse of phone numbers provided for allegedly only security reasons. [0] [0] https://www.eff.org/deeplinks/2019/10/twitter-uninentionally...

It's worse: Twitter staff sold private user PII to the Saudi government (the one that assassinates journalists): https://www.buzzfeednews.com/article/alexkantrowitz/how-saud...

Remind me again, why did we leave IRC?

Re: Twitter starts to require login to view tweets

#219

So can people please quit posting twitter feeds finally? Some of us still have never used or signed up with twitter, or feel the need to, and really don't want to. Bad enough they removed non-javascript access, since they are permablocked through noscript here, I simply close postings on HN that link there and curse them for bothering. Asking for a login atop that is just a 4x non-starter for "news" links. Yes, some…

I think some people have misunderstood this change. It's been active for me for about a week, I suspect most others without accounts just haven't noticed.

Clicking on a linked tweet still works, it's only when you then click on another from within the site that it asks you for a login. It's the same approach Quora takes iirc.

Post reply on HN