Live data from Hacker News

Facebook Messenger, Instagram and WhatsApp Outage

developers.facebook.com

211–220 of 252 posts

Re: Facebook Messenger, Instagram and WhatsApp Outage

#211

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I can share to Signal or contacts-via-Signal, and have been for years... I think this is a you problem. Signal is honestly fantastic as a SMS-replacement app. It sends Signal messages to contacts with Signal and normal SMS to contacts without (Telegram might do the same thing, being able to set it as your default SMS app, I'm not sure).

In Brazil this is a GREAT reason to NOT use it. In fact phone operators for a while tried to ban whatsapp here, SMS prices in Brazil are just nuts (it is normal for an SMS cost fifty cents or so, sometimes even more, a full SMS conversation can cost you several days worth of food). Everyone here just uses whatsapp, because of how ridiculous SMS prices are.

I don't see why it would be a reason not to use it. Just don't set it as your default SMS app.

Re: Facebook Messenger, Instagram and WhatsApp Outage

#212
post #151
post #48

"But senators, we can't break up these three unrelated services because they all use the same messaging infrastructure!"

Ok, so instead of breaking you up into three companies, we'll break you up into 4. The fourth can own the messaging infrastructure and license it out to anyone interested. I can find a legal solution to your technical blockades. Be careful what you ask for.

This is fun to read but also implies that we have representatives competent enough to even understand things at this level. Maybe they don't have to understand it, I doubt they even consult someone who could help them understand this.

Re: Facebook Messenger, Instagram and WhatsApp Outage

#213

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I know Telegram is less secure and Secret Chats are an opt-in. Security-wise Signal would be better... but: Signal experience isn't that good. Alien from the platform they run on. For example, no system recommendations to send this person a message or share something with them through signal.. Telegram is more a platform native and integrated into the system. Also there is the issue of messages arriving late (not min…

On android, I see signal right next to all of the other messaging apps when sharing a photo or some other type of supported file.

Exactly. Signal appears in Android's share feature. I have a friend group on it where we send each other funny images and I never had any problems sharing to the group from Chrome or apps.

Re: Facebook Messenger, Instagram and WhatsApp Outage

#214

Earlier quoted context omitted.

wow... Haven't you heard about the Big Bang?

is that sarcasm? because I can play, but only if we confirm this is sarcasm

There are technical limits to how much sarcasm can be understood as such on the Internet.

Re: Facebook Messenger, Instagram and WhatsApp Outage

#215

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I can share to Signal or contacts-via-Signal, and have been for years... I think this is a you problem. Signal is honestly fantastic as a SMS-replacement app. It sends Signal messages to contacts with Signal and normal SMS to contacts without (Telegram might do the same thing, being able to set it as your default SMS app, I'm not sure).

In Brazil this is a GREAT reason to NOT use it. In fact phone operators for a while tried to ban whatsapp here, SMS prices in Brazil are just nuts (it is normal for an SMS cost fifty cents or so, sometimes even more, a full SMS conversation can cost you several days worth of food). Everyone here just uses whatsapp, because of how ridiculous SMS prices are.

It must be a market difference. Here in north america, SMS is the "default" way you message new contacts, and the majority of chats I have with people are over SMS. SMS is free and unlimited on virtually every phone plan available.

Re: Facebook Messenger, Instagram and WhatsApp Outage

#216
post #43

Quick, build a competitor

Good idea. We can also see which happens first: Facebook fixing its outage, or Facebook buying up that competitor.

Fix the outage, then blatantly copy the competitors' features and force it to their existing user base.

Re: Facebook Messenger, Instagram and WhatsApp Outage

#217
post #181

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> > Saying everything is so integrated that it can't possibly be decentralized is basically proof of monopoly. > This doesn't matter from the standard of antitrust law. What most fail to grasp is that being a monopoly is not illegal. It's only illegal to use monopoly power to harm consumer welfare. Citation needed? I thought, in the US at least, that the government will go after you if you use your monopoly powers to…

It depends on how the Justice department feels, to some extent. GM in the 50s and 60s actually kept an eye on their market share, and sometimes would kill/cutback projects or products that may have threatened going over a certain percentage (around 60%, IIRC.) At that time merely going over that number would have been enough to start an investigation. Some would argue though that back then DOJ 'cared' more.

If you're curious about how this changed, "Amazon's Antitrust Paradox" by Lina Khan article is a wonderful read: https://digitalcommons.law.yale.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?arti...

The summary is that the Chicago school of Economics promoted the idea that in a competitive market, predatory pricing is not possible. Thus, when you see an industry structure emerge (e.g. duopoly), you should assume that it is an efficient competitive outcome. After this, instead of focusing on market share percentages, antitrust authorities began to focus primarily on consumer harm (which is much more challenging to show in court e.g. for predatory pricing, you cannot only argue that your competitor has very low prices right now, you also have to prove that they intend to raise prices once they achieve monopoly power).

Re: Facebook Messenger, Instagram and WhatsApp Outage

#219
post #151

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Ok, so instead of breaking you up into three companies, we'll break you up into 4. The fourth can own the messaging infrastructure and license it out to anyone interested. I can find a legal solution to your technical blockades. Be careful what you ask for.

>I can find a legal solution to your technical blockades. Be careful what you ask for. legislative... senator.

I think he is referring to the Justice Department

Re: Facebook Messenger, Instagram and WhatsApp Outage

#220
post #19
post #15

Earlier quoted context omitted.

In Europe, Whatsapp is ubiquitous. FB Messenger and iMessage are pretty rare here. Edit: looks like I was wrong. I'm in the Netherlands. In the Netherlands and our neighbouring countries, Whatsapp is ubiquitous, so I presumed the rest of Europe was the same. I guess this proves that assumption is the mother of all failures.

Europe is very heterogeneous. I'm sure social network usage is very different in Lithuania, Bulgaria, Spain, Norway or the UK.

Viber is very used in some parts of Europe. More than WhatsApp.

Latin America is basically WhatsApp and nothing else.

Post reply on HN