Live data from Hacker News

Warren Buffett’s Best Investment

gatesnotes.com

211–212 of 212 posts

Re: Warren Buffett’s Best Investment

#211
post #205

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The way you phrased it previously suggested equivalence (all wealthy are insiders) rather than tendency (more wealthy are insiders).

It would help my argumentation skills if you could you point out where I suggested equivalence. I started with 'more like an insider than an outsider'.

Good point. Unfortunately, the threading view of Hacker News doesn't show me the comment I responded to by default and I just try to remember it.

I remembered your comment as, "anyone with more than $4 million is an insider."

If there's any lesson to draw, perhaps it's that more concise statements are less likely to be misunderstood. The more words, the more room for overlooking some of them.

It also might be the context. You were responding to someone saying Gates or Buffet is an outsider (again, I don't have that comment visible). Your comment in isolation would imply "more like" just as you wrote. However, as a response it sounds like a direct contradiction: he's an insider, not an outsider.

Re: Warren Buffett’s Best Investment

#212
post #211

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It would help my argumentation skills if you could you point out where I suggested equivalence. I started with 'more like an insider than an outsider'.

Good point. Unfortunately, the threading view of Hacker News doesn't show me the comment I responded to by default and I just try to remember it. I remembered your comment as, "anyone with more than $4 million is an insider." If there's any lesson to draw, perhaps it's that more concise statements are less likely to be misunderstood. The more words, the more room for overlooking some of them. It also might be the con…

It is true that I believe both Gates and Buffet are insiders. They're at the far end of the economic distribution, and, by simple self interest, have to take an interest in all the concerns I mentioned. I'd wager you could do an image search on Bill Gates and most world leaders and find a picture of them together. I suppose it depends on what you mean by 'insider', but I don't see how outsider' applies.
Post reply on HN