Live data from Hacker News

A.I. note takers are making lawyers nervous

nytimes.com

201–204 of 204 posts

Re: A.I. note takers are making lawyers nervous

#201
post #184

Somewhat off-topic: I've spent thousands of pounds on legal advice which has ranged from poor to mediocre. I found that most solicitors would refrain from giving proper advice and are there only to be instructed. You have to do your own homework, read the law, the case-law, prepare notes and documents, etc. With the rise of LLMs I found it easier to do all these things and come prepared to these meetings, or even do…

IANAL How can AI learn the secret procedural tricks? Where's the training data? And is there a legal consequence for AI giving bad/incorrect legal advice? Can they get disbarred? Can you be sure the AI tool even read an entire piece of legislation (inb4 "you can't with lawyers either" : I thought we're aiming for better)? How will they understand the inner workings of courts, CPS etc? How will they network with other…

> And is there a legal consequence for AI giving bad/incorrect legal advice? Can they get disbarred?

Of course not :) but unfortunately I've received half-truths and outright lies from actual solicitors, while AI has mostly given reliable advice, even if not procedurally perfect.

There's lots of guarding and unwritten rules in the legal profession so this is not something that will be straightforward to train on, but once done, even if imperfect, will bring legal access to the masses.

Re: A.I. note takers are making lawyers nervous

#202
post #145
post #56

Earlier quoted context omitted.

"If you give me six lines written by the hand of the most honest of men, I will find something in them which will hang him" - Cardinal Richelieu Be careful what you wish for. Particularly when it involves tech that often gets it very, very wrong.

Be real. Worry here by these layers and companies is not a false accusation. It is true accusation and potential for success of it.

Not sure what you ran through your LLM to produce that text, but it's not readable as English.

Re: A.I. note takers are making lawyers nervous

#203

Earlier quoted context omitted.

We've found they're surprisingly good if everyone on the call is using a decent headset. The problems start when using conference room audio or someone is on their laptop mic. If they miss a word they never do unintelligible , they just start playing madlibs based on the rest of the sentence. We just went through a round of 100+ (non-sensitive) VoC interviews and they really cut down the workload of compiling all of…

My workflow uses krisp.ai for taking a transcript, and then I have a dedicated project in Claude. I feed it the transcript and ask for it to give me a summary in a specific format I define, with good front matter, etc., and it needs to spit that out in a way that I auto-import into Obsidian. But key in my prompt is asking 1) for it to flag any low confidence or context-nonsensical statements in the transcript, with t…

For the "when did X first mention Y" queries, does it surface things you'd forgotten about that turned out to matter?

Or mostly just confirm what you half-remembered?

Trying to figure out whether the value of the loop is rediscovery or just precise lookup.

Re: A.I. note takers are making lawyers nervous

#204

Earlier quoted context omitted.

My workflow uses krisp.ai for taking a transcript, and then I have a dedicated project in Claude. I feed it the transcript and ask for it to give me a summary in a specific format I define, with good front matter, etc., and it needs to spit that out in a way that I auto-import into Obsidian. But key in my prompt is asking 1) for it to flag any low confidence or context-nonsensical statements in the transcript, with t…

For the "when did X first mention Y" queries, does it surface things you'd forgotten about that turned out to matter? Or mostly just confirm what you half-remembered? Trying to figure out whether the value of the loop is rediscovery or just precise lookup.

I think it's both, for me. I struggle with recall, so it helps me remember. I'm also using it to push to Todoist, etc. I need the memory jog, and then it helps me confirm things as they come back to me, to ensure I remember correctly. (ADHD, and across many projects as a PM).
Post reply on HN