Earlier quoted context omitted.
And in this subthread we are talking about republics which you are keen to mention china isn't.
> in this subthread we are talking about republics which you are keen to mention china isn't This subthread is part of the broader discussion. There are lots of Reddit corners for debating whether America is a republic. I haven’t seen any novel arguments in a while. The argument for whether an American AI is useful out of an American republic, its dying republic or even its embers is the germane one here, and I think…
I'm glad the Anthropic fight is happening now
201–210 of 237 posts
Re: I'm glad the Anthropic fight is happening now
#202One thing I’ve never heard a good answer to: If Anthropic is a supplier not to the Department of Defense itself, but to Palantir, why isn’t supply chain risk the proper designation (assuming the government’s concerns with Anthropic having authority over military missions is valid)? As for whether code written with Claude Code should be so considered - if it’s just code that is subject to human review, I would argue t…
> why isn’t supply chain risk the proper designation Because you can't designate a company a SCR because you don't like the contract you signed with them.
Re: I'm glad the Anthropic fight is happening now
#203Earlier quoted context omitted.
> in this subthread we are talking about republics which you are keen to mention china isn't This subthread is part of the broader discussion. There are lots of Reddit corners for debating whether America is a republic. I haven’t seen any novel arguments in a while. The argument for whether an American AI is useful out of an American republic, its dying republic or even its embers is the germane one here, and I think…
You are just sidestepping the discussion.
I'm avoiding an irrelevant sideline. Big difference.
Re: I'm glad the Anthropic fight is happening now
#204The author is naive. > The whole background of this AI conversation is that we’re in a race with China, and we have to win. But what is the reason we want America to win the AI race? It’s because we want to make sure free open societies can defend themselves. We don’t want the winner of the AI race to be a government which operates on the principle that there is no such thing as a truly private company or a private c…
Great take. If the past year has taught us anything, it’s that the US can’t really be seen as the “good guys” in such a simple way. Many of these things have been happening for years, but war crimes, disregard for international law, blackmailing allies, killing their own citizens without accountability, and allowing foreign governments to heavily influence policy are all troubling signs. It’s easy to point to China a…
-- signed, rest of the world :|
Re: I'm glad the Anthropic fight is happening now
#205Earlier quoted context omitted.
Do you not think a change in knowledge work similar in scale to the industrialization of agriculture would be significant?
Why are you trying to change the meaning of their comment?
Re: I'm glad the Anthropic fight is happening now
#206Earlier quoted context omitted.
> If the past year has taught us anything, it’s that the US can’t really be seen as the “good guys” in such a simple way. More like the past 200 years. America have never been the "good guys", and it is only Americans who seem to think they ever were.
If only Americans think we're the good guys, then why does everyone want to live here?
It's even relatively easy to put yourselves in their shoes. Columbia's GDP/capita is about $8k. In the US it's about $80k. Imagine how you'd feel if Canada had a GDP/capita of $800k. To many people it'd seem like a great idea to move there completely regardless of everything else about the country. People warning you that you'll end up mowing yards and painting houses while making barely enough to put a roof over your head. Bah! Nonsense! How can that be true on $800k/year!? Canada, here I come!
You can see this play out the same in places like Saudi Arabia. Not many place have the taste for their policies, religion, or much of anything else - yet they have a massive immigrant population, far higher than the US (as a percent) precisely because they pay stupidly high wages, often tax free, and have a low cost of living. You can easily become a dollar millionaire teaching English there if money is what you're after simply because you can easily save thousands of dollars a month. And if you get bored you can go watch somebody get crucified for witchcraft on a weekend now and again.
Re: I'm glad the Anthropic fight is happening now
#207Earlier quoted context omitted.
> If the past year has taught us anything, it’s that the US can’t really be seen as the “good guys” in such a simple way. More like the past 200 years. America have never been the "good guys", and it is only Americans who seem to think they ever were.
If only Americans think we're the good guys, then why does everyone want to live here?
Re: I'm glad the Anthropic fight is happening now
#208Earlier quoted context omitted.
> If the past year has taught us anything, it’s that the US can’t really be seen as the “good guys” in such a simple way. More like the past 200 years. America have never been the "good guys", and it is only Americans who seem to think they ever were.
If a majority of the Americans believed America was not generally the "good guys" it would be a sign of a failed democracy. Similarly normal for the population of any country that has net negative externalities from America to view them as the "bad guys". The current and growing anti-US sentiment is an expected result of an increasing gap between the US and the rest of the first world on economy and defense. The exis…
Democracy isn't about maximizing outcomes, because maximizing outcomes entails the possibility of minimizing outcomes. Marcus Aurelius was perhaps one of the best rulers in all of history. His son, Commodus - raised by him from birth, was certainly one of the worst rulers in all of history. Minority rule systems oscillate between extremes of the best of times and the worst of times. Democracy is always just kind of meh, never particularly great, never particularly awful.
But it creates a stable system because while it's meh in the present, you can always envision that things will be totally different in 4 years. Of course they won't be, but there's this weird bug in our psychology that we can't help but remain optimistic, even though in reality candidate after candidate it always feels like 'well it can't get any worse than this at least' and then the next guy is like 'hold my beer.'
Re: I'm glad the Anthropic fight is happening now
#209Earlier quoted context omitted.
There's a phenomenon when PRC comes up where people actively root for the United States to lose. Some of these people are even Americans (at least on paper). Regardless of the wisdom of the Iran war, there is a sizable amount that wants to see dead Americans result from it because it would allow them to do the same moral preening that is going on in this thread with regard to China. The Americans finally "got what th…
yes everyone who has a different opinion to you is lying. that's a great worldview
Re: I'm glad the Anthropic fight is happening now
#210Earlier quoted context omitted.
If only Americans think we're the good guys, then why does everyone want to live here?
I see this comment a lot. People don't want to live there. They want the dollars to send back to their home countries and families.