Live data from Hacker News

Another GitHub outage in the same day

githubstatus.com

201–210 of 298 posts

Re: Another GitHub outage in the same day

#201
post #131

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Not going to happen. This is terminal decline. Next step is to kill off free repos, and then they'll start ratcheting up the price to the point that they have one small dedicated engineering team supporting each customer they have. They will have exactly one customer. At some point they'll end up owned by Broadcom, OpenText, Rocket, or Progress.

Killing off free repos is not going to happen. That would be a suicide move on the level of the Digg redesign, or Tumblr's porn ban. It kind of would be good for everyone if they did do it though. Need to get rid of this monopoly, and maybe people will discover that there are alternatives with actually good workflows out there.

Microsoft has suicide-ed bigger than Digg.

Re: Another GitHub outage in the same day

#202
post #74

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It's the boards. GitHub issues doesn't let you do all the arcane nonsense Azure DevOps' boards let you do.

Isn’t that a feature?

A feature for devs, but I have often been told management is paid by the required field on tickets.

Re: Another GitHub outage in the same day

#203

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I second this. GitHub used to be a fantastic product. Now it barely even works. Even basic functionality like the timeline updating when I push commits is unreliable. The other day I opened a PR diff (not even a particularly large one) and it took fully 15 seconds after the page visually finished loading -- on a $2,000 dev machine -- before any UI elements became clickable. This happened repeatedly. It is fairly stun…

Hey from the GitHub team. Outages like this are incredibly painful and we'll share a post-mortem once our investigation is complete. It stings to have this happen as we're putting a lot of effort specifically into the core product, growing teams like Actions and increasing performance-focused initiatives on key areas like pull requests where we're already making solid progress[1]. Would love if you would reach out to…

Can you guys stop adding new features for a while please and just make what’s there more reliable?

Re: Another GitHub outage in the same day

#204
post #200

This is exactly why my employer is unlikely to adopt Azure. When CoreAI assets like GitHub appear poorly managed, it undermines confidence in the rest of the ecosystem. It’s unfortunate, because Microsoft seems to overlook how strongly consumer experience shapes business perception. Once trust is damaged, no amount of advertising spend can fully restore it.

They dont care. Their sales reps absolutely know that if you are using Microsoft products it is because you are locked in so deeply that escape is nearly impossible.

Re: Another GitHub outage in the same day

#205

GitLab is the solution, if you aren't on it already. I worked for one of Australia largest airline company, monthly meeting with Github team resumed in one word: AI There is zero focus into the actual platform as we knew it, it is all AI, Copilot, more AI and more Copilot. If you are expecting things to get better, I have bad news for you. Copilot is not being adopted by companies as they hoped, they are using Claude…

Do they have their own model? I thought Copilot was a frontend for Clause et. al..

To the best of my knowledge, Copilot is a Microsof in-house thing and it sucks on everything. Claude is far superior and Microsoft is allegedly using Claude internally over its own AI solution.

Re: Another GitHub outage in the same day

#206

GitLab is the solution, if you aren't on it already. I worked for one of Australia largest airline company, monthly meeting with Github team resumed in one word: AI There is zero focus into the actual platform as we knew it, it is all AI, Copilot, more AI and more Copilot. If you are expecting things to get better, I have bad news for you. Copilot is not being adopted by companies as they hoped, they are using Claude…

To be honest all the GitLab dev focus is also AI. * Originally it was Dev (issues) * Then it was DevOps (runners) * Then it was DevSecOps (SAST) * Now it's AI DevSecOps (reviews, etc) The problem is that each feature has been slightly more half-baked than the last one. The SecOps stuff is full of gotchas which don't exist. Troubleshooting a pipeline behaving correctly is extremely painful. The other problem is that i…

End users are being screwed over left and right, you better host your own code. GitHub, GitLab only adds a GUI for git.

Enterprise helm will pay if that means no interruption, no AI being pushed everywhere. Some companies adopt GitLab because you can self host it, even the runners are self-hosted, there is no built-in runner like GitHub.

Re: Another GitHub outage in the same day

#207
post #102

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Things don't always ramp up after 2-4 years. Sometimes MS just kills the project or company after that period of time. See also their moves in the gaming industry.

Heh, I was working at 2 of those gaming companies when they were acquired by m$. I almost fear taking another job in the gaming industry, there seems to be some kind of bastardised version of Murphy's law that any gaming company that hires me will be acquired by ms 6 months later. I mean, that's obviously not the case, but it's weird that it happened twice!

Very weird it happened twice! But that's a kind of a cool factoid to tell people haha.

Even with devs and publishers that don't die or are killed, they still lay hundreds off when a game is done. Then the studio limps along in pre-production mode on their next game for 4-5 years it seems like...

Maybe the only job stability in the industry is with indies, and... Nintendo?

Re: Another GitHub outage in the same day

#208

Earlier quoted context omitted.

One hundred ? Did I read that right?

No its not. 121M repos added on github in 2025, and overall they have 630 million now. There is probably at best 2x increased in output (mostly trash output), but no where near 100x https://github.blog/news-insights/octoverse/octoverse-a-new-...

Published in Oct 2025... I think your estimate is off.

Note the hockey stick growth in the graph they showed in Oct.

Here we are in February.

It's gotten way worse now with additional Claude's, Claw's, Ralph's, and such.

It may not be 100x as was told to me but it's definitely putting the strain on the entire org.

Re: Another GitHub outage in the same day

#209

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Ya, it really was one of the most enjoyable web apps to use pre-MS. I'm sure there are lots of things that have contributed to this downfall. We certainly didn't need bullshit features like achievements.

Even just a year or two ago its web interface was way snappier. Now an issue with a non-trivial number of comments, or a PR with a diff of even just a few hundred or thousand lines of changes causes my browser to lock up.

Which website lets you load PRs with 1000 lines and it’s fast? Honest question, it’s not gitlab.

Re: Another GitHub outage in the same day

#210

Can someone in GitHub senior leadership please start paying attention and reprioritise towards actually delivering a product that's at least relatively reliable? I moved my company over to GH enterprise last year (from AzDO) and I'm considering moving us away to another vendor altogether as a result of the constant partial outages. Things that used to "just work" now are slow in the UI, and GH actions fail to schedul…

My org just moved to Gitlab because of the GH actions problems.

8 hour outage last week
Post reply on HN