Live data from Hacker News

Larry Ellison – 'citizens will be on their best behavior' amid nonstop recording

fortune.com

201–210 of 217 posts

Re: Larry Ellison – 'citizens will be on their best behavior' amid nonstop recording

#201
post #84

Earlier quoted context omitted.

We stop collaborating. Technologists, engineers, and support staff make this machine run. It must be made personally infeasible to continue contributing to our own shortsighted destruction. The incentive structure can and must be changed.

> We stop collaborating. Technologists, engineers, and support staff make this machine run. "We" don't all view the world through the same lens. And moreover not on all matters. Your framing is erroneous, which leads to incorrect assumptions and strategy.

[dead]

Re: Larry Ellison – 'citizens will be on their best behavior' amid nonstop recording

#203
post #39

I encourage people making snap comments to read at least one entire paragraph of the article: > “We’re going to have supervision,” Ellison said. “Every police officer is going to be supervised at all times, and if there’s a problem, AI will report that problem and report it to the appropriate person. Citizens will be on their best behavior because we are constantly recording and reporting everything that’s going on.”…

> People do act differently when they know they are being watched I really want to see more evidence for this. People act differently when they face consequences. More surveillance without enforcement wouldn’t be expected to positively change behaviour.

Just ask GPT, the awareness of being observed significantly impacts behavior even in rather primitive animals:

Research has demonstrated these behavioral changes in various species, including:

    Primates: Monkeys and apes often alter their social interactions and grooming behaviors when they know they are being observed by humans or other primates.
    Birds: Studies have shown that birds may change their foraging behavior when they detect human presence, often becoming more cautious.
    Fish: Some fish species exhibit changes in swimming patterns and social behavior when they sense they are being watched.
These behavioral adaptations are thought to be evolutionary responses that help animals avoid predation and enhance their survival in the wild.

Re: Larry Ellison – 'citizens will be on their best behavior' amid nonstop recording

#204
post #54

For a description of the consequences of mass surveillance and repressive regimentation of individual behavior in a society, read: "Nineteen Eighty-Four" by George Orwell.[a] --- [a] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nineteen_Eighty-Four

Easily the most explicit and pedantic citation of 1984 that I've seen - big fan

Sorry if my comment came across as pedantic. That was definitely not my intention!

Re: Larry Ellison – 'citizens will be on their best behavior' amid nonstop recording

#205
> ... because we are constantly recording and reporting everything that’s going on

Why stop just here? It's AI, right? So it’s all about prediction - next token, next action, it doesn’t matter. Let’s turn Minority Report the movie into reality: when you’re angry at your boss while commuting home, we will watch, predict and prevent your future bad behavior.

Re: Larry Ellison – 'citizens will be on their best behavior' amid nonstop recording

#206

It's interesting this thread is flagged, given that the scenario is a direct consequence of advances of technology, AI, and worship of wealth -- seems very core HN. Entities with this level of resources and influence have very little in common with people, other than biology. We would do well to instead perceive them as dangerous alien parasites -- not precisely hostile, but lacking social connection to the rest of u…

It went off topic at the top of the thread. I didn't flag. But if you want to get something flagged off the front page, I guess that's how it's done.

Ah it's too bad they can't flag just the off-topic subthreads

Re: Larry Ellison – 'citizens will be on their best behavior' amid nonstop recording

#207

Earlier quoted context omitted.

How could Ellison's motivation for creating a surveillance state possibly not be relevant?

> How could Ellison's motivation for creating a surveillance state possibly not be relevant? What is his motivation? Why is Israel relevant?

[flagged]

Re: Larry Ellison – 'citizens will be on their best behavior' amid nonstop recording

#208
post #190
post #135

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> They are going to define "best behavior" in a way that never threatens their feelings, let alone threatens their powers, if you let them. You are painfully correct https://www.kenklippenstein.com/p/trumps-nspm-7-labels-commo...

Looking at that list of extremist indicators, I would agree that they qualify as common beliefs. It's hard to be too outraged though, because they also seem to genuinely reflect destructive beliefs that are absolutely antithetical to American society.

Wow, you seem to be so confident in defining exactly when and how any of the following “beliefs” are “anthitetical to American society”:

> hostility towards those who hold traditional American views on family,

> hostility towards those who hold traditional American views on religion, and

> hostility towards those who hold traditional American views on morality.

You seem to be a paragon of discernment regarding extremely subjective, ill-defined areas. How impressive.

Re: Larry Ellison – 'citizens will be on their best behavior' amid nonstop recording

#209

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Is your contention that the only anti-gun countries are, er, the UK and Singapore? And to be honest, the UK surveillance thing is somewhat exaggerated; it's highly London-centric, and they're mostly privately-owned cameras; the main driving factor is the insurance industry. Ireland, say, has some of the strictest gun laws in the developed world, and doesn't have a large number of CCTVs or other forms of surveillance.

"And to be honest, the UK surveillance thing is somewhat exaggerated; it's highly London-centric, and they're mostly privately-owned cameras; the main driving factor is the insurance industry." The big cities is where the most crime happens. It's not really 'exaggerated'. If you legally aren't allowed to protect yourself during a crime, it's best to have a camera in place that catches the person that's doing it (and…

> The big cities is where the most crime happens.

I mentioned London, specifically, not big cities in general. London's crime rate is pretty much the same as England's as a whole, and many English towns and cities have much higher crime rates.

> This isn't true at all.

In what way? The only place on the island of Ireland which appears at all in the lists of heavily CCTV'd countries is Belfast, which is in Northern Ireland (part of the UK, not Ireland). Dublin (a much larger city) does not feature. Irish gun laws are generally stricter than British gun laws; in particular being allowed to have a gun for self-protection is simply not, in practice, a thing.

As far as I can see, the evidence for high surveillance in western countries being, essentially, a regional insurance company fetish far outweighs evidence that it is linked to _gun availability_.

Re: Larry Ellison – 'citizens will be on their best behavior' amid nonstop recording

#210
post #23

Right because the UK is such a safe place.

> because the UK is such a safe place Objectively, it is [1]. [1] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_intenti... 1.1 vs 5.8 intentional homicides per 100,000

There are more than two countries in the world. Italy, for example, without pervasive monitoring and overt spying of its citizens, is at 0.545, half the UK rate.

Germany, Netherlands, Norway, Poland, just to name a few, are all below the UK rate.

Post reply on HN