Live data from Hacker News

Getting free internet on a cruise, saving $170

news.ycombinator.com

201–210 of 210 posts

Re: Getting free internet on a cruise, saving $170

#201

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I think, in 2025 you are better off with this https://www.starlink.com/us/roam

Often forbidden on cruise ships as it would be on flights for the same reasons (possible interference). In an airplane it's also impossible to make it work though those tiny windows of course. But on a cruise ship balcony it would probably be fine.

Also prohibited on US navy littoral combat ships

https://www.navytimes.com/news/your-navy/2024/09/03/how-navy...

Re: Getting free internet on a cruise, saving $170

#202
post #186

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Hmm, seeing someone fall/jump overboard and then subsequently getting interrogated by the fbi upon docking was anything but boring,

Do you honestly think that happens in most cruises?

It's more about the anticipation

Re: Getting free internet on a cruise, saving $170

#203

Earlier quoted context omitted.

https://www.reddit.com/r/Starlink/comments/1crxkx9/starlink_... Apparently a mid-size ship will have 12 terminals. That same thread talks about other ship sizes but not if they have more terminals. I still submit that the pricing is entirely a function of what the market will bear, and not the cost of the service.

Those 12 terminals still need to talk to satellites. Only a certain number will be in reach, and if the ship is significantly out to sea, those satellites will need to pass data along to others to reach the ground. We know a densely populated land area can saturate the satellites overhead; it's part of the reason we don't use Starlink in, say, NYC. The same math applies to a thousand cruise ship passengers trying to…

Absolutely the density of 12 terminals over what amounts to skyscraper on edge, is high. But cruise ships are not packed into city blocks. The density of terminals over ship-in-ocean sized areas is quite low. The density is very much more sparse than a countryside or farm area. So it feels unlikely to me that you are going to saturate the visible satellites. And those satellites will be very underutilized at their locations not quite over land yet.

Only recently (2025) has Starlink been documented to pass data between satellites and only for new ones. Cruise ships have had starlink for several years so the most common case will likely still be a single hop. Most cruises hug closely enough to the shore (within 100 miles) that a second hop isn't required.

It's not really a thousand passengers, it's just 12 terminals. Sure, those terminals are well oversubscribed vs a normal user terminal, but given the documented terminal-to-ground-station ratio (quite high), I'm pretty doubtful a cruise ship or 2 significantly impacts (or is impacted by) ground bandwidth. The density of users is just at the wrong scale for it to be significant.

Re: Getting free internet on a cruise, saving $170

#205
post #134

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Unless you are on a cruise to work remotely and flee soaring rental prices.

There is no way that a cruise is cheaper.

Sorry, I genuinely thought that this idea was a well adopted meme.

I reckon it is not.

https://www.unilad.com/news/money/living-on-cruise-ship-cost...

Re: Getting free internet on a cruise, saving $170

#206

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Often forbidden on cruise ships as it would be on flights for the same reasons (possible interference). In an airplane it's also impossible to make it work though those tiny windows of course. But on a cruise ship balcony it would probably be fine.

The rea$on that it i$ forbidden on crui$e $hip$ i$ not due to interference, whatever the company may claim.

True, when I hear they charge $30 per day, that's ridiculous.

Re: Getting free internet on a cruise, saving $170

#207

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> A cruise ship has people with nothing to do wandering around The major point of a cruise is that there is constantly something to do. It's wall-to-wall entertainment, 24-hours a day. My 2-year-old was too excited to sleep on a Disney cruise, so we just walked around and found character photos at 10PM. She was too shy to take her picture, so I got my picture taken with her hiding her face on my shoulder. (FWIW: A cr…

Cruises sound and look like absolute nightmares. Physical manifestation of brainrot. Cyberpunk hell

Really, the worst thing about a cruise is that there's a good chance you're going to get sick.

After that, it's more about your attitude.

Re: Getting free internet on a cruise, saving $170

#208
post #17

I used a travel router on my recent trip to Argentina and found it quite useful. It will be a permanent part of my travel kit. Some cooler uses: - streaming HDR video from closed MacBook running Amphetamine to Vision Pro via Moonlink - Having a working HomePod mini in the hotel room. The hotel internet did not like multiple devices off the router. It didn’t reject it outright but it throttled or nerfed it. Individual…

> travel router What's the difference between that and tethering off your phone?

Tethering on an iPhone acts as a simple pass-through of its cellular internet connection over Wi-Fi.

It does not establish a private local area network (LAN) for connected devices to communicate with each other.

The travel router can use an iPhone for internet via tethering, though that iPhone won’t also be able to connect to the network created by the travel router.

The travel router is ~the same as a home WiFi router, but they come with configurations meant for dealing with common issues on the road.

Re: Getting free internet on a cruise, saving $170

#209

Side note, I’m pretty sure you can send iMessage on a cruise ship when connected to their WiFi with no internet package because apple has a mesh network between unrelated devices and finds one with an internet endpoint to funnel messages in and out. I’m just basing this on usage experience and my hypothesis.

> I’m pretty sure you can send iMessage on a cruise ship when connected to their WiFi with no internet package because apple has a mesh network between unrelated devices and finds one with an internet endpoint to funnel messages in and out.

I for one would love to hear more about this sub rosa mesh network.

Re: Getting free internet on a cruise, saving $170

#210

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I haven't been on a cruise in a long time, does anyone know if there are on-board IT people? Might be an interesting job if I ever get bored again.

I was on a somewhat fancy cruise a short while ago (Celebrity, fwiw) and they had a small live tv production crew that would film around the ship broadcast daily events and stuff on the ship's tv channel. The live shows also had a number of a/v tech crew people so there certainly are some IT folks employed on the ships while it embarks.

That's cool, I love cruises I find them fascinating although I know quite a few people who don't like them - to each their own. I've never taken a Celebrity cruise but I've been on Royal Caribbean and Disney with my family, I know they're massive undertakings and huge profit machines. They employ hundreds of people from chefs to musicians and nautical engineers... It does make you wonder about the IT part of the operation though.
Post reply on HN