Live data from Hacker News

Everybody Hates Firefox Updates

evilbrainjono.net

201–205 of 205 posts

Re: Everybody Hates Firefox Updates

#201
post #43

So its been a few month without bashing firefox and thus its that time of the year for that again? Except it has better memory management than any other browser now. Except its the fastest browser on Android now. Except the upgrading no longer break addons as they're compat by default now Except upgrading is now silent (no dialog box, no UAC prompt, no "welcome to the new firefox tab" - yes; on windows) Except if you…

I was on the verge of abandoning FF on Android until the new upgrade fixed the problems I had with it. So that was a big thumbs-up.

It also came with enough significant UI changes that even as a programmer who's used FF dails since pre-1.0 days, I actually had to stop and RTFM to work out how to use it. That was a catastrophic thumbs-down. Most users wouldn't stand for that level of disruption to their software.

Mozilla has done an amazing job of "one step forwards, two steps back" over the years. Firefox has gone from being the amazing browser I recommended to everyone to try to a browser I'm almost embarassed to admit I use.

I really hope the fixes they say they have in the pipeline live up to their promises and fix the issues they still have. But even if they do, if Mozilla don't stop their trend of fixing bugs but breaking the UI, it just won't matter in the end.

Re: Everybody Hates Firefox Updates

#202
post #164

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Please try FF15 when it comes out on August 28. It has a fix that prevents 90%+ of leaks from add-ons. See http://blog.mozilla.org/nnethercote/2012/05/07/update-on-lea... for some details (and note that all the follow-on problems mentioned in that post have now been fixed).

The problem is not add-ons. Let me repeat that -- THE PROBLEM IS NOT ADD-ONS. I left Firefox about a year ago, once Chrome was good enough, because my plain-vanilla Firefox, with all the tweaks to limit memory usage enabled, would still leak memory until it crashed (my laptop has 1.5GB RAM and Ubuntu; it also had a few GB of swap). Closing tabs did not help either. The only response from Mozilla was 'add-ons.' Chrome…

A year ago at what release?

Re: Everybody Hates Firefox Updates

#203
post #94

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Well, maybe I'll give it a try soon again. I did about a year ago and was re-disappointed.

The first big post-FF4 improvements were in FF7, which was released in September last year. See http://blog.mozilla.org/nnethercote/2011/08/09/firefox-7-is-... for some details. And things have improved quite a bit more since FF7.

I personally noticed this too.

Re: Everybody Hates Firefox Updates

#204
post #202
post #164

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The problem is not add-ons. Let me repeat that -- THE PROBLEM IS NOT ADD-ONS. I left Firefox about a year ago, once Chrome was good enough, because my plain-vanilla Firefox, with all the tweaks to limit memory usage enabled, would still leak memory until it crashed (my laptop has 1.5GB RAM and Ubuntu; it also had a few GB of swap). Closing tabs did not help either. The only response from Mozilla was 'add-ons.' Chrome…

A year ago at what release?

Don't know. I grab from official web site, so latest as of a year ago.

Re: Everybody Hates Firefox Updates

#205
post #204
post #202

Earlier quoted context omitted.

A year ago at what release?

Don't know. I grab from official web site, so latest as of a year ago.

AFAIK Mozilla MemShrink was started around that time: http://blog.mozilla.org/nnethercote/2011/06/22/memshrink-pro...
Post reply on HN