Live data from Hacker News

Twitter/X will let people you've blocked see your posts

theverge.com

201–210 of 506 posts

Re: Twitter/X will let people you've blocked see your posts

#201

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Referenced in? That is waaaay too far. That means if the person blocked you, you essentially can't talk about them.

I can't edit the original response, but I meant you shouldn't be able to make replies to threads of their retweeted posts.

Retweeted posts also seems too far. That person could be agreeing or criticizing them, but you can't comment on it? That means any dissenters can just not comment on your posts.

Re: Twitter/X will let people you've blocked see your posts

#202
post #46

I always thought this was a stupid restriction. You can't view the post while authenticated but you can view the post while unauthenticated.

To be fair, you can barely view any post while unauthenticated these days. Sometimes I click on a link to a tweet on my work laptop (where I'm not authenticated) and I get immediately assaulted by several pop-ups and cookie bars and redirected to the landing page when try to dismiss them.

You can create a new account. It's a poorly designed feature that degrades the user experience semi-permanently and with no recourse.

Re: Twitter/X will let people you've blocked see your posts

#203
post #134
post #46

I always thought this was a stupid restriction. You can't view the post while authenticated but you can view the post while unauthenticated.

The old blocking also stopped your posts from appearing in their "for you" timeline. The new blocking doesn't.

This is pure speculation. It's not implemented yet and there is no detailed explanation of how it will work. It could easily still prevent your posts from being algorithmically recommended.

Re: Twitter/X will let people you've blocked see your posts

#204

This is just one more example of Twitter going out of their way to work against the best interests of their users. As twitter continues to treat its userbase like a controlling/abusive spouse I hope more and more people realize that they deserve better and leave.

Nope, Twitter blocking is a poorly designed feature that permanently degrades the user experience.

Re: Twitter/X will let people you've blocked see your posts

#205

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Blocking doesn't really fix the brigading problem, regardless of whether people need to log out or not. Most X users will just post a screenshot of the tweet, breaking accessibility in the process and disassociating the original author from the thread against their will. This isn't always a good thing, as it leads to people being surprised by crowds of strangers suddenly screaming at them and not being able to see th…

> Most X users will just post a screenshot of the tweet, breaking accessibility in the process and disassociating the original author from the thread against their will. But that means the blocking worked. Another person will now have to go to the extra effort of either finding that tweet or going directly to the profile to interact with them. And those extra steps were exactly the feature the blocking provided. It c…

You could design Twitter in a way where handles in quoted tweets aren't clickable if the quoter is blocked by the quotee, but the quotee can still be notified that they've been quoted by somebody they blocked, and optionally choose to see the post. Same for deletion, you could make quotes literally include the original post and preserve it forever, but notify viewers when the original is deleted.

Re: Twitter/X will let people you've blocked see your posts

#206

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It provides friction for further misbehaving. Imagine you blocked someone who has serious issues with people who #foobar. It's better for you if they can't easily find you and repost your content to their community who also hate #foobar. It's not perfect, but the friction helps prevent drive-by bad behaviour.

No it doesn't. The people who are malicious about it will be using multiple accounts. The block button doesn't stop them. If anything, it provides them ammunition to go "See, this person is a sensitive one, let's add them to the list". Either your posts are public or they're not. There's a pretty clear distinction between the two, and anyone who thinks otherwise is sorely mistaken. The risk of people re-posting your…

This is the old "it's not perfect, therefore, it's useless" type of argument. No one claimed it's perfect, but that doesn't mean it's useless.

You don't want to interact with me? Fine. Then why should I still see your posts? Yes, some crazy people will go to lengths to see it anyway, but most don't and will take the hint, shrug, and go away.

Re: Twitter/X will let people you've blocked see your posts

#207

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It provides friction for further misbehaving. Imagine you blocked someone who has serious issues with people who #foobar. It's better for you if they can't easily find you and repost your content to their community who also hate #foobar. It's not perfect, but the friction helps prevent drive-by bad behaviour.

No it doesn't. The people who are malicious about it will be using multiple accounts. The block button doesn't stop them. If anything, it provides them ammunition to go "See, this person is a sensitive one, let's add them to the list". Either your posts are public or they're not. There's a pretty clear distinction between the two, and anyone who thinks otherwise is sorely mistaken. The risk of people re-posting your…

> It's not perfect, but the friction helps prevent drive-by bad behaviour.

> No it doesn't.

There's really no use in continuing this discussion when one party is unable/unwilling to use precise language to discuss marginal effects. Obviously I presume what you mean is that the marginal effect is too small to be relevant, but discussions with people who round that off to "No it doesn't" rarely go anywhere productive.

Re: Twitter/X will let people you've blocked see your posts

#208
post #90

Hiding your posts from abusers is a legitimate use case because most people (emphasis on most) won't bother to go on private browsing every day just to be annoying.

There's an argument here that the previous blocking behavior might give users a false sense of security. In reality, you should not post any information publicly that you wouldn't want someone in particular to read, even if you've blocked that person.

I don't think anyone was ever confused about that. It's about choosing who you interact with and who interacts with you, same in many other areas in life.

Re: Twitter/X will let people you've blocked see your posts

#210
post #204

This is just one more example of Twitter going out of their way to work against the best interests of their users. As twitter continues to treat its userbase like a controlling/abusive spouse I hope more and more people realize that they deserve better and leave.

Nope, Twitter blocking is a poorly designed feature that permanently degrades the user experience.

How can you say that? Especially given that this is a big news item, clearly people find it useful.
Post reply on HN