Live data from Hacker News

The Patent Pledge

paulgraham.com

201–204 of 204 posts

Re: The Patent Pledge

#201
post #21

I disagree that this will help, because the established companies the pledge would apply to are a secondary problem and mostly seem to fight each other (has Microsoft asserted patents against a startup? has IBM? has AT&T? when they asserted patents it was against multi-million dollar businesses!). The primary problem is patent trolls (see e.g. lodsys / intellectual ventures) for whom this pledge could be considered s…

The problems people note are solvd if you issue a patent free for a short time, like 3 years, and then auction a much smaller number of extensions to that term. This creates a pricing maximum for years 4 to whenever.

Re: The Patent Pledge

#203

> Please join them! Paul, there is a major oversight here. The site http://thepatentpledge.org/ doesn't even have a contact form. Also, you may want to make the links nofollow.

Yeah I noticed the same thing. Should the companies email pg directly?

Maybe they should put an announcement on their own websites, and pg will update the site accordingly?

Re: The Patent Pledge

#204

Can someone clarify for me, what does "no first use" mean? Does it mean you can't sue a small start-up for being the first to use a patent you already own?

I understand it as "we will not fire at you unless fired upon".
Post reply on HN