201–210 of 704 posts
Earlier quoted context omitted.
I’ve never seen any data showing that housing bubbles are attributed to “the rich”. The housing market is made of tens of millions of individual home owners, not some moguls cornering the market.
Leveraged asset buyers have an influence when inventory is so low.
Earlier quoted context omitted.
"better start finding and implementing real solutions to housing prices right now" They can't. Providing supply will suffer the wrath of BANANA/CAVE/NIMBY anywhere you dream of living. Constraining demand will either get you voted out of office or devastate your political network or both, depending on which policy you attempt. You're competing with a whole planet full of people that want to live here and have more me…
> For 99% of you that means living far away from your preferred locale among people you probably loath. Parent comment is vitriolic but not actually wrong. Myself, I take great comfort in the idea of huge swaths of liberal, well-educated millennials and xennials migrating out of coastal cities and into small towns across the South and Midwest. Can you work remotely? Want to own your own home on a multi-acre lot for $…
Earlier quoted context omitted.
"better start finding and implementing real solutions to housing prices right now" They can't. Providing supply will suffer the wrath of BANANA/CAVE/NIMBY anywhere you dream of living. Constraining demand will either get you voted out of office or devastate your political network or both, depending on which policy you attempt. You're competing with a whole planet full of people that want to live here and have more me…
> For 99% of you that means living far away from your preferred locale among people you probably loath. Parent comment is vitriolic but not actually wrong. Myself, I take great comfort in the idea of huge swaths of liberal, well-educated millennials and xennials migrating out of coastal cities and into small towns across the South and Midwest. Can you work remotely? Want to own your own home on a multi-acre lot for $…
Earlier quoted context omitted.
It doesn't matter so much if a country is taxing their own rich if they allow rich people from other countries to buy real estate.
I’ve never seen any data showing that housing bubbles are attributed to “the rich”. The housing market is made of tens of millions of individual home owners, not some moguls cornering the market.
Earlier quoted context omitted.
Leveraged asset buyers have an influence when inventory is so low.
Agreed, but the fundamental problem is that inventory is so low. Super low inventory and vacancy rates cause far more problems in addition to prices being set by a wealthier percentile.
While it doesn't directly affect the average person's purchasing power, the same dramatic increase is happening in other asset values as well. [0] One interesting thing to note is that 2019 EV / EBITDA values were already "high," before the coronavirus was spreading. I suspect these two phenomena have different causes overall, but low interest rates are a common factor that cause all asset prices to increase. On the…
This jibes with my experience of buying a house about 6 months ago. My reasoning was that we were experiencing rapid asset inflation fueled by low interest rates and COVID stimulus, and our cash was losing its value relative to housing by the month. I figured that this propping up of asset prices is likely to continue, as any administration that lets housing / 401k values collapse will get massacred in elections.
Copying a link from a mysteriously dead comment below: https://www.corelogic.com/intelligence/comparing-two-home-pr... You have to take interest rates into account. The amount you pay, monthly, for a mortgage of the same size is very different at different interest levels. What people care about is their monthly mortgage payment - that's what makes a home affordable or not. (Which isn't to discount that downpayments…
While it doesn't directly affect the average person's purchasing power, the same dramatic increase is happening in other asset values as well. [0] One interesting thing to note is that 2019 EV / EBITDA values were already "high," before the coronavirus was spreading. I suspect these two phenomena have different causes overall, but low interest rates are a common factor that cause all asset prices to increase. On the…
Home prices are a function of monthly costs. As much as people want to compare the value of a home from year to year, in every instance, I've seen values reflect to monthly spending power. I would love to see some estimate that takes more into account like household income, tax breaks, and interest rates. If I have a interest deduction, my relative taxes are lower. If I have children, my taxes are lower. If I have hi…
If you have the exact same income and rates are at today's 3% vs 2008's 6%, the payments on a $1.0MM home mortgage would be $4.2K vs $6.0k. The difference between those two payments is about $40k/year of gross income difference.
A person in 2021 with the exact same income as 2008 would be paying the same for a $1.4M mortgage per month as the person in 2008 at a $1.0M mortgage.
I don't own a home, so I'm not saying this to justify my purchase, but if I just take the info in the graph, I actually wonder whether there is a lot more room to go in the market. I wonder if we are looking at another 20-30% appreciation before the top?
I have no idea.
How much of this is a result of our "don't tax the rich" policies that created a staggering amount of wealth at the top that has nowhere else to go? So many ultra rich investors are looking for something, anything, to invest in. Plus there is the feedback loop of massive growth you get as the bubble inflates. Is this a direct result of our fiscal policy? Have we destabilize the economy in order to create the richest…
The amount of private equity in housing is really underreported I think - still the vast majority of people owning second homes or additional property are doing it for investments, but there is nothing stopping an “uber for housing” where they use VC money to buy up massive amounts of properties and influence pricing. I believe this is one of Zillow’s primary models. My take is that we need to treat housing as an act…
There are lots of people who don't want to own a home (e.g. who value the mobility/flexibility of renting), and people who are unable to afford the fully loaded homeownership costs. In these rent-vs-mortgage discussions people often overlook the non-mortgage homeownership costs which can be very significant and hard to predict. I say this as a person who found myself needing an unexpected $25k+ roof replacement in my first year of homeownership.
I suspect living standards for the bottom quintile would actually fall if they had to maintain their own homes. E.g. how are the people who can't put together $400 in an emergency, the minimum wage employees living hand to mouth, etc going to be able to afford to replace an unexpected leaking roof (a $10k+ problem) or a broken water heater (a $5k problem) or refrigerator (a $500+ problem)? A lot of basic amenities are legally mandated for landlords to provide that I think low-income tenants would not be able to maintain on their own. A landlord with a larger net worth is better able to absorb these cashflow problems and keep the property in a healthy state.
Some very clever and influential people better start finding and implementing real solutions to housing prices right now. If they don't, expect overwhelming support from Millennials for massive expansions to public housing and rent control, if not even more draconian measures.
Simple solution would be to put a property and sales tax ramp on additional homes. Make landlords who own N homes pay 1.5^N the normal rate.