Live data from Hacker News

Alpine Linux Docker images have NULL for root password

cve.mitre.org

201–203 of 203 posts

Re: Alpine Linux Docker images have NULL for root password

#202
post #175

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I trust myself who setup our infrastructure vs. the security guys who's automatic response to everything is deny all everywhere, encrypt everything everywhere (at rest encryption isn't enough, what can you do to get the db to work on the data encrypted internally 100% of the time?), and enable 2 factor on everything (the github gui has 2fa enabled, why aren't push/pull requests using 2fa?). I think may main point is…

Sounds like you need better security people.

...which, sadly, is true of many larger organizations: "security" ends up as just another middle management approval committee whose only job is to apply byzantine security checklists dreamed up by some Certified Security Architect (tm) way too late in the development process, right when it's hardest for product teams to reshuffle their entire architecture to comply, and with no consideration to the actual circumstances / risk profile of specific projects.

IMHO this should be viewed as a big, glaring anti-pattern, as it fundamentally puts security team goals at odds with product team goals.

Re: Alpine Linux Docker images have NULL for root password

#203
post #162

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Alpine comes with no suid binaries in Docker to my knowledge (it's expected you run your stuff as root inside the container unless there is a reason not to)

Just for the uninitiated: suid binaries are binaries with a special flag set that will make it run with root privileges regardless of who started it. sudo is an example of something that would use suid . When a user runs sudo , the binary actually runs with root privileges from the get-go, checks if the user is OK, then executes the command you specified. However, use of sudo or other suid binaries is entirely pointl…

OK, so what’s the entire point of this article then?
Post reply on HN