Live data from Hacker News

How much does employee turnover really cost?

medium.com

201–210 of 353 posts

Re: How much does employee turnover really cost?

#201
post #79

It's funny. The smart companies I know are all moving away from hiring full-time devs. They want a very small core team of highly skilled devs, all with relatively high equity, combined with tons of freelancers/consultants on a call-list. By far the biggest cost to software companies is employee turnover because the second greatest cost is employee education and training. We've measured developer productivity in mult…

Do freelancers/consultants magically need no onboarding and become fully productive on day 1?

According to the job ads that need someone to "hit the ground running" they do.

Re: How much does employee turnover really cost?

#202

It's funny. The smart companies I know are all moving away from hiring full-time devs. They want a very small core team of highly skilled devs, all with relatively high equity, combined with tons of freelancers/consultants on a call-list. By far the biggest cost to software companies is employee turnover because the second greatest cost is employee education and training. We've measured developer productivity in mult…

IME companies that do this are always crippled by technical debt. Why worry about maintainability when you won't be here in 6 months anyway?

Re: How much does employee turnover really cost?

#203
post #195

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Same with their presentations at conferences. They hire really good people, pay them a ton (300k+), and fire them when they stop performing. It's a good way to get great people, if you can afford it.

That gets into a murky definition of "performing" though. Performance is often limited by other people, many of which may be long gone. It can also create a culture of people unwilling to admit mistakes. It doesn't take long for these behaviours to produce massive amounts of technical debt. The policy doesn't seem to be working for their UI team either.

No system is going to be perfect, but I think it's worth something that they're at least trying to do reasonable things.

The real question is how many times do people fall into that tricky edge case vs. how often is there a fairly clearly case for a termination?

Re: How much does employee turnover really cost?

#204

Managers, here me now. 1) Money is a factor because my job is difficult. 2) Up to date technology is important because I want to build interesting products. As a developer, these are my motivations.

I'd add 0) don't have a shitty code base. Nothing hampers my productivity (and the businesses) like technical debt.

Re: How much does employee turnover really cost?

#205

This article missed the fact that the cost to the company in trying to keep the employees who will leave every year might be greater than the cost of losing them. For e.g., in the example given in the article, the company loses 1.57 million due to employee turnover. However, who knows how much the company might have to spend to keep those employees from leaving. The cost would be high because the effort spent on empl…

This is a non starter if the new employee salary + recruiting costs > existing employee salary + raise.

Recruiting costs are typically worth several years of 10%+ raises.

Re: How much does employee turnover really cost?

#206

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> I had made a verbal deal with the previous CTO in which I would be raised in 6 months time after being hired > My conclusion: never accept verbal agreements again. Was the verbal agreement not honored? 2-3% after 6 months is not nothing. It seems your problem was accepted an offer 20% below what you should.

No. Verbal was 6 months: give raise. Actual was at 6/7 month be told that contingent on performance you would get a raise of 2-3% at 12 months. Being 20% lower than market rate is definitely the problem and a signal that they don't want to pay appropriately. Edit: if you don't value your worth appropriately from the get go, why would the employer?

> raise of 2-3% at 12 months

Ah, I missed that was delayed.

Re: How much does employee turnover really cost?

#207
post #82
post #56

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I've been to management seminars where they downplay the importance of money, saying that employees are mostly motivated by other factors. Then I talk to my co-workers, the ones that are quitting, and about half of them leave because they've been working for 2+ years without a raise. I worked at a company where a company decided to introduce a new management program (LEAN) into one department. That 16 person departme…

My last job gave me a ~2% raise the first year and a ~1% the next. I left shortly thereafter. Should have left after the first lousy raise. The previous job gave me back-to-back 1% raises. Left that job after two years as well. Should have left at the one year mark. I've been in my current job a few months. I'll stick around till the first annual raise cycle to see how they treat me. I don't think I'll give this empl…

You would have been better of talking to them, asking for more of a raise.

I got 60k raise over 2 years because I pushed for it.

Re: How much does employee turnover really cost?

#208

I've often been shocked at how a theoretically rational profit seeking business will happily throw millions down the drain rather than compensate an individual based on value. Ultimately I've concluded that although they may be greedy, most businesses don't make rational profit seeking decisions. They make decisions that stroke their ego, and sometimes their ego can't accept the value that certain employees bring to…

The free market hypothesis is that these companies will ultimately be unable to compete with companies that preserve that value.

What has yet to percolate into the consciousness of a lot of managers is that "web delivered" products are essentially constantly drawing on the engineers who keep them running and available. When they do, they will be able to more accurately assess revenue at risk based on personnel and losing valuable people will become a good reason to let a manager go.

Re: How much does employee turnover really cost?

#209
post #85
post #75

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I'm guessing few would book a management consultant simply telling to pay people more money - consultants who want a job instead have to explain how to motivate for free. But the people who share a lot of the blame for this idiocy and who have no good excuse are "heterodox economists" and TED talk presenters telling us how money doesn't motivate people past a certain point, or how it actually makes people less creati…

Money doesn't motivate people past, oh, a half million or so a year, maybe.

I can't tell for others but it'll absolutely motivate me to be able to buy my own plane or yacht.

Re: How much does employee turnover really cost?

#210
post #128
post #92

Earlier quoted context omitted.

What also amazes me is that the same heterodox crowd critiquing capitalism goes on to say "money doesn't make you happy", citing surveys of millionaires and billionaires who all say they'd be happy with 2x-3x their current net worth! I mean, not necessarily the same people say it, but the same press outlets for sure. But if it doesn't make you happy and you always want more, that desire must motivate you, right? Make…

Talk to some serial entrepreneurs. Many of them are already rich, and don't need to work, but they do it anyway. They're motivated by the challenge, not the money.

Do they give away all their money to charity?
Post reply on HN