Live data from Hacker News

I noticed some disturbing privacy defaults in Windows 10

jonathan.porta.codes

21–30 of 596 posts

Re: I noticed some disturbing privacy defaults in Windows 10

#21
post #8

Okay. Good to know. So, when I decide to upgrade from Windows XP, I will install the legal DVD I have of Windows 7 and stay with that for years! No Windows 8, 10, etc. for me until Microsoft makes some fantastically strong and solid statements about compatibility with old software, security, and privacy.

Worried about security and privacy...yet still uses Windows XP?

Re: I noticed some disturbing privacy defaults in Windows 10

#22
post #9

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> and why is it on by default? Because Cortana would be useless without it and that's a big user-facing feature of Windows 10.

Something like Cortana could have been built to work locally, using your own resources. But it wasn't. This was an opportunity to say "we're not like Siri and Google Now, we respect your privacy", but instead they built something just like them.

I imagine the resource costs would be too high to really make that worthwhile. The choice is probably between bad privacy settings, a bad personal assistant, or bad battery life and disk usage. Microsoft chose the option that would likely upset the smallest group of people.

Re: I noticed some disturbing privacy defaults in Windows 10

#23
post #8

Okay. Good to know. So, when I decide to upgrade from Windows XP, I will install the legal DVD I have of Windows 7 and stay with that for years! No Windows 8, 10, etc. for me until Microsoft makes some fantastically strong and solid statements about compatibility with old software, security, and privacy.

If you seriously are still using Windows XP on an internet-connected device, it is not like your biggest worry is sending data to Microsoft.

Re: I noticed some disturbing privacy defaults in Windows 10

#24

This goes along with the news that Windows 10 backs up your drive encryption key by default, and that Microsoft can use it to decrypt your data. In "good faith", of course.

I can see that one as a default for non-nefarious reasons. If you make it easy for non-specialist users to encrypt their machine, and there is no way for technical support to recover their data, you're going to inevitably end up with angry users. What's not as clear to me is whether you can change the default.

Re: I noticed some disturbing privacy defaults in Windows 10

#27
post #8

Okay. Good to know. So, when I decide to upgrade from Windows XP, I will install the legal DVD I have of Windows 7 and stay with that for years! No Windows 8, 10, etc. for me until Microsoft makes some fantastically strong and solid statements about compatibility with old software, security, and privacy.

You have four and a half years before Windows 7 "End of extended support" occurs on January 14, 2020. You might want to transition straight to linux or OSX.

Ref: http://windows.microsoft.com/en-us/windows/lifecycle

Re: I noticed some disturbing privacy defaults in Windows 10

#28
post #9

Of course you did. Large companies have no vested interest in building systems that do the "right thing" for you as defined by tech types like us who are arguably more sensitive on this subject than most people. They are building services that take your information and try to do something interesting enough with it to make it worthwhile...and why is it on by default? Because they want to make money off of the new fea…

> and why is it on by default? Because Cortana would be useless without it and that's a big user-facing feature of Windows 10.

How about a box that shows up the first time you try to invoke Cortana, asking if you want to turn this feature on.
Post reply on HN