Live data from Hacker News

Anti-Uber Taxi Protest Blocks Access to Paris’s Roissy Airport

bloomberg.com

21–30 of 62 posts

Re: Anti-Uber Taxi Protest Blocks Access to Paris’s Roissy Airport

#21
post #18

I feel that every time this issue gets discussed, it needs to have some background information provided, because quite frankly, taxi drivers in France suck. From my own personal experience, I have had the following incidents: 1) a taxi driver that took me the long way round from a train station to my home. Thinking I was a tourist, because of my accent, he basically tried to take me for a ride thinking I wouldn't not…

Does Uber actually solve any of these problems?

Arguably it could make them worse, there is a reason taxi drivers are licensed in most developed countries.

Re: Anti-Uber Taxi Protest Blocks Access to Paris’s Roissy Airport

#22
post #18

I feel that every time this issue gets discussed, it needs to have some background information provided, because quite frankly, taxi drivers in France suck. From my own personal experience, I have had the following incidents: 1) a taxi driver that took me the long way round from a train station to my home. Thinking I was a tourist, because of my accent, he basically tried to take me for a ride thinking I wouldn't not…

Does Uber actually solve any of these problems?

There is only one problem: anonymity. Yes, it does.

Re: Anti-Uber Taxi Protest Blocks Access to Paris’s Roissy Airport

#23

I feel that every time this issue gets discussed, it needs to have some background information provided, because quite frankly, taxi drivers in France suck. From my own personal experience, I have had the following incidents: 1) a taxi driver that took me the long way round from a train station to my home. Thinking I was a tourist, because of my accent, he basically tried to take me for a ride thinking I wouldn't not…

I live in Pittsburgh and the situation isn't much better. Taxi service effectively doesn't exist here. One newspaper wrote a "review" of sorts of Pittsburgh Yellow Cab and found that, for the most part, they wouldn't take you anywhere put the airport. The author would call them, ask for a ride to the airport, get a cab at his door immediately, then change his destination once he got in the car. They made him get out of the car every time.

Everyone I know who lived here before Uber/Lyft has a story about going out to the bars, calling a taxi, waiting two hours for it to come, and ending up walking two more hours home because the taxi never arrived. And I'm sure many more people have had the same experience and simple chosen to drive drunk. It's quite literally a publicly safety issue. Luckily Uber and Lyft came along two years ago and are now operating legally.

The #1 thing we've all learned from this debacle is that many, many cab companies are the scum of the earth. To be fair, though, some are still good. In Chicago, for example, you can hail a cab without even trying. You can go to the bathroom and find a cab waiting for you in the toilet. They are everywhere, they are reasonably priced, and they know the city a hell of a lot better than most Uber drivers. They continue to thrive because they are full time professionals who provide a better service than Uber and Lyft. That's a lesson the drivers in Paris and Pittsburgh need to learn.

Re: Anti-Uber Taxi Protest Blocks Access to Paris’s Roissy Airport

#24

I feel that every time this issue gets discussed, it needs to have some background information provided, because quite frankly, taxi drivers in France suck. From my own personal experience, I have had the following incidents: 1) a taxi driver that took me the long way round from a train station to my home. Thinking I was a tourist, because of my accent, he basically tried to take me for a ride thinking I wouldn't not…

In Greece we have a solution for this, as old as Uber but that works with the taxi drivers instead against them. Taxibeat is an app you can use to call taxis from your smartphone. You may choose which taxi you want from the list of nearby drivers. For every driver you see his/her name, plates number, car, reviews, whether he permits pets, speaks foreign languages, has wifi, permits smoking, can help people with disab…

I'll try next time I go to Greece, thanks for the tip. I was amazed at how cheap and easy to find taxi are in Greece. Add the evaluation on top of that (with the app you mention) : all problems solved without Uber's help. You need to put some pressure on taxis to get a correct service, either competition or evaluation (= competition with peers). Otherwise you end up with France's situation.

Re: Anti-Uber Taxi Protest Blocks Access to Paris’s Roissy Airport

#25
post #18

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Does Uber actually solve any of these problems?

Arguably it could make them worse, there is a reason taxi drivers are licensed in most developed countries.

Well drivers in Uber are generally paid less, so more incentive for them to make up for it in other ways.

Re: Anti-Uber Taxi Protest Blocks Access to Paris’s Roissy Airport

#26
post #20

I have been cheated by taxi drivers in every city where I lived for more than a few weeks. I am 100% in support of Uber.

Why, does Uber have some sort of guarantee that you are not getting ripped off? How do they address the problem? (I am genuinely asking, not trying to post a rhetorical question)

Actually yes. You're emailed a receipt with a map that includes the route you took. If you have any complaints, you can email them and they'll usually adjust your rate.

(I don't know if that's a formal guarantee but it's my experience)

Re: Anti-Uber Taxi Protest Blocks Access to Paris’s Roissy Airport

#27
post #20

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Why, does Uber have some sort of guarantee that you are not getting ripped off? How do they address the problem? (I am genuinely asking, not trying to post a rhetorical question)

Actually yes. You're emailed a receipt with a map that includes the route you took. If you have any complaints, you can email them and they'll usually adjust your rate. (I don't know if that's a formal guarantee but it's my experience)

And if the gps "isn't working"? I can see it could be easily gamed.

Re: Anti-Uber Taxi Protest Blocks Access to Paris’s Roissy Airport

#28
post #18

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Does Uber actually solve any of these problems?

Arguably it could make them worse, there is a reason taxi drivers are licensed in most developed countries.

Never had a bad experience with Uber. I heard they ruthlessly cut any driver with anything but good ratings.

Re: Anti-Uber Taxi Protest Blocks Access to Paris’s Roissy Airport

#29

I feel that every time this issue gets discussed, it needs to have some background information provided, because quite frankly, taxi drivers in France suck. From my own personal experience, I have had the following incidents: 1) a taxi driver that took me the long way round from a train station to my home. Thinking I was a tourist, because of my accent, he basically tried to take me for a ride thinking I wouldn't not…

I live in Pittsburgh and the situation isn't much better. Taxi service effectively doesn't exist here. One newspaper wrote a "review" of sorts of Pittsburgh Yellow Cab and found that, for the most part, they wouldn't take you anywhere put the airport. The author would call them, ask for a ride to the airport, get a cab at his door immediately , then change his destination once he got in the car. They made him get out…

Sounds like cabs need "body" cameras (interior cams that can't be turned off?) as much as cops do. It's an unbelievable shame, and a really terrible indictment of cab drivers' ability to do their job professionally.

I always thought the cabs in Philly were bad. Apparently they're decent, comparatively.

Re: Anti-Uber Taxi Protest Blocks Access to Paris’s Roissy Airport

#30

I feel that every time this issue gets discussed, it needs to have some background information provided, because quite frankly, taxi drivers in France suck. From my own personal experience, I have had the following incidents: 1) a taxi driver that took me the long way round from a train station to my home. Thinking I was a tourist, because of my accent, he basically tried to take me for a ride thinking I wouldn't not…

In Greece we have a solution for this, as old as Uber but that works with the taxi drivers instead against them. Taxibeat is an app you can use to call taxis from your smartphone. You may choose which taxi you want from the list of nearby drivers. For every driver you see his/her name, plates number, car, reviews, whether he permits pets, speaks foreign languages, has wifi, permits smoking, can help people with disab…

Ireland has something similar with Hailo. It's an absolute godsend.
Post reply on HN