Live data from Hacker News

Bicycle Parking Guidance System in Utrecht

bicycledutch.wordpress.com

21–26 of 26 posts

Re: Bicycle Parking Guidance System in Utrecht

#21
post #15
post #14

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Not at a busy train station in Holland. 200+ bikes are removed per day at Amsterdam's central train station for being parked outside of the designated bicycle parking areas (e.g. sidewalks, bridges, alongside the walls of the station). Even within the designated areas, you usually have to be parked in a bike rack or your lock will be cut and the bike removed. At busy stations it would be great to know which one of th…

Great argument. My country is much more relaxed when it comes to bike parking ( and stealing unfortunately ).

Probably because your country doesn't have as many bikes as Netherland does.

In most places in Netherland, parking wherever you like is no big deal, but there are places (train stations in particular) where bikes really need to be restricted, or there'd be no room for anything other than bikes.

It's the same as with cars: the occasional randomly parked car is not a big problem, but once you've got thousands of cars being parked all over the place, it becomes time to restrict them to designated parking spots. It's no different with bikes, except you need a lot more bikes to get to the point where they become a problem. Dutch cities have that many bikes.

Re: Bicycle Parking Guidance System in Utrecht

#22
post #11
post #9

Earlier quoted context omitted.

You can lock your bike however you want, but any experienced thief can remove those locks within minutes. No reasonable priced combination of locks keeps a thief from taking your bike. Luckily there are so many bikes in Utrecht and Amsterdam and especially around Central Station (10-20k), that chances that they take your bike are really low. Then if you use a good lock, one that takes an extra minute to break, and if…

Interesting. Certain animals use herding, the same strategy, against predators.

During my student days, I always made sure to check if the bike rack had a bike that looked prettier than mine and had worse locks.

Now that I ride a much more expensive cargo bike, I don't worry about it anymore, and it hasn't been stolen yet. Are cargo bikes less attractive? Hard to believe, but it seems to work.

Re: Bicycle Parking Guidance System in Utrecht

#26
post #7

Earlier quoted context omitted.

They use cameras for counting free spaces as they mention in the video. Nothing is said about security. Having cameras does not mean you have actual recording and surveillance.

(I'm the CTO of LumiGuide who developed this system). We're currently not using the system for video surveillance. Images from the cameras are only stored in memory for a short period of time while being processed by our CV algorithm. However, since bicycle theft is a common theme in the Netherlands, there's strong interest from municipalities for using our system for video surveillance. So we're now researching how…

All things considered, preventing theft via active physical structure, vs pursuing a thief AFTER the theft occurred seems to be preferable no?

Ask New Yorkers or Londoners how well video surveillance helps prevent or catch thieves..

[1] http://farm4.static.flickr.com/3024/5859909526_af35d1a4de_z....

[2] http://cdn.trendhunterstatic.com/thumbs/wave-by-joe-mattley....

[3] http://www.landscapeonline.com/products/images/prod_baa1e255...

Post reply on HN