Live data from Hacker News

Do we really want to fuse our minds together?

aeon.co

21–23 of 23 posts

Re: Do we really want to fuse our minds together?

#21
My questions are these:

If there are two minds, and they come in to this form of contact, which survives?

Would they be combined, leaving behind a new one which encompasses the qualities of both? Would they be combined at random?

Would they fight for dominance, leaving only the victor?

What would it feel like to have your consciousness do battle against another, become a new merged product, or for all intents and purposes dissolved?

And potentially, most importantly: What happens not to the consciousness of the other, but the memories? Will the new consciousness (formed via whichever method) have access to both?

Re: Do we really want to fuse our minds together?

#22
post #21

My questions are these: If there are two minds, and they come in to this form of contact, which survives? Would they be combined, leaving behind a new one which encompasses the qualities of both? Would they be combined at random? Would they fight for dominance, leaving only the victor? What would it feel like to have your consciousness do battle against another, become a new merged product, or for all intents and pur…

Reading a whole lot into fabricated memories, I imagine the new entities might have an entirely new set of memories of things that never happened.

Re: Do we really want to fuse our minds together?

#23
post #21

My questions are these: If there are two minds, and they come in to this form of contact, which survives? Would they be combined, leaving behind a new one which encompasses the qualities of both? Would they be combined at random? Would they fight for dominance, leaving only the victor? What would it feel like to have your consciousness do battle against another, become a new merged product, or for all intents and pur…

>If there are two minds, and they come in to this form of contact, which survives?

Neither? Both?

You get a bunch of new memories and some shifts in your personality. If the new memories and personality shift come suddenly, I think a lot of people would consider that a 'death'. If they come gradually, I suppose it is not a death. But either way, the new mind is going to have the memories of both, is going to 'think' that it is both, so if you want to claim that this new mind is actually one or the other of the original minds, you're probably going to find yourself arguing against the very subject you're making the claims about.

Post reply on HN