Live data from Hacker News

Grooveshark Shuts Down

grooveshark.com

21–30 of 283 posts

Re: Grooveshark Shuts Down

#21

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Perhaps any of the alternatives they listed on their site?

I found it interesting that they omitted two very obvious alternatives (Pandora and Slacker Radio). An overt snub, or simply no point in naming two of the most well known services?

Pandora doesn't provide the same service. They purely do "radio" and don't let you make playlists or play specific songs.

I can't explain Slacker's omission though.

Re: Grooveshark Shuts Down

#22

"As a part of a settlement agreement with the major record companies, we have agreed to cease operations immediately, wipe clean all of the record companies' copyrighted works and hand over ownership of this website, our mobile apps and intellectual property, including our patents and copyrights." Ouch. Sounds harsh. Wonder if they had to turn over the user data as well...

I wonder if they had to make such an apologetic statement as well.

Re: Grooveshark Shuts Down

#23
post #13

I'm sooooo glad I was paying a yearly fee for a VIP membership... and now I can't even get a copy of my playlists. All of those obscure songs I fell in love with are gone. I wonder if the information they turned over included my credit card billing data... Is it time to build a personal, private, self-hosted, open-source grooveshark clone?

You can already run your own streaming service with Subsonic today. What are you waiting for?

Re: Grooveshark Shuts Down

#24
post #9

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Same here. I've kind of dreaded this day and thought why is there no standardized 'playlist protocol' or playlist format that music services could share. This is like the 4th time I've had an old music service shut down and lost all my playlists with no migration path.

There is a standard (more-or-less) playlist format: m3u. The trick is convincing services to implement export of that information.

The problem may be that the m3u would contains artist name, song title, and position in the playlist, and even if you could export this, it would not be very robust to import somewhere else.

Re: Grooveshark Shuts Down

#25
post #13

I'm sooooo glad I was paying a yearly fee for a VIP membership... and now I can't even get a copy of my playlists. All of those obscure songs I fell in love with are gone. I wonder if the information they turned over included my credit card billing data... Is it time to build a personal, private, self-hosted, open-source grooveshark clone?

You could do some anonymous block-chain ledger type-service, really doubt that it would win over simply bit-torrent though, and ultimately I'm kind of biased since I really would prefer that real creators get to exercise their rights.

Re: Grooveshark Shuts Down

#27
I'm actually surprised it lasted so long. The business model was wrong from the beginning.

The thing is that in the early months/years, nothing was working as well as Grooveshark. If the website made the big record make so move, all the Grooveshark team's work was not in vein.

Re: Grooveshark Shuts Down

#28

"As a part of a settlement agreement with the major record companies, we have agreed to cease operations immediately, wipe clean all of the record companies' copyrighted works and hand over ownership of this website, our mobile apps and intellectual property, including our patents and copyrights." Ouch. Sounds harsh. Wonder if they had to turn over the user data as well...

I wonder if they had to make such an apologetic statement as well.

When you have a loaded gun down your throat...

Re: Grooveshark Shuts Down

#29
post #25
post #13

I'm sooooo glad I was paying a yearly fee for a VIP membership... and now I can't even get a copy of my playlists. All of those obscure songs I fell in love with are gone. I wonder if the information they turned over included my credit card billing data... Is it time to build a personal, private, self-hosted, open-source grooveshark clone?

You could do some anonymous block-chain ledger type-service, really doubt that it would win over simply bit-torrent though, and ultimately I'm kind of biased since I really would prefer that real creators get to exercise their rights.

What is this blind obsession with "THIS NEEDS A BLOCKCHAIN!!!!!!!"? There's nothing, absolutely nothing, in a system of storing playlists which needs decentralized canonical ordering. A blockchain is literally one of the most inefficient ways of storing data imaginable, and serves no purpose here other than a buzz word.

Re: Grooveshark Shuts Down

#30

I'm actually surprised it lasted so long. The business model was wrong from the beginning. The thing is that in the early months/years, nothing was working as well as Grooveshark. If the website made the big record make so move, all the Grooveshark team's work was not in vein.

Just a heads up, its vain, not vein. =))
Post reply on HN