Live data from Hacker News

Graph of Foursquare's Popularity After Removing Check-Ins

junkyardsam.com

21–30 of 178 posts

Re: Graph of Foursquare's Popularity After Removing Check-Ins

#21
Another non-scientific anecdote here. I attended a talk with maybe 150 attendees recently and the VC asked the audience who had ever used Foursquare. Then he asked who had used it in the past month.

Almost everyone had tried the product at some point, but very few were still actively using the product.

Re: Graph of Foursquare's Popularity After Removing Check-Ins

#22
post #13

Earlier quoted context omitted.

They built something that, while wildly popular for a while, was impossible to monetize successfully. Checkins just don't represent any value to anyone (at least, not that Foursquare could get anyone to pay for). The lesson here is that you can build something amazing and still fail if you can't turn it in to a business.

was impossible to monetize successfully No excuse. If you have a timestamped record of people's interactions with physical businesses and can't find a way to monetize that, sell to one of the thousands of people who can connect those dots pretty easily. And how do you possibly convince yourself that moving into an already-saturated market like ratings is going to help?

Has anyone been able to successfully monetize check-ins? It seems that if it were that straight forward to monetize as you suggest, someone would have done this by now. Even Facebook's check-in system seems to have faded in popularity as far as I can tell.

Re: Graph of Foursquare's Popularity After Removing Check-Ins

#23
They pivoted to become the location data powering major mobile apps (ex. Twitter). Dealing with small business to monetize is hard. You can't charge the consumer because you need the checkin and to get enough of a sales team on the ground in the SMB market is astronomical. If you ask me if they should bring back checkin to core 4sq app, not sure if it's fully relevant anymore. Their new ad platform pretty much just monitors you as you walk. So geoloc ads. I like it, and if they get enough SMB advertisers they can be a good acquisition target.

Re: Graph of Foursquare's Popularity After Removing Check-Ins

#24
post #9

I'm still astounded by this. They had a #&$%ing verb . That is the #&$%ing gold standard of presence. "I'm going to foursquare this." I actually heard real human beings say this. If your app name has become a verb the last thing you ever want to do is refocus . If you want to go to a ratings app like they apparently did (because... uh... that's not a saturated space or anything?...) then you make another app and leav…

> wildly successful app

Foursquare didn't agree. They didn't pivot just because it's the cool thing to do.

Re: Graph of Foursquare's Popularity After Removing Check-Ins

#28
post #19

Earlier quoted context omitted.

"If your app name has become a verb the last thing you ever want to do is refocus." What? If you don't make money, you will go bankrupt . You can be a verb all you want, if it doesn't make money, it doesn't matter .

If your monetisation attempt kills your app, you will go bankrupt and it is a failure.

You have two options. One will leave you bankrupt within a year or two with probability 1.0 and one will leave you bankrupt within year or two with probability 0.8. Which would you chose?

Re: Graph of Foursquare's Popularity After Removing Check-Ins

#29
It looks more like a long and steady decline that has slowed somewhat since releasing Swarm.

https://www.google.com/trends/explore#q=swarm%20app%2C%20fou...

Note that you should sum the two together to be fair, meaning they haven't declined much since a year ago.

Re: Graph of Foursquare's Popularity After Removing Check-Ins

#30
post #25

As a scientist, the missing Y-axis makes one half of me laugh out in derision and the other half cry out in despair. Get your axes and scales right people. WTF.

https://www.google.com/trends/explore#q=Foursquare

"Numbers represent search interest relative to the highest point on the chart. If at most 10% of searches for the given region and time frame were for "pizza," we'd consider this 100. This doesn't convey absolute search volume."

Post reply on HN