Live data from Hacker News

Google announces Android for Work

googleforwork.blogspot.com

21–30 of 174 posts

Re: Google announces Android for Work

#21
post #16
post #9

So we're all going to code, write, etc. on four inch screens? Seriously why hasn't someone made a smart phone that "transforms" into a larger screen form factor when connected to a monitor? I could see Android phones doing this. I could never imagine iOS doing it-- Apple would never cannibalize Mac like that, and iOS is too jailed for anything "real." Of course apps would have to support it. But those that didn't cou…

> Seriously why hasn't someone made a smart phone that "transforms" into a larger screen form factor when connected to a monitor? It has been done repeatedly. Motorola and Ubuntu come to mind. Both were failures. I don't want my phone to turn into a desktop. Desktops are all about muscle, massive storage, gigabit connections, etc. Phones are about saving battery life.

And phones in nearly all cases are limited by thermal profile. That's what keeps you from running at full tilt on a mobile device even when plugged in.

Re: Google announces Android for Work

#22

> a dedicated work profile that isolates and protects work data Oh wow, can this be used to just create a separate profile for every app? That way I can run Uber or Line without giving them every permission to everything? This is the biggest reason I do not install apps. Every "famous" app requests so many permissions it's just stupid. And not to mention the weirdness of some of them, like "WiFi Device Information".…

Isn't there an app that restricts these permissions? I believe your phone has to be rooted for it to work though.

Re: Google announces Android for Work

#23
post #7

I tried to find any info about license or repos and couldn't find anything. Unlike Samsung's Knox, which is FOSS, how can this be even remotely secure if it is closed source? Seems that Google is full on the "Extinguish" phase with Android. edit: amazing that I'm being downvoted for stating facts yet nobody replies to me.

The fact of the matter, is that Google usually publishes their source. They're just a bit slow at it. Most versions of android ship in binary form before source is released.

yet, they are just phasing all the important bits to privative code. Of course, this Android for work goes with Google Play, and guess what, it is privative, of course.

Just a step more into their "Extinguish" phase.

Re: Google announces Android for Work

#24
post #6

I love the name "Google Play for Work."

Awkward naming aside, it seems like this is very similar to what Apple did in iOS2.0 with iOS Enterprise Developer program.

"Google Play for Work allows businesses to securely deploy and manage apps across all users running Android for Work, simplifying the process of distributing apps to employees and ensuring that IT approves every deployed app"

Leaving aside exactly how it's done, the end goal is the same: If I am Example Inc's CTO, I can now have my staff develop Example Inc Android apps that are neither sold on Play store nor side-loaded.

Apple requires running your own App Store server, I'm fairly certain Google will probably make it more cloud centric.

Glad they're finally stepping up on this front.

Re: Google announces Android for Work

#25
post #9

So we're all going to code, write, etc. on four inch screens? Seriously why hasn't someone made a smart phone that "transforms" into a larger screen form factor when connected to a monitor? I could see Android phones doing this. I could never imagine iOS doing it-- Apple would never cannibalize Mac like that, and iOS is too jailed for anything "real." Of course apps would have to support it. But those that didn't cou…

> So we're all going to code, write, etc. on four inch screens?

I have an Android device with a 12" screen. Android isn't just on phones.

Re: Google announces Android for Work

#27
post #14

> a dedicated work profile that isolates and protects work data Oh wow, can this be used to just create a separate profile for every app? That way I can run Uber or Line without giving them every permission to everything? This is the biggest reason I do not install apps. Every "famous" app requests so many permissions it's just stupid. And not to mention the weirdness of some of them, like "WiFi Device Information".…

Actually that's the reason I use iOS

I honestly don't understand why this is down-voted, more "sandboxed" apps is one of the reasons I use iOS as well.

Re: Google announces Android for Work

#28

> a dedicated work profile that isolates and protects work data Oh wow, can this be used to just create a separate profile for every app? That way I can run Uber or Line without giving them every permission to everything? This is the biggest reason I do not install apps. Every "famous" app requests so many permissions it's just stupid. And not to mention the weirdness of some of them, like "WiFi Device Information".…

Isn't there an app that restricts these permissions? I believe your phone has to be rooted for it to work though.

XPrivacy: https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=biz.bokhorst.x...

App Ops: https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=droidmate.appo...

Also, if your phone isn't rooted, is it really yours?

Re: Google announces Android for Work

#30
post #14

> a dedicated work profile that isolates and protects work data Oh wow, can this be used to just create a separate profile for every app? That way I can run Uber or Line without giving them every permission to everything? This is the biggest reason I do not install apps. Every "famous" app requests so many permissions it's just stupid. And not to mention the weirdness of some of them, like "WiFi Device Information".…

Actually that's the reason I use iOS

[deleted]
Post reply on HN