Live data from Hacker News

Diaspora social network cannot stop IS posts

bbc.com

21–30 of 101 posts

Re: Diaspora social network cannot stop IS posts

#21
post #15

I don't like what these guys are posting about but should we really abandon freedom of speech over it? Wouldn't that be an example of the terrorists winning?

The problem is that not all countries consider this free speech. If you're hosting a Diaspora pod in the UK, then having this material on your system is considered terrorism.

Re: Diaspora social network cannot stop IS posts

#22
If they set up their own pod then they can spread whatever propaganda they want. Earlier in the year IS made the foolish mistake of setting up on a Red Matrix server administered by someone who opposed them, and they promptly got kicked off.

https://libertypod.org/posts/7a778c00f3a201319eb700163efe12c...

Re: Diaspora social network cannot stop IS posts

#23
post #17

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> I think it's a bit weird that instead of using this to promote their values (Decentralization, Freedom, Privacy as mentioned on their landing page [0]) they are essentially pressuring pod admins to take down the content. Yeah that's probably because the ISIS is known for suicide bombings, cutting off heads, video taping it so that the families and friends of the victim can see how gruesome their loved one died, kil…

So it's "Freedom of Speech" (but only if we like it)?

To reiterate:

* Freedom of speech is freedom of restriction from government.

* Calls to violence and videos of murder are not covered by the 1st amendment.

Re: Diaspora social network cannot stop IS posts

#24
I've been thinking about this type of problem for a while now. One possible solution would be a requirement for the content to pay for its 'right to be visible' or 'right of existence'. Rates for right of existence could vary based on network sentiment/karma regarding the content. Karma could be earned by users providing storage or purchased in bulk for a fee.

Re: Diaspora social network cannot stop IS posts

#26
Scientists have ethics committees, but what do we turn to in these situations? Undoubtedly, many of us would argue that free speech is one of the best things that has come out of the internet, and open source and decentralised software is often created for this very reason. On the other hand, it gives extremists a platform for communication. It's a fine balancing act and I'm not sure there is enough debate around these sorts of issues.

Re: Diaspora social network cannot stop IS posts

#30
post #9

This is like saying "E-Mail cannot stop X mails" or "XMPP cannot stop X chats", which is pretty obvious. The whole point of a decentralized service like Diaspora is that it can't be completely censored. Internet providers could partially block the access to pods that don't censor this kind of content, but then they could setup their own Diaspora pod in a Tor hidden services...

Doesn't it operate as a social network, where some content is available publicly? That would make it a bit different than email...
Post reply on HN