Live data from Hacker News

Dark Stalking on Facebook

pjf.id.au

21–24 of 24 posts

Re: Dark Stalking on Facebook

#21
post #4
post #3

Earlier quoted context omitted.

They may not want you to know. They may have had a reason for not telling you about the event (i.e. they're going to a party thrown by your ex-girlfriend). There's a number of social reasons people don't generally let people know everything they do.

If they don't want things published, they shouldn't be publishing them on Facebook. Nobody should be using Facebook as their personal calendar. Also, if a detail of how Facebook handles event queries is enough to "keep you up at night", how the hell do you handle nuclear proliferation in the CIS states?

> If they don't want things published, they shouldn't be publishing them on Facebook. Nobody should be using Facebook as their personal calendar.

Most folks I know on facebook tend to use it to communicate with their friends. All of their friends are in one simple place, and they can arrange events easily.

They may not be aware of what they're doing until its too late or they read an article like the OP.

Its just ease of use that people have grown accustomed to.

Re: Dark Stalking on Facebook

#22
post #2

Why does knowing friends' past events cross a moral boundary?!

The moral boundary is that most users would assume that this information would not be public because they themselves cannot see other peoples' information through the web ui.

I don't write much info to facebook because I haven't taken the time to understand their security and application model. I can't figure out what the knobs do, or who can see what. now I've got to weigh the utility of seeing all my past events (which is actually pretty cool) against the creepiness that friends can see the same info.

These would be juicy queries:

* which events for which I was not invited to, but that many other friends of mine were?

* when a friend declines events that I attend, which event did they accept/attend instead (bonus points for events that I throw)?

As mentioned elsewhere, this might result in some hurt feelings. Also, it would be creepy to the muggles to know that such magic back-doors exist.

Re: Dark Stalking on Facebook

#23
post #2

Why does knowing friends' past events cross a moral boundary?!

Not just past events, but past events you/they have DECLINED.

If you don't want people to see that you have declined an FB event, you should 'remove yourself from it' (I forget the exact terminology) rather than declining it.

Perhaps the fact that these are distinct actions is a problem with the FB event RSVP interface.

Re: Dark Stalking on Facebook

#24

Once you put in in the public sector of the Internet it is always there. If people always operate under this assumption they will be fine (yes I realize in certain cases information may not be cached before it is removed.) You shouldn't enter any information on a social networking site that you don't want everyone to see, no matter what the privacy settings tell you. Personally I am wary of sending sensitive informat…

They'd never use the term, it would be a PR disaster, but maybe "blatency controls" would be more truthful, as in "How blatent do you want to be?".
Post reply on HN