Live data from Hacker News

Network Instability in NYC2 on July 29, 2014

digitalocean.com

21–22 of 22 posts

Re: Network Instability in NYC2 on July 29, 2014

#21
post #7

So an RE failed and flipped to the secondary. They run mlag from the agg layer to their tors. Said mlag had a grey failure. The time to recovery was predominantly fault detection. After detection they upgraded the os on the known good switch. Presumably this bounced, affecting remaining traffic. After upgrade they downed the failed switch, shifting traffic to the known good. Moderately interesting that they run every…

They're probably learning that MLAG should be avoided unless absolutely necessary. But providing common L2 domains across cabinets is probably something they "need." There's much less to go wrong with ECMP at L3. Stateful networking components frighten me.

Not knowing anything about their infrastructure Id guess that they're using vlan tags for customer isolation. They'd want customer instances spread among racks, based on instance type etc. Going to in house/vxlan/nvgre encap certainly looks better suited, but still has a high bar to entry.

Re: Network Instability in NYC2 on July 29, 2014

#22

Earlier quoted context omitted.

They're probably learning that MLAG should be avoided unless absolutely necessary. But providing common L2 domains across cabinets is probably something they "need." There's much less to go wrong with ECMP at L3. Stateful networking components frighten me.

Not knowing anything about their infrastructure Id guess that they're using vlan tags for customer isolation. They'd want customer instances spread among racks, based on instance type etc. Going to in house/vxlan/nvgre encap certainly looks better suited, but still has a high bar to entry.

You guys sound like you know a lot about these types of networking protocols. Can you recommend a decent summary of currently available approaches to relatively dynamic private link layer network topology provision suitable for cross-cabinet (or even cross-site) virtualized infrastructures and their drawbacks? For instance, I've been seeing Open vSwitch gaining popularity.
Post reply on HN