Live data from Hacker News

Microsoft’s New CEO Needs An Editor

mondaynote.com

21–27 of 27 posts

Re: Microsoft’s New CEO Needs An Editor

#21

Essentially, this article is complaining that Nadella is playing politics. When you're dependent on mass complicity, boasting airy platitudes and leaving the plan publicly undefined (that is, saying a bunch of stuff that's impossible to disagree with) is the only way to succeed. You don't become CEO of Microsoft by being a political ignoramus. Nadella knew this would go public and is using it to project the image the…

Absolutely true. Nadella knows exactly what he's trying to say, but he has to fluff it up to avoid ambush.

But at his level, you're gonna get ambushed by someone no matter what you write.

Re: Microsoft’s New CEO Needs An Editor

#22
Whoever wrote this article is a bit delusional. Every CEO letter in Silicon Valley is full of ridiculous cliches and platitudes. Why did the author pick this particular CEO for censure? I can think of only two reasons: 1) Nadella is foreign looking 2) Microsoft is everyone's favorite punching bag.

Have you read some of the communication coming out of Facebook and Salesforce? Jesus, just walk around Facebook's campus and you'll see ridiculous motivational posters that say things like, "DEMAND EXCELLENCE!"

Re: Microsoft’s New CEO Needs An Editor

#23

Whoever wrote this article is a bit delusional. Every CEO letter in Silicon Valley is full of ridiculous cliches and platitudes. Why did the author pick this particular CEO for censure? I can think of only two reasons: 1) Nadella is foreign looking 2) Microsoft is everyone's favorite punching bag. Have you read some of the communication coming out of Facebook and Salesforce? Jesus, just walk around Facebook's campus…

Why did the author pick this particular CEO for censure?

Because the "whoever" who wrote the article is Jean-Louis Gassée, who as an executive of Apple and Be, Inc had half a lifetime of an adversarial relationship with Microsoft.

Re: Microsoft’s New CEO Needs An Editor

#24
post #6

Sounds like the new CEO is very good at "fluffing" up his word count. He says a lot, but says very little.

That's because Microsoft has now become IBM and what they say or plan to do is now irrelevant. He is the perfect CEO for this stage in Microsoft's journey.

Re: Microsoft’s New CEO Needs An Editor

#25
post #21

Essentially, this article is complaining that Nadella is playing politics. When you're dependent on mass complicity, boasting airy platitudes and leaving the plan publicly undefined (that is, saying a bunch of stuff that's impossible to disagree with) is the only way to succeed. You don't become CEO of Microsoft by being a political ignoramus. Nadella knew this would go public and is using it to project the image the…

Absolutely true. Nadella knows exactly what he's trying to say, but he has to fluff it up to avoid ambush. But at his level, you're gonna get ambushed by someone no matter what you write.

Perhaps this was why Steve was so exciting. :) Of course, it caught up to the company in courts, but ...

Re: Microsoft’s New CEO Needs An Editor

#26
post #4

I really enjoyed "Microsoft is the Very Antithesis of Strategy" that was linked to by this Monday Note: http://techpinions.com/microsoft-is-the-very-antithesis-of-s...

Really, I can see some bad assessments in it. #3 and #4 are easily refuted via IE and Xbox. The Bing example in #1 is pretty bad as without Bing they wouldn't have had a partner like Facebook and they would have struggled to find services for Windows phone and tablets.

Also for a article picking on statements from others, statements like "Surface is an attempt to pretend Apple didn’t solve the tablet problem when they introduced the iPad. " seems plain stupid since Android has taken the lead from Apple and I don't think anybody believes the tablet "problem" is solved yet

Post reply on HN