Live data from Hacker News

Why Google Made Its Self-Driving Car So Darn Cute

techcrunch.com

21–30 of 80 posts

Re: Why Google Made Its Self-Driving Car So Darn Cute

#21
post #8

What is the ANCAP rating for these? Cute they might be but they look to be quite flimsy in construction. Maybe that's one of the reasons why they are so slow, not just to avoid the risks of high speed impact but also so that they don't have to be tested right alongside the output of the rest of the automobile industry. That gives google time to perfect the software in a real world traffic without all the costs and co…

I doubt they have done the ANCAP/NCAP ratings (given the recent story about how lots of AUDI models are not NCAP rated it could be a while).

There is a tubular 'roll cage' type of thing going on with it, reminiscent of rally cars and kit cars. Given that rally cars have roll cages and normal cars do not, I for one look on a roll cage as a good thing, even if the rest of the box is prototype bits of plastic.

Part of a safety rating is the effect a car has on pedestrians. People can get killed by hood ornaments even at a relatively low speed. To date very few cars have been specifically designed with pedestrian safety in mind. One of the few was the Austin Metro and that was a long time ago. It does look as if the Google people have thought of pedestrian safety - it is a big part of the self driving concept and it also appears to be part of the implementation. I wouldn't be at all surprised if the final implementation of the driver-less car is in a whole new level of safety compared to regular cars with the difference being like the difference between 'tame' and 'wild' animals.

Re: Why Google Made Its Self-Driving Car So Darn Cute

#22
post #13
post #12

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Seriously, your big problem with self driving cars is you think a giant laser on top is ugly?

I can kind of understand that. Cars are not only a motor on 4 wheels. Design is one of the most important aspects when man building and selling cars, so it is not strange that people think of the camera as something that doesn't fit. Until Tesla came and showed an electrical car that actually DID attract car / driving fans, the majority of people wouldn't consider an electrical car because most of them were plain ugl…

> I think the real breakthrough will be achieved by a completely redesigned and appealing car.

Hopefully, on a Tesla. Tesla range and safety design + self driving. I'd pay six figures for that.

Re: Why Google Made Its Self-Driving Car So Darn Cute

#23
post #19
post #17

Being a programmer, a sci-fi fan, and always excited by new developments even from a young age, I thought I'd never reach a time where I would find it difficult to accept new technology. Clones, immortality, interstellar travel, tech-enabled telepathy, bring it on. I now realise that sitting in a self-driving car will cause me to press on the ghost brake pedal while sweating with anxiety every time it needs to slow d…

> I now realise that sitting in a self-driving car will cause me to press on the ghost brake pedal while sweating with anxiety No it won't. :) In next versions you will probably not be facing the road anyway. Do you "ghost brake" when driving in the back of a limousine?

Hah - when travelling in the passenger seat I often see my dad try and brake when I leave it a little later than he would.

He also grips on to the handle above the window.

Re: Why Google Made Its Self-Driving Car So Darn Cute

#24
post #8

What is the ANCAP rating for these? Cute they might be but they look to be quite flimsy in construction. Maybe that's one of the reasons why they are so slow, not just to avoid the risks of high speed impact but also so that they don't have to be tested right alongside the output of the rest of the automobile industry. That gives google time to perfect the software in a real world traffic without all the costs and co…

Pretty sure while they may look flimsy, these care are anything but. I believe there are several micro-cars on sale now that have a very safe inner structures as well as advanced safety features despite looking "cute". Example: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Smart_%28automobile%29#Safety

Re: Why Google Made Its Self-Driving Car So Darn Cute

#25
post #19
post #17

Being a programmer, a sci-fi fan, and always excited by new developments even from a young age, I thought I'd never reach a time where I would find it difficult to accept new technology. Clones, immortality, interstellar travel, tech-enabled telepathy, bring it on. I now realise that sitting in a self-driving car will cause me to press on the ghost brake pedal while sweating with anxiety every time it needs to slow d…

> I now realise that sitting in a self-driving car will cause me to press on the ghost brake pedal while sweating with anxiety No it won't. :) In next versions you will probably not be facing the road anyway. Do you "ghost brake" when driving in the back of a limousine?

Do you "ghost brake" when driving in the back of a limousine?

Yep. I'm frequently uncomfortable when someone else is driving. There's a handful of people in the world who don't make me uncomfortable when driving... my parents, a few friends who drive "safely"... Oh, and taxi drivers (where somehow my lizard brain appreciates that though I am not in control, the creature that IS in control has 100+ times more experience of driving than me, and is therefore unarguably a better driver). Though not all taxi drivers - some of the minicab (as opposed to licensed black cab) drivers make me nervous.

So for this technology to work for me and not make me nervous each time I step into it, I'll have to really get to trust it.

I'm not sure putting a cute face on the front of the car is gonna do that for me, but the effort is definitely worthwhile.

Re: Why Google Made Its Self-Driving Car So Darn Cute

#26
post #8

What is the ANCAP rating for these? Cute they might be but they look to be quite flimsy in construction. Maybe that's one of the reasons why they are so slow, not just to avoid the risks of high speed impact but also so that they don't have to be tested right alongside the output of the rest of the automobile industry. That gives google time to perfect the software in a real world traffic without all the costs and co…

It looks conceptually similar to the Smart Fourtwo in size and design, and that car managed to score 4/5 on the ANCAP. So I don't see any reason why this car shouldn't manage the same.

Re: Why Google Made Its Self-Driving Car So Darn Cute

#27
post #2

I can't get beyond the second slide. Possibly because > TypeError: a.adsReloadAd is not a function Edit: Oh, I can if I turn adBlock off.

Totally hate the format... what is this, Buzzfeed meets TechCrunch?

As if TechCrunch's main stream of news wasn't "mainstream" enough already...

Re: Why Google Made Its Self-Driving Car So Darn Cute

#28
As my old AI lecturer put it "If a person driving a car runs over a person that driver is at fault, if an AI driving a car runs over a person that AI will probably never be used again in any car.", so it's interesting to see the 'cute' approach they are taking to, as the article says "minimize the fear".

Re: Why Google Made Its Self-Driving Car So Darn Cute

#29
post #8

What is the ANCAP rating for these? Cute they might be but they look to be quite flimsy in construction. Maybe that's one of the reasons why they are so slow, not just to avoid the risks of high speed impact but also so that they don't have to be tested right alongside the output of the rest of the automobile industry. That gives google time to perfect the software in a real world traffic without all the costs and co…

As a low-speed vehicle capped at 25mph, the car is exempt from most federal regulation.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Low-speed_vehicle#United_State...

Post reply on HN