Live data from Hacker News

SaaS Builders: Beware The Free Trial

derickbailey.com

21–30 of 49 posts

Re: SaaS Builders: Beware The Free Trial

#21
I once used a SaaS—or whatever you call the abstraction on top of that—and ended up paying $80 for a “sample” EC2 instance of theirs that was just idling, after I had activated it a month earlier.

Soured me on trying out new platform services pretty damn hard.

Re: SaaS Builders: Beware The Free Trial

#22

I'm currently thinking that for my next SAAS project it's going to be pay up front with a 30 day money back guarantee. I've done freemium and 30 day trials and the data I got early made me think that people would convert and they didn't even though they would use the product every day. Maybe my pricing was bad or my sales technique was terrible. I don't know. What I do know is if you price something up front you'll k…

This is a good compromise -- certainly better than the take-your-credit-card free trial that surprises you with a charge. 'Money back guarantee' has worked for a long time, particularly in pre-internet days.

What is really funny is when you think about it, we all buy things without trying them every single day. We make assumptions that a product will work or that it can be replaced/refunded when it doesn't.

Surprisingly, in the online world we think everything is different and that nobody buys things without a free trial of some kind, but over and over again I see products and services that sell without a free trial.

I think it's doing early stage products a disservice to assume you have to have a free trial to make money. When you are proving out if a product will sell, you need to know if people will pay you money for it, not if they are casually interested in trying it.

If it don't make dollars, it don't make sense.

Re: SaaS Builders: Beware The Free Trial

#23
post #3

It really depends on the market. My prior project went well with 10 day free trials. People installed it, it did what they wanted, so they kept it. Current project...trials are popular, but getting people engaged in the trials is tough. Lots of engagement diet day..then it drops sharply off,many no amount of emailing bumpsup the return rate about a percent or two. I think it depends on the market, the product and the…

Why 10 days, just a nice round number? (don't mean that disparagingly) or was there some statistical basis for it? A lot of trials I see are 14 or 30 day, 10 not so much.

Just a guess, but maybe that it always gives the user a full calendar Mon-Fri to check it out?

Re: SaaS Builders: Beware The Free Trial

#24

The problem about drawing any broader conclusions here is it appears to boil down to "Don't offer a 90 day free trial in the podcast hosting business because most customers run their course in 56 days" Not sure it really tells us anything about the effectiveness of a free trial for x days and pay vs a charge now with a 30 day money back guarantee

true! i tried to make that point at the very end of the post... maybe should have emphasized it more

I enjoyed reading the post, and was relieved to see the caveat at the end, but when you shout things like:

> "Beware The Free Trial ... SaaS builders! BEWARE!"

I don't think it's just a lack of emphasis... It's the presence of jumping to conclusions and offering that as a general lesson.

Re: SaaS Builders: Beware The Free Trial

#25
post #19

I think the big caveat here is that the space you're in makes it particularly dangerous to offer a free trial. In other words, there are spaces where those costs are far more negligible, such that you could certainly afford 500+ abandoned free trials to convert 1 paid customer.

In other words, you need to understand your acquisition costs and your conversion funnel. Then you can decide what form of a trial--if any--makes sense for you.

Re: SaaS Builders: Beware The Free Trial

#26
post #25
post #19

I think the big caveat here is that the space you're in makes it particularly dangerous to offer a free trial. In other words, there are spaces where those costs are far more negligible, such that you could certainly afford 500+ abandoned free trials to convert 1 paid customer.

In other words, you need to understand your acquisition costs and your conversion funnel. Then you can decide what form of a trial--if any--makes sense for you.

Right, and maybe that's tough to do from the onset, but as you learn those lessons you can and should adjust.

So if your conversion rate is X and you offer Y and you're losing money, you probably need to reduce what Y costs (or can cost) you.

Re: SaaS Builders: Beware The Free Trial

#27

I'm struggling to see why bandwidth is costing you so much. We have a dedicated server with 10tb bandwidth on 1gbps port for under $100 a month. Also, if the podcasts are failing they can't be using much bandwidth? I think this is cognitive dissonance, you're complaining about free users costing you a lot of money in bandwidth yet apparently they are all failing (very few listeners?)

I'm serving files from Amazon S3. This gives me the benefit of world class storage and streaming, without having to own / run the servers myself. Bandwidth from them is "cheap" at $0.12/GB... but with an average podcast of 30 minutes being 25meg file, an episode with 1,000 downloads is 2.5GB of bandwidth. i have a customer that averages 20,000 downloads per episode, and a bunch of others with close to 1,000 downloads…

Without exploring what you do too deeply, is there a way for you to monetize the freemium/free trial accounts? Can you apply some advertising to them automatically unless/until they upgrade?

Re: SaaS Builders: Beware The Free Trial

#28
post #9

Anyone know a good collection of SaaS articles like this? We're about to launch our first SaaS service and would love some battle hardened good practices.

As a marketer working with SaaS companies, I would caution you against reading articles like this.

They make big generalizations (free trials are bad!) based on hindsight reasoning and very few data. For every article you find that says you should do X, you can just as easily find one that says you should NOT do X.

With that said, two good sources of information are Jason Cohen[0] and Patrick McKenzie[1].

[0] http://blog.asmartbear.com/ [1] http://www.kalzumeus.com/blog/

And if you're looking to have someone in your corner who has done this, give me a shout!

Re: SaaS Builders: Beware The Free Trial

#29
Whatever you do, just make sure that cancelling really is easy if you expect them to give you their credit card because consumers beware of scammy 30 days moneyback guarantee that are designed to make you jump through so many hoops that most give up, or worse, continues billing you until you manage to.

An example, eFax: a black hole of pure evil when it comes to cancelling: anyone who ever tried wants to murder kittens afterwards. Whatever you do, never ever ever signup for that thing. Seriously. (At least in the U.S. there is the chat and twitter options, but in Europe, you're basically screwed unless you cancel your credit card).

Re: SaaS Builders: Beware The Free Trial

#30
post #28
post #9

Anyone know a good collection of SaaS articles like this? We're about to launch our first SaaS service and would love some battle hardened good practices.

As a marketer working with SaaS companies, I would caution you against reading articles like this. They make big generalizations (free trials are bad!) based on hindsight reasoning and very few data. For every article you find that says you should do X, you can just as easily find one that says you should NOT do X. With that said, two good sources of information are Jason Cohen[0] and Patrick McKenzie[1]. [0] http://…

Thanks for the info and the offer!
Post reply on HN