Live data from Hacker News

Man Denies He's Bitcoin Founder

hosted.ap.org

21–30 of 123 posts

Re: Man Denies He's Bitcoin Founder

#21
So Newsweek, returning to print newsstands after several years, runs with a cover story that is debunked on the internet in a matter of hours?

Is this not a perfect metaphor for the print journalism industry? Can we bet on when Print Newsweek 2.0 also goes belly-up?

Re: Man Denies He's Bitcoin Founder

#22
post #4

Man, it's a good thing HN didn't fly off the handle and start obsessing over this man and try to invade his privacy using the excuse that NewsWeek started it and that makes it okay. That would've been pretty embarrassing.

That was not my impression of the HN comments in the least. Most HN commenters seemed to think it was an egregious invasion of his privacy from what I read.

Re: Man Denies He's Bitcoin Founder

#23
Man says X, later claims not X. Bitcoin enthusiasts declare total victory for not X, call for tar and feathering of company that published X.

No harm in giving this some time and seeing if "Man Denies He's Bitcoin Founder" turns out to filed next to[1] "Man Denies Connection to Olympic Bombing" or next to "OJ Announces Search For Real Killers".

[1] pedantry disclaimer: not meant as perfect analogies

Re: Man Denies He's Bitcoin Founder

#24
post #17

I will forever mark the name, Leah McGrath Goodman and Newsweek editorial staff in my mind as a toxic journalist and TMZ-styled publication after this event. Granted, I don't think Leah McGrath Goodman and Newsweek did anything illegal by breaking this story. I don't think it's wrong for Goodman to attempt to contact Satoshi's relatives over the phone. What really crossed the line for me was Leah McGrath Goodman and…

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bill_Gates%27s_house

Bad example.

Re: Man Denies He's Bitcoin Founder

#26
post #9

Earlier quoted context omitted.

If by fallout you mean tons of revenue, then I agree.

I'm thinking more like a huge lawsuit.

Libel? Slander? Where's the suit? If this guy actually is Satoshi the last thing in the world he wants is to be on a witness stand.

Opening a case against Newsweek lets them subpoena all sorts of records that they aren't entitled to with out a case, primarily because the truth is a defence to slander / libel, and if this guy loses then he's forever Satoshi.

Also it's going to be pretty difficult to prove that he suffered damages from the article.

Re: Man Denies He's Bitcoin Founder

#27
post #15

From article "exclusive two-hour interview" but then no link?

I don't think they meant video interview. I read somewhere else that he went to the AP offices and they talked for two hours. So interview in the sense of reporter talking to person.

It did seem a rather short article for that amount of talking.

Re: Man Denies He's Bitcoin Founder

#28
post #17

I will forever mark the name, Leah McGrath Goodman and Newsweek editorial staff in my mind as a toxic journalist and TMZ-styled publication after this event. Granted, I don't think Leah McGrath Goodman and Newsweek did anything illegal by breaking this story. I don't think it's wrong for Goodman to attempt to contact Satoshi's relatives over the phone. What really crossed the line for me was Leah McGrath Goodman and…

Why are you discussing Leah's article when this article is discussing something completely different (the fact that Leah's article is wrong)?

You can go to the post of the Newsweek article and get a billion comments exactly like yours. It is pointless to keep harping about it in every related discussion...

Re: Man Denies He's Bitcoin Founder

#29
post #17

I will forever mark the name, Leah McGrath Goodman and Newsweek editorial staff in my mind as a toxic journalist and TMZ-styled publication after this event. Granted, I don't think Leah McGrath Goodman and Newsweek did anything illegal by breaking this story. I don't think it's wrong for Goodman to attempt to contact Satoshi's relatives over the phone. What really crossed the line for me was Leah McGrath Goodman and…

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bill_Gates%27s_house Bad example.

Bill Gates spends millions a year on personal security. What if this guy is not actually worth millions of dollars?

Re: Man Denies He's Bitcoin Founder

#30
According to the Newsweek article this Satoshi Nakamoto:

1. Dropped all contact with the reporter when the topic of Bitcoin was brought up over email.

2. Called the cops when the reporter went to his house to ask him about Bitcoin.

3. Said to the reporter: "I am no longer involved in that and I cannot discuss it," "It's been turned over to other people. They are in charge of it now. I no longer have any connection."

Someone here is lying, because a person who only heard of Bitcoin three weeks ago doesn't do and say those things.

Post reply on HN