Live data from Hacker News

Data protection: Angela Merkel proposes Europe network

bbc.co.uk

21–30 of 67 posts

Re: Data protection: Angela Merkel proposes Europe network

#21
post #16

[deleted]

So you would also find it perfectly normal if in the pre-Internet era the US government would open each and ever letter and parcel send from outside the US.

I'm old enough to remember regimes in which that was common practice back in the day. I know people who grew up in them.

We did not refer the them as either friendly or free and democratic nations.

But congrats on being a sovereign nation, and good luck with that. In, say, 20 years time you may find yourself on the wrong side of the modern electronic version of the iron curtain.

Re: Data protection: Angela Merkel proposes Europe network

#22
post #20

Earlier quoted context omitted.

That makes a bit more sense. At the level of infrastructure there already is a "European network", with pretty good interconnects. It's very uncommon for intra-European packets to go via the US, at least in continental Europe. There are some routes where it can happen due to peculiarities of peering agreements, but I've seen it quite rarely. On the other hand, if lots of Europeans are hosting their email in the U.S.,…

On the other hand, any traffic that needs to cross the Atlantic, via the Apollo cables, takes a detour via GCHQ Bude, which is funded by the NSA ( http://www.thisiscornwall.co.uk/USA-spent-millions-Bude-spy-... ). I suspect a lot of non-US traffic goes via London, too.

Used to be a much greater proportion than it is today, largely thanks to the growth of places like the Amsterdam Internet Exchange.

At one point there was a building on the Isle of Dogs (former island in the Thames) through which an absolutely terrifying proportion of the network traffic for western Europe travelled.

Re: Data protection: Angela Merkel proposes Europe network

#23
post #11

I hope it's more like "EU" than Europe, because countries like UK seem more than happy to sell the rest of us out. In the end the solution will be to build trustless P2P networks, everywhere, but the only way US and US companies will agree to allowing something like that will be if EU pushes for localized EU networks and stuff like this to make their life too hard otherwise.

Er, the UK has been part of the European Union since 1973.

Cameron promised a referendum. I hope they get out for good this time.

Re: Data protection: Angela Merkel proposes Europe network

#24
I seriously doubt that Merkel's intentions are pure on this. For starters, we know that Germany has given some degree of cooperation in NSA spying, including allowing the US to build an army base that will be used by the NSA[1]. Secondly, we know that the BND used the NSA's systems for its own intelligence purposes[2].

Something tells me this is as much (if not more) an attempt to put European users' data within reach of European spy agencies as it is about protecting European users' privacy. I suppose the upside is that it ensures that peoples' data is in the hands of their own governments rather than being in the hands of governments they have no control over.

[1] http://www.spiegel.de/international/world/edward-snowden-acc...

[2]http://www.spiegel.de/international/germany/german-intellige...

Re: Data protection: Angela Merkel proposes Europe network

#26

I hope it's more like "EU" than Europe, because countries like UK seem more than happy to sell the rest of us out. In the end the solution will be to build trustless P2P networks, everywhere, but the only way US and US companies will agree to allowing something like that will be if EU pushes for localized EU networks and stuff like this to make their life too hard otherwise.

I was just reading the history of the EU. So UK was part of the outer 7 European states. On the enlargement of the pre-pre-cursor of the EU to the pre-cursor of the EU in 1960

"However, then–French President Charles de Gaulle saw British membership of the Community as a Trojan horse for US interests, and hence stated he would veto British membership." (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Inner_Six)

Ha, he was probably right. But you will never get rid of us now!

Re: Data protection: Angela Merkel proposes Europe network

#27
post #24

I seriously doubt that Merkel's intentions are pure on this. For starters, we know that Germany has given some degree of cooperation in NSA spying, including allowing the US to build an army base that will be used by the NSA[1]. Secondly, we know that the BND used the NSA's systems for its own intelligence purposes[2]. Something tells me this is as much (if not more) an attempt to put European users' data within reac…

Personally, I'd rather my information be in the hands of the United States rather than my own governments (the United Kingdom -- unfortunately it's with both!) Your own government can do more against your interests than a foreign government can.

Re: Data protection: Angela Merkel proposes Europe network

#28
We begin therefore where they are determined not to end, with the question whether any form of democratic self-government, anywhere, is consistent with the kind of massive, pervasive, surveillance into which the Unites States government has led not only us but the world.

This should not actually be a complicated inquiry.

http://snowdenandthefuture.info/events.html

http://benjamin.sonntag.fr/Moglen-at-Re-Publica-Freedom-of-t...

You heard a lot of stuff from governments around the world in the last two weeks, but not one statement that consisted of “I regret subjecting my population to these procedures.” The German Chancellor, though triumphantly reelected with not a cloud in her political sky, is in no position to say “I agreed with the Americans to allow 40 million telephone calls a day to be intercepted in Germany; I just want them to stop listening to my phone!” The President of the United States is considering the possibility of not listening to thirty-five mobile phones around the world. The other several hundred million people we listen to are stone out of luck.

You understand what a charade this is, of course. The leaders of global societies do not conduct their classified business over their personal mobile phones. Our listening there is not gaining us important military intelligence. The President of the United States is publicly considering not listening to conversations that leaders of other countries have with their spouses, their siblings and their children. But the conversations nine hundred million other people are having with their spouses, their siblings, and their children remain fair game.

Nobody is talking about that; you’re not supposed to think about it.

Surveillance is not an end toward totalitarianism, it is totalitarianism itself.

http://www.bbc.co.uk/democracylive/europe-24385999

Re: Data protection: Angela Merkel proposes Europe network

#29
post #17

China kicking out Google doesn't seems so crazy now. The American government is a worldwide aggressor that cannot be restrained. All defenses must be put up in an attempt to stop it. As a side benefit China has fostered a large homegrown internet industry which many other countries lack. Services like Baidu and Sina Weibo are more than acceptable. Europe is more than capable of doing the same and hopefully with less…

> China kicking out Google doesn't seems so crazy now. The American government is a worldwide aggressor that cannot be restrained.

You're touching on something here. What you're saying is that Google = American government [1]. With the rise of open fascism in the US, the merging of strategic corporations (mostly the technology, entertainment, and banking monopolies) with government interests is become more and more obvious - and scary for that matter.

[1] http://cryptome.org/2013/08/assange-google-nsa.htm

Re: Data protection: Angela Merkel proposes Europe network

#30
Shitshitshitshitshit! I knew that this would be the knee-jerk reaction of politicians. If this happens, we will get borders on the internet. And if there is anything which can wreck the internet, borders are it. Now for the first time I'm really scared about the future of the internet. Let's get involved politically now and educate these people about the foundations of the internet, and try to keep it a neutral piece of infrastructure. Curse the NSA for wrecking net neutrality, and other agencies for waging war here. The internet was international and neutral from the start, don't bring your territorial thinking here!
Post reply on HN