Live data from Hacker News

Bitcoin Ponzi scheme

ponzi.io

21–30 of 306 posts

Re: Bitcoin Ponzi scheme

#21

This is a beautiful piece of art/social experimentation/I-don't-know-what.

It's brilliant, and it will work, and continue to work until people don't believe in it.

That's the fun part. Watching to see how big it will grow. It's almost like putting an exact dollar value on the amount of greed present.

Re: Bitcoin Ponzi scheme

#24
post #14

There have been a few Bitcoin sites like this, I think the original one was Bitcoin Gem. Most of them turned out to be scams (and I don't just mean that they were Ponzis).

Well, (1) they weren't so hilariously open about their scam nature, (2) they weren't so nicely done and so transparent.

On the other hand, this is going for just a few days, it might go south quickly.

Re: Bitcoin Ponzi scheme

#25
post #20

How does that work exactly? I pay in X BTC and two other people pay in say 0.5 X and 0.7 X then I get these BTC back? How exactly will my X BTC be distributed among other gamblers?

You don't get the original money back at the end, you just get the 1.2x BTC that other people gave you.

Re: Bitcoin Ponzi scheme

#26
post #2

I will add, since this hit the frontpage: nobody post any big money there . It's a Ponzi scheme. It says so in the title.

Ponzi scheme is ok if you are in at the beginning of the scheme. That's what makes this interesting - it's basically a bet that other people will also believe this will go on.

Re: Bitcoin Ponzi scheme

#28
post #17

A bit OT but how do you build automatic Bitcoin services like this?

Using RPC API of the official client? Unless you do something smarter like bitcoin lottery (I forgot how it is called).

If you have just a few transactions then yes, but the official client has a few caveats that can show up as problematic.

I would write it myself, but there is far better explanation here on reddit

http://www.reddit.com/r/Bitcoin/comments/1x93tf/some_irc_cha...

basically:

- the difficulty of finding available addresses is quadratic to the number of unspent transactions

- someone can slightly change the transaction so it's still valid, but have a different transaction ID - that can mess up clients and break chains of unconfirmed transactions

Post reply on HN