Live data from Hacker News

Scoble says Google Glass is doomed

plus.google.com

21–30 of 67 posts

Re: Scoble says Google Glass is doomed

#21
post #3

To me scoble is an attention whore. Does anyone remember this image of Scoble wearing Google Glass? http://sitegoals.com/wp-content/uploads/2013/12/904635_10201...

He's in marketing and a technical evangelist. It's his job.

Yes, I find him really annoying taken unfiltered. But when he's good, he's really good.

Sadly, writing on social media reveals his greatest weakness. He really needs to write for someone who tosses out about 90% of what he generates.

Re: Scoble says Google Glass is doomed

#22
I hope Google Glass is a bait-and-switch. It's a low-resolution UI and they are getting constant user feedback of how users are using it (e.g voice vs touch usage). I hope what really is happening is that its driving the design for Google's Watch.

However, post-Snowden I don't see myself using either.

Re: Scoble says Google Glass is doomed

#23
What is the purpose/point of google glass?

From 97% of news articles / reviews google glass is a voice activated camera. While this is mildly interesting it's the only use anyone has for the device. Who cares about this feature? It's not especially new, exciting or a good user experience.

If google could distill google glass into a single statement like "1000 songs in your pocket" we might understand it.

What is the equivalent statement for google glass?

Re: Scoble says Google Glass is doomed

#24
post #20

Something about the authors writing style just rubs me the wrong way. Kinda like an advert that was carefully crafted by a team with the sole purpose of triggering a specific emotion. That being said, I did actually learn something from that wall of text: The fact that Glass needs to be specifically fitted to the wearer is definitely problematic. I'm curious how G will work around that from a logistical PoV.

It's Scoble. I guarantee he's not carefully crafting anything other than his own thoughts. I appreciate the fact he calls out his emotions in his posts - why blame him for your own emotional response to reading it?

Re: Scoble says Google Glass is doomed

#25

1. Has to have a light to indicate recording, or everyone around you will be paranoid. (Most people will still be paranoid, but at least you can say "No red light, it's not recording!"). 2. Will probably be very popular as a cyclist camera. Cyclist who just want a decent 720p camera to record cycling activity (evidence against dangerous drivers), but don't want to attach a dorky camera to their head (i.e. GoPro), wil…

A goPro mounted like an alien beacon on top of the rider's head could be a clear signal to a-holes that their behavior will easily be recorded. I could see a whole secondary market in decoy helmet mounts appearing. Google Glass might just inspire more rage since it lacks the goofiness. Drivers may get a sense of levity from the goPro. It's like seeing the antennas on little cars that make them look like remote controlled cars... so cute - "Go ahead. Cut me off. You're just the cutest little two seater I ever did see!!"

Re: Scoble says Google Glass is doomed

#26
I'd say the core concept isn't doomed, but amongst the 'lean-back' (tv, dvd) and 'lean-in' (Laptop, tablet) UI modalities: the 'in-your-face' glass modality is certainly going to have a struggle balancing age old social norms with disruptive tech. Especially when there are good reasons for the social norms.

Re: Scoble says Google Glass is doomed

#27
post #4

My bet is on Google Glass going the way of the Segway... ...that is to say, ridiculed by the general public, but finding a bit of a niche in certain industries. The police, postal carriers, etc. @cstross did a pretty good job of convincing me that some form of augmented reality would be very useful for the police. There is a real-life push right now to get police wearing cameras too, I think this sort of device could…

Same usual mistake: Google Glass is NOT a proper HUD (Heads Up Display), or a proper form of Augmented Reality. It doesn't project anything on the main vision area, but only on the little screen on the upper right side.

Re: Scoble says Google Glass is doomed

#28

What is the purpose/point of google glass? From 97% of news articles / reviews google glass is a voice activated camera. While this is mildly interesting it's the only use anyone has for the device. Who cares about this feature? It's not especially new, exciting or a good user experience. If google could distill google glass into a single statement like "1000 songs in your pocket" we might understand it. What is the…

I would have said "hands-free city navigation", but everyone - Google, the "explorers", people who meet them in the street - seems to be preoccupied with the photo/video applications. I don't know if that's because the device is actually defective for that purpose in some unobvious way, or because people just can't look beyond the video-recording use (or if not that, the notification-firehose one).

Re: Scoble says Google Glass is doomed

#29
post #4

My bet is on Google Glass going the way of the Segway... ...that is to say, ridiculed by the general public, but finding a bit of a niche in certain industries. The police, postal carriers, etc. @cstross did a pretty good job of convincing me that some form of augmented reality would be very useful for the police. There is a real-life push right now to get police wearing cameras too, I think this sort of device could…

Same usual mistake: Google Glass is NOT a proper HUD (Heads Up Display), or a proper form of Augmented Reality. It doesn't project anything on the main vision area, but only on the little screen on the upper right side.

...which is its advantage. I doesn't take up your full viewing space, but puts the information right in front of you.

Re: Scoble says Google Glass is doomed

#30

1. Has to have a light to indicate recording, or everyone around you will be paranoid. (Most people will still be paranoid, but at least you can say "No red light, it's not recording!"). 2. Will probably be very popular as a cyclist camera. Cyclist who just want a decent 720p camera to record cycling activity (evidence against dangerous drivers), but don't want to attach a dorky camera to their head (i.e. GoPro), wil…

There is a reason why the GoPro is still in the form factor it is in. It is terribly hard to pack most of the GoPro's features into a small volume, they went with something cubish and built accessories off of that. The Glass couldn't keep up to the demands many fans would have and I imagine there is a struggle within the company concerning the increasing demands for resolution, frames per second, and image quality with the volume of the form factor they have.

That said I do see helmets with HD cameras and wireless controls in the future. Trademark™ and all that.

Post reply on HN