Live data from Hacker News

AutoDesk Releases An Electronics Simulator Called 123D Circuits

techcrunch.com

21–30 of 67 posts

Re: AutoDesk Releases An Electronics Simulator Called 123D Circuits

#21
post #20

Is this based on Fritzing (fritzing.org)?

Nope, just a non-free clone with a marketing budget. I must say I'm not sure how to feel watching the maker and hacker culture I love so much having its open heart slowly ripped out.

You can look at it as a kind of validation of the community - there's commercial interest in it.

Also, just because someone starts on this app, doesn't mean they won't move on to something else later.

Re: AutoDesk Releases An Electronics Simulator Called 123D Circuits

#22
post #20

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Nope, just a non-free clone with a marketing budget. I must say I'm not sure how to feel watching the maker and hacker culture I love so much having its open heart slowly ripped out.

You can look at it as a kind of validation of the community - there's commercial interest in it. Also, just because someone starts on this app, doesn't mean they won't move on to something else later.

Well, I agree if you s/validation/co-opting/

No, it doesn't necessarily mean they won't move on to something else later, but they're now living in a universe where it will always be Autodesk's job to make that harder or less obvious to them. By any means available.

Re: AutoDesk Releases An Electronics Simulator Called 123D Circuits

#23

Earlier quoted context omitted.

So if it's so random that you can't reliably measure it because it changes every time you plug and unplug the same pin (let alone different pin diameters), how can software hope to model it?

Each time you virtually plug something in the program's breadboard, generate a random number. If the number is lower than a threshold, prevent the connection from working. Change the threshold at every program loading and randomly during use.

Haha I assume you're joking; that would give the user zero benefit and immense pain.

Re: AutoDesk Releases An Electronics Simulator Called 123D Circuits

#26
post #20

Is this based on Fritzing (fritzing.org)?

Nope, just a non-free clone with a marketing budget. I must say I'm not sure how to feel watching the maker and hacker culture I love so much having its open heart slowly ripped out.

If you (or anyone else reading) haven't already, go read Steven Levy's Hackers. This is sort of the theme of the latter half of the book.

Re: AutoDesk Releases An Electronics Simulator Called 123D Circuits

#28
I think there is a lot of value to blowing up your Arduino for reals. When you blow up a couple of Arduinos, you'll tend to force yourself to learn very quickly why it is happening and how to avoid it.

What is so bad about "blowing up a capacitor" or "burning yourself with a soldering iron"? Capacitors are a few cents, each. Buy them in bulk and never worry about needing one again. Soldering iron burns are easy to avoid if you have spent any time in a kitchen.

I feel like this is missing a big point. Arduino is the safe, easy entry point to learn electronics. The danger is miniscule, and whatever danger that is there, is part of the learning process. You need this as much as you need a rice-cooker simulator.

Post reply on HN