Live data from Hacker News

Elon Musk To Traverse The U.S. Using A Model S In 6 Day Trip

techcrunch.com

21–30 of 79 posts

Re: Elon Musk To Traverse The U.S. Using A Model S In 6 Day Trip

#21
post #14
post #7

> At 1.5 hrs/day, we will only ever need to > charge when stopping anyway to eat or sightsee, > never just for charging itself. I'm all for the development of electric cars but downplaying having to stop at what's effectively a gas station in the middle of nowhere for 1.5 hours per day is pretty disingenuous. You wouldn't get a lot of people buying a normal gasoline powered car if it took 1.5 hrs to fill it up each t…

It's free. If you could get gasoline for 200 miles for free, would you mind waiting for 30 minutes? I guess it's $25-30 worth of gasoline, corresponding to $50-60 per hour of waiting. I could wait. With the battery swap that Tesla is now introducing, you could also chose to swap the battery in a couple of minutes.

It's NOT free, you paid for a very expensive battery upfront.

Re: Elon Musk To Traverse The U.S. Using A Model S In 6 Day Trip

#23
post #20
post #14

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It's free. If you could get gasoline for 200 miles for free, would you mind waiting for 30 minutes? I guess it's $25-30 worth of gasoline, corresponding to $50-60 per hour of waiting. I could wait. With the battery swap that Tesla is now introducing, you could also chose to swap the battery in a couple of minutes.

charging electric cars ain't free.

No, but using the Tesla Supercharger stations is free for Model S owners.

Re: Elon Musk To Traverse The U.S. Using A Model S In 6 Day Trip

#26
post #16

Earlier quoted context omitted.

True if you're only interested in getting there as fast as possible. For most people who choose to drive from coast to coast, stopping often to see random things is part of the fun and reason they chose to drive in the first place.

Indeed, I love stopping at random places when I'm on the road. Having to spend 1.5hr per day at a gas station is not a random stop however, and having to spend 1.5hr per day at one in lieu of stopping somewhere more interesting takes some of the fun out of driving and stopping at interesting places on the road.

The SuperChargers are not at gas stations. They are on purpose locating them near malls, restaurants etc.. I certainly would not like to spend all day cooped up in a car without a couple of stops to eat or stretch my legs, and I think you'd find very few people drive all day without taking breaks to eat etc. of that kind of length.

Re: Elon Musk To Traverse The U.S. Using A Model S In 6 Day Trip

#27
post #15
post #7

> At 1.5 hrs/day, we will only ever need to > charge when stopping anyway to eat or sightsee, > never just for charging itself. I'm all for the development of electric cars but downplaying having to stop at what's effectively a gas station in the middle of nowhere for 1.5 hours per day is pretty disingenuous. You wouldn't get a lot of people buying a normal gasoline powered car if it took 1.5 hrs to fill it up each t…

This is PR, so spinning the charge time as nothing more than a good opportunity to grab a bite to eat is smart. One assumes that the charging stations are located in places with a variety of nearby amenities for this purpose? To me the fact that any journey would have to be planned with charging stations as waypoints is more obnoxious than the actual stopping itself.

All the supercharger points are on their website, with a list of amenities, and yes they are pretty much all next to malls, restaurants etc.

Re: Elon Musk To Traverse The U.S. Using A Model S In 6 Day Trip

#28
post #25

I was wondering why someone hadn't done this. It's a bit of dangerous press. If the car breaks down, or runs out of battery for some reason, that's not going to look good. Bit of a gamble.

If it breaks down, it can be spun as another data point they can use to improve upon.

Re: Elon Musk To Traverse The U.S. Using A Model S In 6 Day Trip

#29
post #17
post #16

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Indeed, I love stopping at random places when I'm on the road. Having to spend 1.5hr per day at a gas station is not a random stop however, and having to spend 1.5hr per day at one in lieu of stopping somewhere more interesting takes some of the fun out of driving and stopping at interesting places on the road.

Won't the interesting places want to attract people who can afford expensive cars? Won't they start to add charging points?

Now someone's starting to get it ...

Re: Elon Musk To Traverse The U.S. Using A Model S In 6 Day Trip

#30
post #25

I was wondering why someone hadn't done this. It's a bit of dangerous press. If the car breaks down, or runs out of battery for some reason, that's not going to look good. Bit of a gamble.

Most 'normal' people already give electric vehicles a cynical eye. The people who already believe in them don't need more convincing. The cynics need convincing. A breakdown will only make them think "I knew it" while a successful trip will at least add one more argument against their cynicism. Not much of a gamble in my opinion.
Post reply on HN