Live data from Hacker News

What the Steve Jobs movie got right, and wrong

cnn.com

21–30 of 56 posts

Re: What the Steve Jobs movie got right, and wrong

#21
post #8

Are we going to have a movie about Norman Borlaug, Dennis Richie or Douglas Engelbart as well? What made the movie industry pick Jobs as the topic? I honestly don't understand it.

You don't understand it? You can't fathom why Steve Jobs gets a movie and those guys that you need a CS degree to recognize don't? Keep thinking.

[deleted]

Re: What the Steve Jobs movie got right, and wrong

#22
post #8

Are we going to have a movie about Norman Borlaug, Dennis Richie or Douglas Engelbart as well? What made the movie industry pick Jobs as the topic? I honestly don't understand it.

You don't understand it? You can't fathom why Steve Jobs gets a movie and those guys that you need a CS degree to recognize don't? Keep thinking.

Borlaug has nothing to do with CS.

Re: What the Steve Jobs movie got right, and wrong

#23
post #8

Are we going to have a movie about Norman Borlaug, Dennis Richie or Douglas Engelbart as well? What made the movie industry pick Jobs as the topic? I honestly don't understand it.

Can you honestly name other people in the computer business that during their lives lived with that much charisma

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Charisma

as Steve Jobs? His life is up to the very end the stuff many a film can be made of.

Imagine just one of the most recent the scenes: being on the hospital bed weighting like 50 pounds and rejecting the medicine equipment that was "not designed nicely enough!"

Even his "bad" side is what makes his life more thankful for films.

Re: What the Steve Jobs movie got right, and wrong

#24
post #8

Are we going to have a movie about Norman Borlaug, Dennis Richie or Douglas Engelbart as well? What made the movie industry pick Jobs as the topic? I honestly don't understand it.

Unless you can sell their stories in the time proven 127 minute, 2 peaks setup and market them to a major studio, I doubt it will get any traction. The only other option would be that the people who care about it fund it, but even though that pool might seem large inside of the tech microcosmos, it's comparitively small, and you'll have a low budget movie that has trouble being shown in theaters. Engelbart could actu…

Made a lot of sense, thanks for the writeup. Probably I am just silly for not understanding why our society doesn't cherish people who had so much more impact on our lives.

Re: What the Steve Jobs movie got right, and wrong

#25
post #23
post #8

Are we going to have a movie about Norman Borlaug, Dennis Richie or Douglas Engelbart as well? What made the movie industry pick Jobs as the topic? I honestly don't understand it.

Can you honestly name other people in the computer business that during their lives lived with that much charisma http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Charisma as Steve Jobs? His life is up to the very end the stuff many a film can be made of. Imagine just one of the most recent the scenes: being on the hospital bed weighting like 50 pounds and rejecting the medicine equipment that was "not designed nicely enough!" Even his…

Its not because you have charisma that it necessarily means you use it in a positive way in the world. Drm, walled gardens, patent mentality, i can name a few reasons why Jobs should not be glorified.

Re: What the Steve Jobs movie got right, and wrong

#26
post #22

Earlier quoted context omitted.

You don't understand it? You can't fathom why Steve Jobs gets a movie and those guys that you need a CS degree to recognize don't? Keep thinking.

Borlaug has nothing to do with CS.

There already is a Borlaug movie (Freedom from Famine)

Re: What the Steve Jobs movie got right, and wrong

#27
post #8

Are we going to have a movie about Norman Borlaug, Dennis Richie or Douglas Engelbart as well? What made the movie industry pick Jobs as the topic? I honestly don't understand it.

Unless you can sell their stories in the time proven 127 minute, 2 peaks setup and market them to a major studio, I doubt it will get any traction. The only other option would be that the people who care about it fund it, but even though that pool might seem large inside of the tech microcosmos, it's comparitively small, and you'll have a low budget movie that has trouble being shown in theaters. Engelbart could actu…

FYI there is a Feynman movie. I haven't seen it so I can't comment on the quality.

http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0116635/

Re: What the Steve Jobs movie got right, and wrong

#28

I haven't seen it, but I hope they show in the end that it is just not important to be a successful entrepreneur, but a good human being as well, which Steve Jobs failed miserably at.

Steve should kick a puppy at some point in the movie to drive home how irredeemably evil he was. Maybe they could have him wear a black hat the whole time so small children will understand he's the bad guy.

Re: What the Steve Jobs movie got right, and wrong

#30
post #6

From the trailers & preview material I was worried the movie might be deceptive. Specifically the scenes with Woz and Jobs in the parking lot and later in the office. In an interview Wozniak said the parking lot conversation never took place and got the underlying feelings incorrect. That made me jump to the conclusion that the preview's portrayal of the office scene where Woz leaves Apple would be equally misleading…

[deleted]
Post reply on HN