Live data from Hacker News

Laziness & The Web Designer: How Some Tools Make Designers Lazy

devinhalladay.com

21–24 of 24 posts

Re: Laziness & The Web Designer: How Some Tools Make Designers Lazy

#21
post #10

Does this argument work for illustration as well? Do you prefer to write SVG using a text editor instead of using Illustrator?

That's completely irrelevant. The non-human-readable SVG format can't translate to this topic in any respect.

False. SVG is an XML format, and very much human-readable.

Re: Laziness & The Web Designer: How Some Tools Make Designers Lazy

#22

Well, a few weeks ago I would have agreed to your opinion. But after watching Bret Victors great Talk about The Future Of Programming ( https://vimeo.com/71278954 ) I don't think you're 100% right. Right at the moment I also prefer hand written code over that generated code by some Adobe tool. But as Bret Victor puts it in the talk, I think it would be shame if we create applications in 20 to 40 years in the same way…

I'd like to think that Macaw is like training wheels (or a fixie bike) for getting into web development. Is it production ready-code? Probably not. Does it do a good job of showing how things should work? Hell yes.

Re: Laziness & The Web Designer: How Some Tools Make Designers Lazy

#23
( tataniel 4 days ago | link

WTF? An Illustrator that never learned Hand Craft illustration as the core of it's art, is not an illustrator but a guy who uses tools to replace and emulate that art, same way, a Front-End must know how to code. If not is just using tools, not a bad thing, but it's just the superficial layer of the work. reply)

You do understand that if someone learns how to illustrate using a specific tool, it would classify them as an illustrator. Just because a person doesnt use the same methods you consider traditional illustration doesnt mean they're not an illustrator. Does it mean they're not as good of an illustrator? Possibly. But that's a bit close-minded.

Post reply on HN