Live data from Hacker News

Do web designers actually use the internet?

caitlinrivers.com

21–23 of 23 posts

Re: Do web designers actually use the internet?

#21
post #5

1. This is an UX problem but many designers take on that role for one reason or another. It is rather annoying. 2. Different teams maybe? Don't necessarily see this as the designer's fault. 3. That does seem an outdated concept these days but sometimes the client wants it that way. 4. That's a marketing problem, not design. 5. That's a subjective thing that depends on many aspects of the design. 6. Because they might…

What do you recommend for learning about web design?

Re: Do web designers actually use the internet?

#22
post #21
post #5

1. This is an UX problem but many designers take on that role for one reason or another. It is rather annoying. 2. Different teams maybe? Don't necessarily see this as the designer's fault. 3. That does seem an outdated concept these days but sometimes the client wants it that way. 4. That's a marketing problem, not design. 5. That's a subjective thing that depends on many aspects of the design. 6. Because they might…

What do you recommend for learning about web design?

The easiest method is to design a web page, then see if you can actually build it so that it displays as expected across various browsers. If you find you cannot, then adjust the design with what you've learned and try again. Eventually you'll learn what works and what doesn't. Once the limitations and advantages are understood then the design part is much easier.

The equivalent is for a print designer to design something in Illustrator for a certain size and type of paper and never actually printing the design on that paper to see how it turns out.

I'm in the school of thought that a web designer should know HTML/CSS and how browsers render those elements as a web page. They don't necessarily need front-end developer level knowledge, but if they don't at least know the basics of how browsers work then they'll always try designs that are not workable.

Personally, if I ran a web design curriculum, I would require HTML/CSS education first, then start on design. But it's often the reverse, or worse in that designers are taught all kinds of different avenues of design, but web design is that kid in the corner no one picks for dodgeball. I've interviewed many a designer with nice school projects but not one web project in the portfolio.

Re: Do web designers actually use the internet?

#23
post #6
post #4

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I must agree with you. I browse the web on my phone a lot, and the only website where I want to use the mobile version is wikipedia. And even then, I need to switch back to the desktop view at times.

I agree. Does anyone else find that mobile sites lag when scrolling? They do on my iphone, while normal sites display perfectly fine.

probably some hack to speed scrolling made last year, that now serves the opposite purpose.
Post reply on HN