Live data from Hacker News

8 days. 8,000 forums

moot.it

21–30 of 72 posts

Re: 8 days. 8,000 forums

#21
post #13

Are there any active forums besides the main moot.it/forum? I tried going to relatively common keywords and most are just people kinda squatting on them during the initial landgrab.

Like we say; we've been up only 8 days. Our forum is currently the most active one and you'll probably get the best picture there. Here is a playground forum where you can fool around freely:

http://moot.it/demos/forum.html

Re: 8 days. 8,000 forums

#22
I really like the fact that Moot seems to handle both forum-style posts and on-page comments. As the owner of a content site, I really want both. I've even gone so far as to try to hack Disqus to work as a forum.

If there was an easy import feature for Disqus threads, I'd probably switch right over.

Re: 8 days. 8,000 forums

#25
Very impressive.

We have a startup ( http://microco.sm/ ) in this very space (hosted forums) and will be launching our alpha in the next two weeks. Our design rushes are pretty close to this (though we haven't updated the linked site in ages it feels) and we love that others are innovating in this space and feel that they've also spotted and validated a need for simpler, more engaging forums.

I really like the look of this, one of the much stronger offerings to have emerged in this space.

Will be good to see how we all do in a year or so, and which we way pivot and the changes in our respective business models.

Right now this looks like more of a Disqus rival than anything, but I'm sure they will do well with things like forums for really small communities such as housing associations and knitting groups, etc.

Re: 8 days. 8,000 forums

#26

I don't believe in forums as a SaaS. Wordpress growth, in a sense, it is because it is open source. You can have your own version, and also, if you prefer, they can host your blog. A forums is a different kind of service, takes a lot of time and effort to build a community, and if this guys dissapear in 2 or 3 months, years, etc, it is a big loss. I prefer the path that Discourse is taking. It's software is open sour…

I _do_ believe in forums as a SaaS.

Yes, there are risks, as you pointed out. There are also benefits.

The forum service provider rolls out updates

The forum service provider applies security patches

The forum service provider keeps the service running 24 hours, and gets woken up in the middle of the night to fix unexpected crashes, not me.

--

I try to outsource anything I can. And forums is one of them.

Re: 8 days. 8,000 forums

#29
Impressive performance and clean design. /me interested.

I don't understand the need to claim such a broad copyright license on content submitted.

"When providing us with content or posting content on Moot’s site or related third-party sites, you grant us a non-exclusive, worldwide, perpetual, irrevocable, royalty-free, sublicensable (through multiple tiers) right AND LICENSE to exercise any and all copyright, trademark, publicity, and database rights you have in the content, in any media known now or in the future."

The "Why do we have this clause" link doesn't feel like it answers that either.

Also, the "Following is guaranteed" bit needs work. It sounds good, but is legally worthless, I expect.

Re: 8 days. 8,000 forums

#30

I don't believe in forums as a SaaS. Wordpress growth, in a sense, it is because it is open source. You can have your own version, and also, if you prefer, they can host your blog. A forums is a different kind of service, takes a lot of time and effort to build a community, and if this guys dissapear in 2 or 3 months, years, etc, it is a big loss. I prefer the path that Discourse is taking. It's software is open sour…

I _do_ believe in forums as a SaaS. Yes, there are risks, as you pointed out. There are also benefits. The forum service provider rolls out updates The forum service provider applies security patches The forum service provider keeps the service running 24 hours, and gets woken up in the middle of the night to fix unexpected crashes, not me. -- I try to outsource anything I can. And forums is one of them.

I run some very large forums, and the reason I'm now making a forum PaaS/SaaS play is precisely because of the above.

Just Google for "Powered by vBulletin 3.8" to see how many hundred thousands of forums are running old unpatched versions of forum software.

Most people who run forums are into the topic of the forum, not becoming a sysadmin.

Post reply on HN