Live data from Hacker News

Rover - All Your SF Transit Options In One Place

blog.roversf.com

21–30 of 40 posts

Re: Rover - All Your SF Transit Options In One Place

#21
post #9

I've been using Rover on iPhone for a few months and it's great. Prior to Rover the best option was using both Google Maps (great routing, but no real-time schedules for SF transit) and Routesy/Nextmuni (real-time schedules, but no routing)-- two apps for every bus trip. Muni buses are more often late than not, so Rover is solving a real problem with just the walking+transit piece. It also has InstantCab/Uber/Sidecar…

Nice I like the uber / sidecar / instantcab integrations.

For those who haven't Uber'd yet, get $10 off with promo uberfeb10.

Re: Rover - All Your SF Transit Options In One Place

#22
post #8
post #6

It looks like they don't support BART yet. You should probably change the title so it's not false advertising for those of us who are eager for more apps that truly support all sf transit options.

Hey Garthex! Thanks for checking out our app - Rover does support BART (with real-time arrival data), try routing to SFO for example. Let me know if that doesn't work for you - we'll investigate if something is not looking right!

I've generally had success (and love the app due to the user experience and integrated nextbus functionality) but I was getting a message "Rover only works for SF MUNI right now." a few times for a particular route between Berkeley and SF. So at the very least, that text should get changed.

Also, the headline seems wrong since it doesn't seem to support some transit options such as AC Transit. Although, likely the spirit of the headline is that it supports "all" kinds of transit options such as buses, Uber, and bike sharing, but I'm sure that is also incorrect (i.e. does it include ferries? cable cars? private planes? hot air balloons?)

Edit: Actually AC Transit is East Bay and the headline says SF options (rather than SF Bay Area options), so the headline isn't wrong because of that.

Re: Rover - All Your SF Transit Options In One Place

#23

One problem: It thinks that it doesn't take any time to walk from, say, Powell station to a street-level bus, so it gives you connections that you can't possibly make. This is the same problem that almost all transit apps have, unfortunately. Edit: Also, it seems to give me really bizarre suggestions. Right now, for a trip to Alamo Square Park from downtown SF, it suggests that I take Bart from Montgomery to Powell (…

I don't see why this should be so hard. They could use Google Maps to do the walking path and then just apply a default walking speed (or even let you set yours) to calculate walking time.

Re: Rover - All Your SF Transit Options In One Place

#24
post #6

It looks like they don't support BART yet. You should probably change the title so it's not false advertising for those of us who are eager for more apps that truly support all sf transit options.

If you're on Android, I've found the best BART application by far is OpenBART https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=pro.dbro.bart&...

Re: Rover - All Your SF Transit Options In One Place

#25
post #8

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Hey Garthex! Thanks for checking out our app - Rover does support BART (with real-time arrival data), try routing to SFO for example. Let me know if that doesn't work for you - we'll investigate if something is not looking right!

I've generally had success (and love the app due to the user experience and integrated nextbus functionality) but I was getting a message "Rover only works for SF MUNI right now." a few times for a particular route between Berkeley and SF. So at the very least, that text should get changed. Also, the headline seems wrong since it doesn't seem to support some transit options such as AC Transit. Although, likely the sp…

Ah yes this is what happened to me.

Re: Rover - All Your SF Transit Options In One Place

#26
post #24
post #6

It looks like they don't support BART yet. You should probably change the title so it's not false advertising for those of us who are eager for more apps that truly support all sf transit options.

If you're on Android, I've found the best BART application by far is OpenBART https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=pro.dbro.bart&...

I would prefer an app that combines BART and Muni data into a cohesive trip.

Re: Rover - All Your SF Transit Options In One Place

#29

One problem: It thinks that it doesn't take any time to walk from, say, Powell station to a street-level bus, so it gives you connections that you can't possibly make. This is the same problem that almost all transit apps have, unfortunately. Edit: Also, it seems to give me really bizarre suggestions. Right now, for a trip to Alamo Square Park from downtown SF, it suggests that I take Bart from Montgomery to Powell (…

I don't see why this should be so hard. They could use Google Maps to do the walking path and then just apply a default walking speed (or even let you set yours) to calculate walking time.

Google Maps doesn't do depth or man-made obstructions to walking. The bus he's trying to catch is directly on top of the underground station, leading a simplistic walk estimator to give a near-instantaneous result. In actuality there are multiple stairs as well as a bottleneck-prone exit gate.

Re: Rover - All Your SF Transit Options In One Place

#30
post #9

I've been using Rover on iPhone for a few months and it's great. Prior to Rover the best option was using both Google Maps (great routing, but no real-time schedules for SF transit) and Routesy/Nextmuni (real-time schedules, but no routing)-- two apps for every bus trip. Muni buses are more often late than not, so Rover is solving a real problem with just the walking+transit piece. It also has InstantCab/Uber/Sidecar…

Nice I like the uber / sidecar / instantcab integrations. For those who haven't Uber'd yet, get $10 off with promo uberfeb10.

And $5 off InstantCab with promo "rover"!
Post reply on HN