Live data from Hacker News

My iOS 7 Wishlist

tomdale.net

21–30 of 160 posts

Re: My iOS 7 Wishlist

#21
post #13

I'd love to be able to actually replace Apple's apps with Google's. When I hit a link I don't want it to open in Safari, I want Chrome. Ditto with Map links. I want Siri to be replaced with Google Voice Search (and for there to be APIs that allow Google to fully replace Siri).

It sounds like you don't want an iPhone. I would recommend you look into Android.

Re: My iOS 7 Wishlist

#22
post #13

I'd love to be able to actually replace Apple's apps with Google's. When I hit a link I don't want it to open in Safari, I want Chrome. Ditto with Map links. I want Siri to be replaced with Google Voice Search (and for there to be APIs that allow Google to fully replace Siri).

Though you stll prefer Apple's hardware and other function iOS provides to Android devices and OS? What's the tipping point for you?

Re: My iOS 7 Wishlist

#23
post #12
post #7

What APIs would something like Google Now need that don't currently exist? The only one I can think of is a way to launch it easier, rather than with an icon. But the push and local notifications, geo-tracking, ability to access your Gmail, and even the ability for Google Maps to pre-download map tiles are available to Google on iOS. What else does it need?

the ability for Google Maps to pre-download map tiles [is] available to Google on iOS Google Now will automatically pre-download the map vector data before your trip, without you asking it to. For Google to do the equivalent on iOS, they'd need to be able to perform periodic background jobs, which isn't something that iOS supports currently.

It wouldn't be perfect, but the Google Now app could recognize that you're nearing an airport — something iOS does support, with background location updates — and then download the map data when it gets that notification. iOS apps can also share data between apps from the same vendor (via the Keychain, pasteboards, or various other mechanisms), so there wouldn't be an issue with passing that data over to the Google Maps app for offline viewing.

Re: My iOS 7 Wishlist

#24
Personally, the biggest thing for me is file management. I hate it that I can't just connect a device and copy files to and from it via USB.

Now, I'm not saying that I need to see every file and folder on the iOS device, but exposing a data folder for each installed application would be a big help.

Re: My iOS 7 Wishlist

#26

>Let us do what we want. Pretty much everyone I know who has ditched iOS has done so because of this reason. Seems to me like the author is just a bit behind and finally caught on. I love the Apple hardware, dislike the closed options I get on iOS.

This is what happens when you market a phone as something that "just works". It's great that iOS is able to be used by kindergarten-level children, but at the same time, it's not.

My next phone is going to be Android-based, because I believe that I can handle using mobile devices expecting users to be able to think critically.

Re: My iOS 7 Wishlist

#27
post #13

I'd love to be able to actually replace Apple's apps with Google's. When I hit a link I don't want it to open in Safari, I want Chrome. Ditto with Map links. I want Siri to be replaced with Google Voice Search (and for there to be APIs that allow Google to fully replace Siri).

Given that you're primarily wanting Google software, what is it about iOS or the iPhone that is keeping you from switching to an Android phone?

The phones themselves... ?

Re: My iOS 7 Wishlist

#28
post #13

I'd love to be able to actually replace Apple's apps with Google's. When I hit a link I don't want it to open in Safari, I want Chrome. Ditto with Map links. I want Siri to be replaced with Google Voice Search (and for there to be APIs that allow Google to fully replace Siri).

Given that you're primarily wanting Google software, what is it about iOS or the iPhone that is keeping you from switching to an Android phone?

Not the orignal commenter, but I've tried switching to Android several times so I feel qualified to reply:

* Apple hardware is superior to any of the Nexus phones. Buttons don't rock without triggering action, screens are consistent colors, etc.

* There is a hardware home button that doesn't change locations. This makes it easy to get 'home' from anywhere, and, most importantly, to orient the device by feel in your hand without looking at it.

* The phone in't huge.

* Battery life is better on iOS.

* There is only one email app, not seperate apps for exchange / imap and gmail.

* The quality of apps on iOS is vastly superior to Android. Both in terms of function, but also UI. This is partly because of developers, but also because there isn't the screen size fragmentation issue.

I really want google to succeed with Android. I want someone to make a phone that's better than the iPhone. No one is doing it, yet, though.

Re: My iOS 7 Wishlist

#29
post #13

I'd love to be able to actually replace Apple's apps with Google's. When I hit a link I don't want it to open in Safari, I want Chrome. Ditto with Map links. I want Siri to be replaced with Google Voice Search (and for there to be APIs that allow Google to fully replace Siri).

Given that you're primarily wanting Google software, what is it about iOS or the iPhone that is keeping you from switching to an Android phone?

Probably native OS performance + battery life (depending on which Android device one has it can be good [Nexus 7] to mediocre [Verizon Galaxy Nexus]). Perhaps they prefer Cocoa + Objective C to Java, if they're a developer. It's a tradeoff I suppose to which one considers more important. I like Android well enough these days and try to use Mono + C# when possible, but each platform has its merits and have to weigh what is more important as a user/developer.

disclosure: Android user for nearly 3+ years and owns a Galaxy Nexus, Nexus 7 and a few other Android devices.

Re: My iOS 7 Wishlist

#30
Google Now isn't awesome because Google exposed various APIs into their omniscient database. And they're not letting random apps grab 'Now' information for their own purposes either. They haven't played the "Open" card on "Now", at all, that I've seen.

So thinking Apple would match it by just opening some APIs is double-unlikely. Particularly not with their reluctance to allow any hooks that third party developers might misuse.

If Apple pursued this, they'd develop a first-party solution by more-tightly-integrating the existing first-party apps (Maps/Calendar/Passbook/Siri) and call it a day.

A measured step forward on that front is actually more Apple-like and would be less surprising than if they rolled out the more oft-cited requests, like widgets, services, siri API and changeable defaults.

Particularly since making Siri "aware" of your immediate future needs/obligations would be a feature multiplier all its own.

Post reply on HN