Live data from Hacker News

Goodbye Google Reader

blog.mediumequalsmessage.com

21–30 of 73 posts

Re: Goodbye Google Reader

#21

I used Google Reader for years and years as a central repository for all of the webcomics i read. I switched to Newsblur this year and haven't looked back. It definitely has a better take on sharing.

But Google Reader has historical records that no other service has. That is the main advantage with them.

Re: Goodbye Google Reader

#22
post #8

pinboard is great What i'd like now is a better version of instapaper or the alternatives.

What don't you like about Instapaper? There are many good alternatives, including Pocket and Readability.

Instapaper lately has been having many messed up conversions. I use instapaper because they have a pretty clear business model. They make money from subscriptions and app sales. Pocket and Read It Later both don't have paid apps nor subscriptions. So the only other option is that you are being sold.

I'd much prefer an app I run myself with user maintained site defined scraping definitions.

I like instapaper though, it's good for what it does. Could be better though.

Re: Goodbye Google Reader

#23
post #15

I've recently found The Old Reader: http://theoldreader.com/ Feels like greader would be if they kept driving it forward. They also do an import of all your greader feeds in one step, so I was able to just drop-in replace greader.

looks nice but without google or facebook accounts how can I use?

Re: Goodbye Google Reader

#24

I used Google Reader for years and years as a central repository for all of the webcomics i read. I switched to Newsblur this year and haven't looked back. It definitely has a better take on sharing.

Glad somebody mentioned NewsBlur. I run NewsBlur and have been aggressive in developing it into a world-class feed reader. Native iOS and Android apps, a nice shared stories feature, and it's actively developed.

See for yourself, since it's open-source: http://github.com/samuelclay.

And because I run my own feed fetchers, you don't have to worry about the inevitable sunsetting and neglect of Reader. Also means I can do far more interesting things to feeds and stories that other Google Reader API-based clients can't.

Try it out: http://www.newsblur.com

Re: Goodbye Google Reader

#25
post #21

I used Google Reader for years and years as a central repository for all of the webcomics i read. I switched to Newsblur this year and haven't looked back. It definitely has a better take on sharing.

But Google Reader has historical records that no other service has. That is the main advantage with them.

They do? I've noticed that Google Reader only seems to keep about 30 to 60 days worth of items - at least for me.

The only thing that I can think of, in terms of historical records, in the UI - is the 'how often is this feed updated?' graph under feed information.

I disagree with you, their main advantage is that they're Google. So they won't get shunned/blocked by webmasters. Other people/services can and do get blocked occationally.

Other advantages are; GReader is pretty easy to get going with (I already had a Google account), the UI isn't too much in the way and the fact that they're "always on" (but the last one is true for all 'webapps'/'web services') so they won't miss a update from a feed.

Re: Goodbye Google Reader

#27
post #14

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I was wondering about that. Why would the author want to mask the name of the service in question?

I think it's just an oddly passive-aggressive writing style. He also keeps talking about services not selling his personal information, implying (I think) that Google does. However, that's of course not true, as it would violate Google's privacy policy and be a moronic business move in general. Honestly, I think it's great if the author wants to sing the praises of some new products or services he found to replace hi…

When people imply that Google will "sell" your personal information, they don't mean that they will pass on your email address and your phone number to a third party but rather engage in "selling" to third parties by using your personal information.

Re: Goodbye Google Reader

#29
I miss Bloglines, honestly. I switched to greader after bloglines started having DB problems several years ago, but never really liked the UI - seemed too bloated and slow. I switched to using Reeder as a frontend, but in an effort to switch to local services I started using Fever + Sunstroke (iOS app). My main beef with Fever is that if you're reading an article and it does a feed refresh it will refresh the view and take away the article you were reading (since it was marked as read).

Re: Goodbye Google Reader

#30
post #21

I used Google Reader for years and years as a central repository for all of the webcomics i read. I switched to Newsblur this year and haven't looked back. It definitely has a better take on sharing.

But Google Reader has historical records that no other service has. That is the main advantage with them.

The main advantage of Reader is that third party clients sync with it.
Post reply on HN