Live data from Hacker News

Watching TikTok and Instagram deactivates the cognitive control network: Study

rathbiotaclan.com

21–30 of 132 posts

Re: Watching TikTok and Instagram deactivates the cognitive control network: Study

#21
post #9

The brain is incredibly energy hungry so it evolved to detect situations that don’t require full attention and activates the Default Mode Network. This happens when you’re zoning out to pretty much anything, and indicates that you’re essentially in “low power mode”. My question here is whether the framing of the content in question “shutting off brain regions” is an honest one compared to what I said above. fMRI is a…

the article does note:

"The researchers caution against reading the deactivation as evidence of impaired cognitive function. As they put it in the paper, “this deactivation should not be interpreted as a failure of cognitive control capacity.” Instead, the team argues the pattern likely reflects an adaptive shift toward low-effort, automatic processing during passive, low-conflict viewing."

my take: if the study authors could qualify a subject's liked videos, they could qualify a subject's liked activities, and study activation thresholds prior to and post short form content exposure. this would provide a better substrate from which to draw such conclusions.

but I don't need a study to tell me that short form content fries the brain ... it fries my brain!

Re: Watching TikTok and Instagram deactivates the cognitive control network: Study

#22
post #9

The brain is incredibly energy hungry so it evolved to detect situations that don’t require full attention and activates the Default Mode Network. This happens when you’re zoning out to pretty much anything, and indicates that you’re essentially in “low power mode”. My question here is whether the framing of the content in question “shutting off brain regions” is an honest one compared to what I said above. fMRI is a…

I would postulate that it's even worse than this, given that default mode network activity is proven to be essential for a healthy mind. This is when engage in useful thinking even when we're not "doing anything".

I think screen activity/tiktok keeps us in some kind of purgatory where we can neither fully engage nor fully disengage.

Re: Watching TikTok and Instagram deactivates the cognitive control network: Study

#23
I get the TikTok addiction, but before that it was fb, before that was the tv, before that the newspaper/magazines, before that the books, before that table games etc

I don’t know it seems that regardless of the technology the brain needs dozing off from reality.

Re: Watching TikTok and Instagram deactivates the cognitive control network: Study

#24
post #20

I haven’t read the study, but I’ve read the comments so far. I wonder if this mechanism is the same mechanism that impacts, say, swipe-focused dating websites, as well? And Twitter feeds with super-short messages. A lot of the most viral modern tech has been bite-sized content feeds of various types.

Leetcode became popular along the same time line. Coincides with GenZ aging into adulthood after being educated in the debunked "3-cueing" or "whole language" reading education model. So far 40 states have pivoted away from it as states that switched first saw reading comprehension improve. Whole lot of social experimentation without informed consent being put on people by 50+ year olds who run the world and never ha…

Eeeh, Leetcode is older. I’m a millenial and it was popular when I was going through - 10ish years earlier.

Re: Watching TikTok and Instagram deactivates the cognitive control network: Study

#25

Worthwhile to note that “TikTok” here just means the format, not the platform. YouTube has its “shorts”, Facebook, insta, X, et all engage heavily in milking your doom scrolled eyeballs for time and profit.

It is a proprietary eponym.

Re: Watching TikTok and Instagram deactivates the cognitive control network: Study

#26

I get the TikTok addiction, but before that it was fb, before that was the tv, before that the newspaper/magazines, before that the books, before that table games etc I don’t know it seems that regardless of the technology the brain needs dozing off from reality.

"It's not that bad, everything was toxic befor so we can continue as if nothing was bad."

Re: Watching TikTok and Instagram deactivates the cognitive control network: Study

#27

Earlier quoted context omitted.

define short form content as anything under an arbitrary time threshold, legislate all online providers of short form content to mandate an arbitrary time limit per day for all users, add a law that parents knowingly allowing children to exceed national daily short form content limits are subject to penalty. seems fairly straightforward. but uh, I guess we could all capitulate to giving corporations our biometric dat…

I don't think it's straightforward at all. What's considered "short form content". Just video? Does just audio count? Does a gif count? What if I make a website that uploads videos at 1/10th the speed, and the user plays it back 10x faster so it becomes short form? What if i make a video aggregator website that pulls from multiple different sources so the user gets around the time limit per day per user? What if user…

Let me add, it sound very much like 3D-prohibition for guns. The total demonization of anything, because it could be bad, given certain conditions, is a recipe for disaster. As you say, is extremely difficult to define where are the limits, and the extremely hard to apply the limits without screwing over millions.

Re: Watching TikTok and Instagram deactivates the cognitive control network: Study

#28

I get the TikTok addiction, but before that it was fb, before that was the tv, before that the newspaper/magazines, before that the books, before that table games etc I don’t know it seems that regardless of the technology the brain needs dozing off from reality.

Hmm... this doesn't quite add up. Do we have brain scans showing that critical thinking centers of the brain turn off when people read books or play table games?

Re: Watching TikTok and Instagram deactivates the cognitive control network: Study

#30
post #20

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Leetcode became popular along the same time line. Coincides with GenZ aging into adulthood after being educated in the debunked "3-cueing" or "whole language" reading education model. So far 40 states have pivoted away from it as states that switched first saw reading comprehension improve. Whole lot of social experimentation without informed consent being put on people by 50+ year olds who run the world and never ha…

Eeeh, Leetcode is older. I’m a millenial and it was popular when I was going through - 10ish years earlier.

[flagged]
Post reply on HN