Live data from Hacker News

We can still stop California's 3D printer surveillance scheme

eff.org

21–30 of 208 posts

Re: We can still stop California's 3D printer surveillance scheme

#22
post #4

The Take Action link only took 30 seconds: https://www.eff.org/3DPrintCA (did choose to edit the letter but otherwise really, it autofills and takes no time)

Also, if you have a couple extra minutes to spare, consider handing the letter and the name of your senator to an LLM (I used Deepseek V4 Pro) with instructions to research your representative and tailor the message to them specifically.

Re: We can still stop California's 3D printer surveillance scheme

#24
post #4

The Take Action link only took 30 seconds: https://www.eff.org/3DPrintCA (did choose to edit the letter but otherwise really, it autofills and takes no time)

I share your hopeful optimism, but here's the reality of the mass-email campaigns targeting congress:

[email received 6/18/26 from the office of Steve Scalise, majority leader in the house, who is one of my representatives. I have trimmed for brevity.]

>> Due to advancements in technology, many third-party organizations use their mailing lists to send advocacy letters like this on your behalf. With the increased volume of third-party letters being sent to my office, I want to be sure that I am able to more appropriately address your thoughts and concerns.

I will be sure to consider the views you have sent me, but if you have any additional thoughts on this issue, or need other assistance with a federal agency, please contact my office directly through my website scalise.house.gov or by calling (202) 225-3015

-----------

In case it is not clear to anyone reading, this is kosher political speak for "I am ignoring automated emails. Consider this your notice."

Honestly, I am surprised it took this long, although I'm quite certain it has been going on for a lot longer and generally they simply do not provide the courtesy of telling you they are ignoring you.

Re: We can still stop California's 3D printer surveillance scheme

#25
post #16
post #13

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> Then what, ban stepper motors? Don't give them ideas. But seriously, given that the 3D printer movement started out with people building their own printers from scratch and there continues to be a healthy open-source hardware ecosystem within the community, I can't see this stopping anyone. Unless you also make it illegal for 3D printers to print 3D printer parts...

But how was the first 3D printer made? Are they gonna ban CNC machines next?

Working on it

Re: We can still stop California's 3D printer surveillance scheme

#26
California voters, write to your state senator. I'm in San Francisco, and I wrote to Scott Wiener, who recently voted to pass this out of committee.

Before that when it was still in the assembly, I wrote to Matt Haney, which didn't do much good because he voted for it both in committee and for passage.

But, I feel like bay area legislators need to know many of their constituents know this bill is misguided and are paying attention. The tech capital of the world shouldn't have artificially impaired tools.

Re: We can still stop California's 3D printer surveillance scheme

#27
post #20
post #11

[flagged]

We just reeeeeally want to believe, more than other states, that our government is The Good Guys and we can Fix The Problems if we only added more laws and more taxes. Every two years we are presented with 20 earnest-seeming ballot measures that each have roughly this message: > "We have a major problem in California -- ____ is not as ____ as it should be. Prop 1234 authorizes the state to sell $__,000,000,000 in bon…

Yes, that has been clear for a long time, about as long as CA has been a one-party state. The real question is why you supposedly smart Californians keep on falling for the... same... old... lie... every... damn... time. It is not as if the pie-in-the-sky people haven't promised a chicken in every pot and a cow in every shed and a car on every driveway - replace these with whatever modern equivalents you like - a thousand times before without delivering even a single chick, calf or push bike. Why do you keep on falling for the same old tired this-time-it-will-work lies? This is not limited to CA and might even become more prevalent in NY now that the DSA has seriously started to hollow out the remains of what used to be the Democratic party but it has been going on for much longer in the formerly Golden, now somehow tarnished state. Why? California Dreaming used to be a thing, not a nightmare.

Re: We can still stop California's 3D printer surveillance scheme

#30

California voters, write to your state senator. I'm in San Francisco, and I wrote to Scott Wiener, who recently voted to pass this out of committee. Before that when it was still in the assembly, I wrote to Matt Haney, which didn't do much good because he voted for it both in committee and for passage. But, I feel like bay area legislators need to know many of their constituents know this bill is misguided and are pa…

[flagged]
Post reply on HN