Live data from Hacker News

War Crimes Seem to Be Official US Policy Now

phillipspobrien.substack.com

21–30 of 66 posts

Re: War Crimes Seem to Be Official US Policy Now

#21
This thread will get flagged and disappear, probably because at least someone in HN leadership realises just how bad this reflects on the USA and its people.

But people in the USA should realise this:

An entire generation is growing up now, who hate, dislike or at least distrust the USA.

Where I have the feeling the US will come to its senses, eventually, hopefully; my children tell me that they and all their classmates see no difference between China, Russia, USA or Israel. None of these countries seem particularly trustworthy to them.

At the "Model United Nations" my oldest, who had to represent the United States realistically was surprised to learn just how immensely hypocritical, self-serving, arrogant and sometimes just plain evil the viewpoints of the USA are. And have been, for his entire life now.

That's the generation that has to do business with the USA in 10-20 years time.

Buckle up.

Re: War Crimes Seem to Be Official US Policy Now

#22
post #2

"Now" is doing a metric ton of heavy lifting in that headline.

Remember when America firebombed civilians during World War Two?

That was, sadly, very much an "everybody does this" thing, from Guernica to Chongqing to Coventry.

But yes, there are two possible lessons from those horrors:

- never again must this happen to anyone: the construction of international peace frameworks, the ICC, and human rights law

- what is currently happening, which is very different

Re: War Crimes Seem to Be Official US Policy Now

#23

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Remember when America firebombed civilians during World War Two?

Wasn’t regret for and fear of the scale of that damage partly why we supported the Geneva Convention?

Unfortunately that knowledge seems to have been lost with the passage of time.

Re: War Crimes Seem to Be Official US Policy Now

#24
post #18

Now? There is reason why United States is not a member of the International Criminal Court (ICC). It's their policy for decades. There is no bigger threat for world peace than US (and maybe Israel).

Not maybe. Israel is the whole reason the USA is losing its mind (and its war) in Iran right now.

Re: War Crimes Seem to Be Official US Policy Now

#25

This thread will get flagged and disappear, probably because at least someone in HN leadership realises just how bad this reflects on the USA and its people. But people in the USA should realise this: An entire generation is growing up now, who hate, dislike or at least distrust the USA. Where I have the feeling the US will come to its senses, eventually, hopefully; my children tell me that they and all their classma…

"An entire generation is growing up now, who hate, dislike or at least distrust the USA."

Same as it always was.

Re: War Crimes Seem to Be Official US Policy Now

#26

This thread will get flagged and disappear, probably because at least someone in HN leadership realises just how bad this reflects on the USA and its people. But people in the USA should realise this: An entire generation is growing up now, who hate, dislike or at least distrust the USA. Where I have the feeling the US will come to its senses, eventually, hopefully; my children tell me that they and all their classma…

You were correct, it got flagged. Personally I held the belief that people shat too much on the USA, then the current regime started and I feel a fool.

Re: War Crimes Seem to Be Official US Policy Now

#27
If I am not mistaken, it is not a war crime as per the Geneva Convention. It could be a war crime under Additional Protocol I (1977) or the Rome Statute (1998) but the US hasn't ratified these. It clearly is a last choice reaction by the US, and it's better than the alternative of carpet bombing.

Tell me, why is it legal for Iran to bomb oil tankers of other countries?

Re: War Crimes Seem to Be Official US Policy Now

#29

This thread will get flagged and disappear, probably because at least someone in HN leadership realises just how bad this reflects on the USA and its people. But people in the USA should realise this: An entire generation is growing up now, who hate, dislike or at least distrust the USA. Where I have the feeling the US will come to its senses, eventually, hopefully; my children tell me that they and all their classma…

"An entire generation is growing up now, who hate, dislike or at least distrust the USA." Same as it always was.

[deleted]
Post reply on HN