Live data from Hacker News

It Will Never Be the Year of the Linux Desktop

unix.foo

21–30 of 79 posts

Re: It Will Never Be the Year of the Linux Desktop

#22

I've always interpreted "Year of the Linux Desktop" as a personal journey, like Hot Girl Summer. It's not about the year that there's a watershed and suddenly everyone is rolling custom distros, it's about an individual's journey with discovering and trying Linux. Every year can be the year of the Linux desktop if you believe!

The year of the linux Desktop was the friends we made along the way... fixing our Linux desktop.

Re: It Will Never Be the Year of the Linux Desktop

#24
post #3

I wish somebody would make a Polymarket bet out of this. I'm 100% with the author on this one

I’d take the other side of that bet if i didn’t think gambling was a cancer

Good thing health insurance is so cheap where I live. I really don't mind risking a little cancer for a good bet

Re: It Will Never Be the Year of the Linux Desktop

#28
> If you use a Mac and open the Accessibility Inspector tool that’s built into the system (you really should try it), you can see a second version of the computer, hiding inside the first one. The first version is the one you look at: windows, shadows, rounded rectangles, a little bouncing icon in the Dock from Slack announcing that you are falling behind.

Now use that Accessibility Inspector tool inside Slack (an Electron App) and you'll be welcomed to a deeply nested tree of unlabelled objects.

Re: It Will Never Be the Year of the Linux Desktop

#29
The thing is: it already is the year of the Linux Desktop for me. I don't care about 'OS market share' or how many people use something; I have no control over them.

I also don't care about "OS-maxxing", either--quibbling over 'Wayland', or which OS has the best window manager, arguing about 'gaming', etc.

What I do care about? Freedom and control. Linux gives me that.

So my desktop? It's Linux. The Year of Linux on the Desktop arrived for me years ago. And it can be that year for anyone, anytime. Today.

Re: It Will Never Be the Year of the Linux Desktop

#30
Interesting explanation of a subject I had no knowledge of! I'm familiar with browser accessibility trees, but I've never thought about how operating systems do it themselves.

From the outside view, I still wouldn't make any bets with 100% certainty about the future of anything to do with computers.

If you grant that there is some chance that the trends of programming models' capabilities will continue for another few years, then there is some chance that software and its bottlenecks will be completely transformed. A rapidly overhauled accessibility tree for linux? A good-enough computer use model that doesn't require accessibility trees at all? A world of bespoke, personalized operating systems? All of these things (and many more) seem like outcomes with non-zero probabilities.

Post reply on HN