Live data from Hacker News

Liberated Systemd

github.com

21–30 of 77 posts

Re: Liberated Systemd

#21
As i get old i get more and more annoyed and this useless armchair activism.

This piece of software is useless and cannot be employed anywhere and it’s essentially a futile exercise in virtue-signalling.

The problem is not technical, it’s political.

Go and make some actual political activism, don’t shit out useless software.

Re: Liberated Systemd

#22
post #21

As i get old i get more and more annoyed and this useless armchair activism. This piece of software is useless and cannot be employed anywhere and it’s essentially a futile exercise in virtue-signalling. The problem is not technical, it’s political. Go and make some actual political activism, don’t shit out useless software.

But shitting out useless software is what we do here!

Re: Liberated Systemd

#23
post #9

Why are people worried about age bracket category (optional, defaults to "over 18") but they're not worried about remote attestation (will be mandatory to view any website)?

They are.

I think this is the main reason why sane people are revolting against age groups, because mandatory KYC to use a locked-down Linux begins exactly with that: a small integer field in userdb.

Re: Liberated Systemd

#24
post #21

As i get old i get more and more annoyed and this useless armchair activism. This piece of software is useless and cannot be employed anywhere and it’s essentially a futile exercise in virtue-signalling. The problem is not technical, it’s political. Go and make some actual political activism, don’t shit out useless software.

But shitting out useless software is what we do here!

Fair point.

Re: Liberated Systemd

#25
post #19

Here is the changes: https://github.com/systemd/systemd/commit/71ad73569d9a5e2588...

Wow. Literally right next to the birthday field, which is apparently a gateway to mass surveillance, is physical location, which is apparently not?

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gecos_field

Re: Liberated Systemd

#26
post #18

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I believe Debian doesn't ask for a e-mail address on installation, but the username is obviously necessary if you're going to login. I leave "Users full name" empty and it's fine. The e-mail address also has a use, for important notifications. There are cases where the OS tries to send an email. But as I mentioned, I don't even know where to set it I've never been prompted and if I was I would leave it empty.

Any app that has access to your age category has access to your home directory where much juicier things live. Probably including your email address, and all your passwords.

I'm a little special and use a hack so I don't even have to provide my e-mail address on git commits to prevent leaking it in my git history. So probably not in my case, but I understand your concern and a lot can be done to improve OS privacy. But "they already know what you eat for breakfast" is not a valid argument to reduce privacy further.

Re: Liberated Systemd

#27
This project everyone is laughing at actually accomplished what was probably it's only goal. I was alerted to proof of systemd's priorities. I mean I already knew but nothing beats a good solid action when it comes to trying to say it to anyone else.

Re: Liberated Systemd

#28
So this looks like a spite fork intended to make a point, not likely to become a widely used fork of systemd.

However, 1) he is right, and 2) systemd's recent full-throated embrace of AI for programming make it clear that systemd really is in dire need of a fork. This project has gone full corporate insanity.

I was never one of the vocal anti-systemd folks (I think it's a huge improvement over SysV-style boot stuff), but the risk of this project was always the monoculture aspect. It's on approximately every Linux install, and it's going bad FAST.

Re: Liberated Systemd

#29
Just move to a non-systemd distro and disable this madness.

I am kind of hoping systemd succeeds in adding age validation. That will probably enable distros like Slackware to fly under the radar. My only worry is Firefox, Chrome will be changed to expect this systemd validation.

Re: Liberated Systemd

#30
post #21

As i get old i get more and more annoyed and this useless armchair activism. This piece of software is useless and cannot be employed anywhere and it’s essentially a futile exercise in virtue-signalling. The problem is not technical, it’s political. Go and make some actual political activism, don’t shit out useless software.

This particular project is making a small political point, that this attempt at regulation of FOSS is useless and easily circumvented. The impact is proportional to the effort (small) but it’s not useless any more than running an ad would be.

Ageless Linux is a similar project, but with a larger possible impact, as it has the potential to serve as a test case for overturning the law. By directly and flagrantly violating the law, it serves as a magnet for prosecution.

Post reply on HN