Hacker News Board Hacker News, browsed like a classic message board
Live data from Hacker News

Which jobs are most vulnerable to AI?

washingtonpost.com

Post reply on HN
Print view View original

21–30 of 30 posts

Re: Which jobs are most vulnerable to AI?

#21

Post by abu_ameena »

kjkjadksj wrote: post #19
abu_ameena wrote: post #18

Earlier quoted context omitted.

If we are talking about jobs (quantity) maybe to some extent. But if want to be honest, it’s qualitative (human-judgment) question. And even if a job seems totally AI-ready on paper, it might have invisible side effects. (Thought experiment: do I want an AI robot to perform a surgery on me, if it only has 2% chance of hallucinating? My answer is no, bring the surgeon)

I wonder if we will see some perverse incentives emerge to make the AI seem even better. For example, say a well rested, stress free surgeon can have a 1% error rate. Well, lets make the job harder then, fatigue the surgeon, lay many of them off (or just not rehire as they leave) and spread the remainder thin. Make them hit 3% error rate. Then fire the lot because it would be malpractice not to.

If that’s the dystopia we would live in, I’d imagine an alternate healthcare/legal system would emerge. Also, personally I’m far more forgiving of the human-error than that of the machine

Re: Which jobs are most vulnerable to AI?

#24

Post by kschaul »

Author here. The new contribution of the research[0] this article visualizes is a measure of the adaptability of workers across different occupations, should they be displaced by AI.

> But there’s another dimension to the picture. Some workers will find it easier to adapt, the researchers argue, based on factors like their savings, age and transferrable skills.

> Most web designers will be fine. Many secretaries will not. The most vulnerable occupations are largely held by women.

[0]: https://www.brookings.edu/articles/measuring-us-workers-capa...

Re: Which jobs are most vulnerable to AI?

#25

Post by boshalfoshal »

Answer: Any job where the majority (or all) of your work can be done strictly by using a computer, and for tasks that have easily verifiable and objective outcomes. And from an economic perspective, jobs that have the highest cost (i.e, highest margins for AI companies to replace) have a strong economic incentive to be automated first. So Software, Finance, Accounting, Law, etc.

Yes - this means software engineers are likely the first to go, along with other high paying computer jobs.

Re: Which jobs are most vulnerable to AI?

#26

Post by deterministic »

boshalfoshal wrote: post #25

Answer: Any job where the majority (or all) of your work can be done strictly by using a computer, and for tasks that have easily verifiable and objective outcomes. And from an economic perspective, jobs that have the highest cost (i.e, highest margins for AI companies to replace) have a strong economic incentive to be automated first. So Software, Finance, Accounting, Law, etc. Yes - this means software engineers ar…

> this means software engineers are likely the first to go

Nope. Grab a random person off the street and ask them to write Enterprise software using an AI. Good luck with that.

The job will change but it still requires a lot of deep knowledge about software development to be effective with AI.

Re: Which jobs are most vulnerable to AI?

#27

Post by j3k3 »

boshalfoshal wrote: post #25

Answer: Any job where the majority (or all) of your work can be done strictly by using a computer, and for tasks that have easily verifiable and objective outcomes. And from an economic perspective, jobs that have the highest cost (i.e, highest margins for AI companies to replace) have a strong economic incentive to be automated first. So Software, Finance, Accounting, Law, etc. Yes - this means software engineers ar…

One thing that irks me about this place is the great-confidence people make claims, when they have zero idea about stuff outside of their domain.

I know ten people who work across Accounting and Finance in high-level positions who have all told me that in the past few months, the LLM-steam has wore off and they aren't seeing any material benefits.

Re: Which jobs are most vulnerable to AI?

#28

Post by jmathai »

abu_ameena wrote: post #18
jmathai wrote: post #7

Earlier quoted context omitted.

In practice, is AI incapable of performing human-judgement ... at the levels most humans do?

If we are talking about jobs (quantity) maybe to some extent. But if want to be honest, it’s qualitative (human-judgment) question. And even if a job seems totally AI-ready on paper, it might have invisible side effects. (Thought experiment: do I want an AI robot to perform a surgery on me, if it only has 2% chance of hallucinating? My answer is no, bring the surgeon)

> if it only has 2% chance of hallucinating

I want people to have jobs.

Setting that aside, it is dependent on error rate of human surgeons, right?

Re: Which jobs are most vulnerable to AI?

#29

Post by kjkjadksj »

abu_ameena wrote: post #21
kjkjadksj wrote: post #19

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I wonder if we will see some perverse incentives emerge to make the AI seem even better. For example, say a well rested, stress free surgeon can have a 1% error rate. Well, lets make the job harder then, fatigue the surgeon, lay many of them off (or just not rehire as they leave) and spread the remainder thin. Make them hit 3% error rate. Then fire the lot because it would be malpractice not to.

If that’s the dystopia we would live in, I’d imagine an alternate healthcare/legal system would emerge. Also, personally I’m far more forgiving of the human-error than that of the machine

For the musk class maybe. But for you and I?

Re: Which jobs are most vulnerable to AI?

#30

Post by j45 »

iammjm wrote: post #6
j45 wrote: post #3

I feel this article knows nothing about AI robots that can clean how a Janitor does. In any event adoption of tech can take time as hard as it might be to believe. It might not take 40 years for factories to adopt electricity when it comes to AI.

"AI robots that can clean how a Janitor does" I am yet to see a robot that could clean my bathroom. And I have a pretty basic bathroom: a toilet, a shower, a bathtub, a sink, a mirror, some shelves, laundry baskets, a washing machine, a window, a door, a floor. How would you design a robot that can clean all of those?

I appreciate that you are taking the Janitor example quite literally.

From a jobs to be done perspective of any housekeeping task, there is a lot more progress in the past year than I realized. I thought the same until it was shared with me.

https://www.figure.ai/

There are others as well, quite a few out of China.

2 weeks ago: robot on the line in BMW production https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=B2uPkPLijgs

Post reply on HN