Live data from Hacker News

WebMCP is available for early preview

developer.chrome.com

21–30 of 226 posts

Re: WebMCP is available for early preview

#21
post #8

Earlier quoted context omitted.

In my opinion sites that want agent access should expose server-side MCP, server owns the tools, no browser middleman. Already works today. Sites that don’t want it will keep blocking. WebMCP doesn’t change that. Your point about selenium is absolutely right. WebMCP is an unnecessary standard. Same developer effort as server-side MCP but routed through the browser, creating a copy that drifts from the actual UI. For…

So... an API? Most sites don't want to expose APIs or care enough about setup and maintenance of said API.

Are you asking if Agents should use API?

Re: WebMCP is available for early preview

#22

Can someone explain what the hell is going on here? Do websites want to prevent automated tooling, as indicated by everyone putting everything behind Cloudfare and CAPTCHAs since forever, or do websites want you to be able to automate things? Because I don't see how you can have both. If I'm using Selenium it's a problem, but if I'm using Claude it's fine??

Why should a browser care about how websites want you to use them?

Re: WebMCP is available for early preview

#23

>Users could more easily get the exact flights they want Can we stop pretending this is an issue anyone has ever had.

Well I have had the problem of "I want to find the cheapest flight that leaves during this range of dates, and returns during this range of dates, but isn't early in the morning or late at night, and includes additional fees for the luggage I need in the price comparison" and current search tools can't do that very well. I'm not very optimistic WebMCP would solve that though.

Re: WebMCP is available for early preview

#24
post #4

>Users could more easily get the exact flights they want Can we stop pretending this is an issue anyone has ever had.

I want my local dm shop to offer me their product info as copyable markdown, ingredient list, and other health related information. This could be a way to automate it.

Why would you want that over a proper API with structured data?

Re: WebMCP is available for early preview

#27
post #20

Can someone explain what the hell is going on here? Do websites want to prevent automated tooling, as indicated by everyone putting everything behind Cloudfare and CAPTCHAs since forever, or do websites want you to be able to automate things? Because I don't see how you can have both. If I'm using Selenium it's a problem, but if I'm using Claude it's fine??

i’m seeing this at my corporate software job now. that service that you used to have security and product approval for to even read their Swagger doc has an MCP server you can install with 2 clicks.

Sometimes, it gets added there without your consent.

Re: WebMCP is available for early preview

#28
Hey, it's the semantic web, but with ~~XML~~, ~~AJAX~~, ~~Blockchain~~, Ai!

Well, it has precisely the problem of the semantic web, it asks the website to declare in a machine readable format what the website does. Now, llms are kinda the tool to interface to everybody using a somewhat different standard, and this doesn't need everybody to hop on the bandwagon, so perhaps this is the time where it is different.

Re: WebMCP is available for early preview

#29
post #23

>Users could more easily get the exact flights they want Can we stop pretending this is an issue anyone has ever had.

Well I have had the problem of "I want to find the cheapest flight that leaves during this range of dates, and returns during this range of dates, but isn't early in the morning or late at night, and includes additional fees for the luggage I need in the price comparison" and current search tools can't do that very well. I'm not very optimistic WebMCP would solve that though.

matrix.ita does this very well, and has been doing so for nearly 3 decades.

Re: WebMCP is available for early preview

#30

Can someone explain what the hell is going on here? Do websites want to prevent automated tooling, as indicated by everyone putting everything behind Cloudfare and CAPTCHAs since forever, or do websites want you to be able to automate things? Because I don't see how you can have both. If I'm using Selenium it's a problem, but if I'm using Claude it's fine??

These are obviously different people you're talking about here
Post reply on HN