Live data from Hacker News

President Trump Announces New Trump Class Battleship

navy.mil

21–22 of 22 posts

Re: President Trump Announces New Trump Class Battleship

#21
post #4

I thought the BB class was no longer relevant in today's modern, missile and drone oriented naval battle fields?

Yes-ish. In a serious fight against a peer-ish level adversary, the RoI on such a ship looks very dubious. But short of that, a huge warship can have great prestige & intimidation value - assuming that it is competently designed, and built, and outfitted, and operated. Naval history is swarming with only-on-paper designs for big warships. And a fair number of real-steel warships which were cripples, glass cannons, or…

I stand corrected, my memory recalled the old star fleet battles BB class(!)

Re: President Trump Announces New Trump Class Battleship

#22

At first glance this seems crazy. But what a battleship with a gun so powerful, that it can shoot down everything. Having a nuclear powered vessel that can shoot a railgun and laser might be battleship in size

A new surface vehicle for naval warfare is absolutely bonkers in the modern era. Even in the littoral space where notionally you don't have the depth for a sub-surface launcher, the LCS project was a complete bust. For anything in deep water, a submarine platform is so much more useful for projecting force and not a sitting duck.

Having a missile boat which can cross the pacific without an oiler is a must if we want to bring anything to the pacific.
Post reply on HN